PDA

View Full Version : Royalists Want Monarchy To Return To France



Groenewolf
01-28-2010, 02:04 PM
NPR (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=123012611)


Even though France has been a republic for more than 200 years, there are many people in France who would like to see the return of the King. Royalists believe that one day they will be able to convince the French to restore the monarchy.

Copyright © 2010 National Public Radio®. For personal, noncommercial use only. See Terms of Use. For other uses, prior permission required.

STEVE INSKEEP, host:

Every January the Royalists of France, or is it that the Royalists de France, gather to mark the date when King Louis XVI was beheaded. His death marked the beginning of the French Republic. Yet many who remember the kings death hope that France will some day restore the monarchy.

Eleanor Beardsley sends this report.

(Soundbite of music)

ELEANOR BEARDSLEY: Organ music thunders through the stone cavernous basilica of Saint Denis on the northern outskirts of Paris. More than 800 people have gathered here, not just to pay homage to King Louis XVI, but to mourn the death of the French monarchy. Saint Denis is the necropolis of the French royal family. More than 50 monarchs, including Louis XVI and his queen, Marie Antoinette, are buried here.

Unidentified Man #1: (Latin spoken)

BEARDSLEY: The mass is in Latin. The priest swings a censer of incense on a chain. The somber service in this stone-cold Seventh century church resonates with regret for a France that lived 16 centuries in the Catholic monarchy. The priest describes the day it all came to an end when Louis XVI was led to the guillotine.

Unidentified Man #2: (French spoken)

BEARDSLEY: They came at night with their torches and clubs, he says, to carry out the most abominable of sacrileges. Harold Hyman, a long time journalist who takes a special interest in the French Royalists, says the group has no chance of bringing back the monarchy.

Mr. HAROLD HYMAN (Franco-American Journalist): So they take this weird political posture - a sort of anti-progress protest against the modern world and mass culture and television and American influence, and this is, I think, what unites them all.

BEARDSLEY: Royalists say the French Revolution was ruthless, not glorious, and that Louis XVI was a progressive king with vision. After all, he did send his general, the Marquis de Lafayette, to help some unruly colonists throw off their British oppressors. Retiree Marie-Noelle Erre(ph) explains why shes a monarchist.

Ms. MARIE-NOELLE ERRE (Royalist): Its the monarchy that built the country. If it hadnt been for the revolution, there would have been an evolution with time. Beside that, King Louis XVI was a very good king.

BEARDSLEY: The Royalists are deeply divided over who is the legitimate successor to the French throne. But that question is not pertinent, for now anyway, says Dominique Emele(ph), the director of the Alliance Royale, the monarchist political party. The Royalists have practically no political support and no members in parliament, but Emele believes that one day the Party will be able to convince the French to restore a constitutional monarchy.

Mr. DOMINIQUE EMELE (Alliance Royale): (Through translator) One of the biggest problems in France today is that our president is the head of a political party. So he doesnt represent all the French. Only a king can truly represent the people, unify the nation, and solve the long-term problems of France.

(Soundbite of music)

BEARDSLEY: Back at the Basilica of Saint Denis, the mass closes with a requiem. The church where Joan of Arc once prayed now lies in the middle of a gritty immigrant suburb. Sixty five-year-old Michel Simoneaux(ph) emerges from the 18th century atmosphere inside the Basilica and comes face to face with modern day France.

Mr. MICHEL SIMONEAUX: (French spoken)

BEARDSLEY: The revolution was a cataclysm from which France will never recover, Simoneaux says. Everything we admire is from before the revolution. Just look at this marvelous cathedral, and look at this town. Its the symbol of everything France has become.

For NPR News, Im Eleanor Beardsley in Paris.

Wulfhere
01-28-2010, 03:43 PM
"Royalists Want Monarchy To Return To France"

Well, they would do, wouldn't they.

"there are many people in France who would like to see the return of the King"

Why can't they just rent it on DVD?

Murphy
01-28-2010, 03:54 PM
I am glad to see that France is not at all completely lost as I thought it to be.

Vive Le Roi!

Regards,
The Papist.

Liffrea
01-28-2010, 03:59 PM
They can have ours.;)

The Lawspeaker
01-28-2010, 04:00 PM
They can have own Crown Prince... hell.. while we are at it: let's throw in the Queen as well (for free).

Loddfafner
01-28-2010, 04:41 PM
France a republic for over 200 years? What of the late Bourbons, the house of Orleans, and Napoleons 1 and III?

Wulfhere
01-28-2010, 04:47 PM
France a republic for over 200 years? What of the late Bourbons, the house of Orleans, and Napoleons 1 and III?

They all still have official claimants. Unlike, say, the Merovingians.

Aemma
01-28-2010, 05:07 PM
Bring on the French monarchy I say! Let those bastard republicans get a taste of their own medicine and restore France to its once glorious state. :D

Nationalitist
01-28-2010, 05:33 PM
Restorationist nostalgia is much better than "new right" and "identitarianism".

Poltergeist
02-04-2010, 04:24 PM
Is the contrary faction already erecting a guillotine?

The Lawspeaker
02-04-2010, 04:27 PM
Is the contrary faction already erecting a guillotine?I hope they are dusting it off by now. :)

http://images.volkskrant.com/weblog/www/pub/mm/tempest/3159/Image/guillotine.gif

Svipdag
02-04-2010, 04:53 PM
A monarch is a professional. He/she has trained all his/her life for the office, unlike some peanut farmer or small-time politician whom a political party has chosen to seek the highest office in the land.

The only advantage a president has is that, if he prove unfit for the office, he can be got rid of in a few years.

In order for the professionalism of a well-qualified monarch to be of any real benefit to the country, however, he/she must be more than a figurehead. To be effective, the monarch must have some real authority.

This must be specified in the constitution, and there must be a legal non-violent procedure for forcing the abdication of an incompetent, corrupt, or malevolent ruler.

France has fared so badly under a succession of short-lived democratic regimes that, surely, she would be, at worst, no worse off under a competent benevolent monarch.

asulf
02-05-2010, 10:02 AM
We French have had time to reflect on our history for 200 years.

revolution starting in the salons of the Marquise de Pompadour, was carried by a humanistic ideals make sense of comfort to the people of France (and to include good and gentry of the province close to the people) who lived in a diametrically opposite to the aristocratic nobility, who sat at Versailles is concern over their interests and concerns to please at any cost to the monarch, as the state of France and its people, is losing its quality of nobility to access than courting.

Here compiled by yours truly amber table decor, breeding ground for germs revolutionary.
It is suffering ....... hunger, exacerbated to prefer to die quickly fighting slowly of starvation that triggered the event.
A sentence passed in the story is this: Lord, hear the anger of people who are hungry ...
Louis 16 would have responded: the people are hungry? he eats!

The sequence of events you know, the nobility and clergy, was swept by the fury of the people releasing the chains of slavery in disguise.
and made the abuses took place.
Fanatics instaurèrent terror, tore intestine struggles of the people.
Although nowadays the system is far from perfect, I grant you the lack of direct democracy is the people are not listening.

I am not revolutionary I take my blue blood heritage.
But see these degenerate Bourbons of France and behavior aristocratic, disdainful arrogant very aware of the dinner parties for the jet set, or they find, crumbs of what was a certain grandeur decadent, I bristle hair.
Not one of her suitors to the throne of France, is not concerned with France.
Not a charitable or foundation to their credit, nothing but arrogance and vanity.
These are just skins inflated with air, devoid of the substance of the charge, which was a time the magnitude of the nobility of France.
For what was the size of France, we always pay French today
resentment and jealousy of our neighbors. who grow blithely anti French feeling ......
Sorry d be here a representative of the French people who has to his credit the discovery of half the known lands on the globe, and fourth claims of scientific discovery, and this, in all areas.
When to put a puppet on a throne ........ we will never do them this gift
Do not dream, but rather a caliphate which we hang the nose at all................

asulf
02-05-2010, 11:29 AM
En Français pour ceux qui préfèrent; et de surcroit ,cela ne dénature point le fil de ma pensé

Nous autres Français, avons eu loisir de méditer sur notre histoire depuis 200ans .

la révolution au départ dans les salons de la marquise de Pompadour ,était portée par un idéal humaniste sensé apporter du réconfort au peuple de France (et la englobe la bonne et petite noblesse de province proche du peuple ) qui vivait de façon diamétralement opposée, à la grande noblesse aristocratique ,qui siégeait à Versaille se préoccupant plus de leurs intérêt et du soucis de plaire à tout prix au monarque ,que de l état de la France et de son peuple, perdant de fait sa qualité de noblesse pour accéder à celle de courtisant.

voici dressé par votre serviteur le tableau succin du décor, terreau du germe révolutionnaire?
C'est la souffrance ....... de la faim, portée au paroxysme au point de préférer mourir rapidement en luttant que lentement de faim qui déclencha les événements .
Une phrase à traversé l histoire la voici : Sire,écoutez la colère du peuple qui a faim...
Louis 16 aurais rétorqué :le peuple a faim ? qu'il mange !!!

La suite des évènements vous la connaissez ,la noblesse et le clergé ,fut balayé par la fureur du peuple se libérant des chaînes d'un esclavage déguisé.
et de fait les exactions eurent lieu.
Des fanatiques instaurèrent la terreur,des lutes intestines déchirèrent le peuple.
Certes de nos jours le système est loin d être parfait,je vous l accorde un manque de démocratie directe existe le peuple est pas écouté.

Je ne suis pas révolutionnaire j'assume mon héritage de sang bleu .
Mais voir ces dégénérés de Bourbons de France et leur comportement aristocratique,dédaigneux arrogant très au fait des dîners mondains de la jet set, ou ,ils retrouvent,miettes de ce que fut une certaine grandeur décadente ,me hérisse le poil .
Pas un de ses prétendants au trône de France, ne se préoccupe de la France .
Pas une action caritative ,ni fondation à leur crédit,rien que de la morgue et de la vanité.
Ce ne sont que des outres gonflées par l'air ,vidée de la substance de la charge ,qui fit un temps la grandeur de la noblesse de France.
Pour ce qui fut de la grandeur de la France, nous français payons toujours de nos jours
la rancoeur et la jalousie de nos voisins. qui cultivent allégrement ce sentiment anti français......
Désolé d être ici un des représentant du peuple Français qui ,a à son actif la découverte de la moitié des terres connues sur le globe ,et revendique un quart des découvertes scientifiques ,et ce, dans tous les domaines.
Quand à mettre un pantin sur un trône........nous ne leur ferons jamais cadeau de cela
Ne rêvez pas ,c'est plutôt un Califat qui nous pends au nez,à tous.