Distribution of Y-chromosome DNA (Y-DNA) haplogroups of ethnic Macedonians

[Dianatomia]

Ethnic Macedonians vs Northern Greeks;



Attachment 61644

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-DNA_...y_ethnic_group

Seems that Pontian refugees have increased the frequency of E1b1b in Northern Greece (Greek Macedonia) making it higher than amongst ethnic Macedonians from R. Macedonia

It would be interesting to see that Pontian Greeks have such high doses of E-V13 so as to increase the E-V13 in Greek Macedonia. If they were to increase the E-V13 by 11%, Greek refugees must have almost had 50% of E-V13. This would be an absolute record in the Balkans.

Also haplogroup I in Macedonian Slavs is 34,2% vs 12,5% in Northern Greece. These are enormous differences given that they are direct neighbors. It would seem that haplogroup I is either Slavic or Illyrian.

[poiuytrewq0987]

It would be interesting to see that Pontian Greeks have such high doses of E-V13 so as to increase the E-V13 in Greek Macedonia. If they were to increase the E-V13 by 11%, Greek refugees must have almost had 50% of E-V13. This would be an absolute record in the Balkans.

Also haplogroup I in Macedonian Slavs is 34,2% vs 12,5% in Northern Greece. These are enormous differences given that they are direct neighbors. It would seem that haplogroup I is either Slavic or Illyrian.

I2 is more likely Slavic than not given how it's even present in the Slavic homeland in high percentages. It's also a commonly known fact that the Bosnians score very high Eastern European than not which means it is a Slavic haplogroup, not Illyrian.

[poiuytrewq0987]

[Rethel]

I2 is more likely Slavic than not given how it's even present in the Slavic homeland in high percentages. It's also a commonly known fact that the Bosnians score very high Eastern European than not which means it is a Slavic haplogroup, not Illyrian.

I2 is neither "Slavic" neither "Illyrian" becasue is not IE.

[wvwvw]

I2 is more likely Slavic than not given how it's even present in the Slavic homeland in high percentages. It's also a commonly known fact that the Bosnians score very high Eastern European than not which means it is a Slavic haplogroup, not Illyrian.

I is Germanic, native Balkan but originated in the middle east. R1a is Slavic and evolved in Asia.

[poiuytrewq0987]

I2 is neither "Slavic" neither "Illyrian" becasue is not IE.

Indo-European is a linguistic grouping, NOT genetic. Slavic is also a linguistic grouping, not genetic. However, it IS possible to determine the origin of I2 which seems to have several different origins, at least three. One Slavic-Pripyat Marshlands, one Sardinian-West Mediterranean, one Iranic-Kurdish. ALL IE speakers, if that's so important to you.

The Slavs descend from not only one paternal lineage but several. R1a and I2a are the primary lineages, but there were most likely other minor lineages too. If you can name me an ethnic group that descends from a single paternal lineage then go ahead and do it. You'll only discover the futility of that.

For example, I am E-V13 yet I can't find Albanian relatives with my Y-DNA data. Only Slavic ones, I matched with a Pole and two Slovenians the best while lesser matches were some Italian matches.

[poiuytrewq0987]

I is Germanic, native Balkan but originated in the middle east. R1a is Slavic and evolved in Asia.

I is not Germanic, silly. It had a single core population that originated somewhere in MENA-Asia. This origin population migrated to Europe through Central Asia over the centuries. Eventually, this group arrived in what is today's Belarus and Ukraine, and another group broke off and continued on to Scandinavia. Hence, the separation of I into I1 and I2. I1 IS Germanic, but I2 is not.

[Rethel]

For example, I am E-V13 yet I can't find Albanian relatives with my Y-DNA data. Only Slavic ones, I matched with a Pole and two Slovenians the best while lesser matches were some Italian matches.

Look deeper into past

[Rethel]

The Slavs descend from not only one paternal lineage but several. R1a and I2a are the primary lineages, but there were most likely other minor lineages too. If you can name me an ethnic group that descends from a single paternal lineage then go ahead and do it. You'll only discover the futility of that.

If you do not see corealtion, you are blind and deaf.

Btw, much more silly and idiotic are all these balkanian shit disscussions.

[poiuytrewq0987]

If you do not see corealtion, you are blind and deaf.

I am not psychic and cannot read into your posts aside the insults.