US Presidential Candidate Suggests Palestinian State Should Be Created In Sinai

[Wadaad]

Its just a bantustan..the herero were told they could have a 'homeland' in the Kalahari desert aswell and when they refused they got massacred. Or the trail of tears. When they ship you off to the deserts, it is time for you to die with dignity or live like the wretched red indians of the American reservations out in the desert.

95% Palestinians were peasants that cultivated figs, olive groves, etc...the rest being urban town dwellers. Only a small minority were bedouin desert descent. This is just genocide in another name, in the past, only 'exiled' people and crazy gnostic monks lived in the barren wastelands of the Sinai. If Palestinians accept this, they should just swallow cyanide and acknowledge defeat and not impose themselves on the native EGYPTIAN sinai bedouins.

[Maleficent]

So are you a full fledged zionist now? You're ok with being the 'african americans' of Israel, because that's what Israeli arabs are, they're pre-civil rights Black American '2nd class citizens'. You're gonna look down on Palestinians the way Aframs look down on Black Africans?

Lol come back when you don't have screws loose.

First of all, last time I checked Black African immigrants in USA are the ones looking down on Aframs, when they are the ones whose ancestors sold the ancestors of Aframs into slavery to "the White man". Aframs can't win for losing with Nigerians and such, IMO.

Second of all, don't you ever forget that my family is not Palestinian in the same way Assyrians are not Iraqi-Arabs. Native minority communities should not be marginalized with majority muslim invaders. I'm gonna stop now, you already know where I'm going with this.

[Wadaad]

Lol come back when you don't have screws loose.

First of all, last time I checked Black African immigrants in USA are the ones looking down on Aframs, when they are the ones whose ancestors sold the ancestors of Aframs into slavery to "the White man". Aframs can't win for losing with Nigerians and such, IMO.

Second of all, don't you ever forget that my family is not Palestinian in the same way Assyrians are not Iraqi-Arabs. Native minority communities should not be marginalized with majority muslim invaders. I'm gonna stop now, you already know where I'm going with this.

forget the Muslim thing for a second. The PLO had nothing to do with Islam. btw...Muslims are "Abdullah" not Abdul-zion.

Are you a zionist or not?

[zhaoyun]

Lol come back when you don't have screws loose.

First of all, last time I checked Black African immigrants in USA are the ones looking down on Aframs, when they are the ones whose ancestors sold the ancestors of Aframs into slavery to "the White man". Aframs can't win for losing with Nigerians and such, IMO.

Second of all, don't you ever forget that my family is not Palestinian in the same way Assyrians are not Iraqi-Arabs. Native minority communities should not be marginalized with majority muslim invaders. I'm gonna stop now, you already know where I'm going with this.

Most Palestinian Christians have historically been against Zionism as well. Though many probably are not happy with the recent Islamist turn in Palestinian nationalism during the past 20 years or so. But it doesn't change the fact that the majority of Palestinian Christians are against Zionist, which makes sense, because they lost out as much as the Muslims did.

[Maleficent]

For the record, my Bible quote was a sarcastic comment. Ben Carson is somewhere near my top contenders(I'm gunning for Rand Paul and will vote for Hillary if I don't like whoever wins the Republican Primary), but it's clear he doesn't understand completely the Mideast situation. He's good for America, but not for foreign policy.

[StonyArabia]

Lol come back when you don't have screws loose.

First of all, last time I checked Black African immigrants in USA are the ones looking down on Aframs, when they are the ones whose ancestors sold the ancestors of Aframs into slavery to "the White man". Aframs can't win for losing with Nigerians and such, IMO.

Second of all, don't you ever forget that my family is not Palestinian in the same way Assyrians are not Iraqi-Arabs. Native minority communities should not be marginalized with majority muslim invaders. I'm gonna stop now, you already know where I'm going with this.

Palestinian Muslims and Palestinian Christians are largely the same with minor differences. However we have a real genetic difference with Assyrians, being mostly of Arabian Bedouin stock. There is very little similarity between Iraqi Arabs and Assyrians. Iraqi Arabs are tribal and many of the tribes trace their origins to various area of Arabia. Many of these tribes often moved with their women and children, and this why our mtDNA also is very different from that of Assyrians. Yet Palestinian Muslims have the same mtDNA as the Christian and Samaritian and especially the Samaritans. Have you seen Gilgemesh genetic results he does not differ at all from the other "Levantines" he is Muslim. The comparison is not really the same.

[zhaoyun]

Palestinian Muslims and Palestinian Christians are largely the same with minor differences. However we have a real genetic difference with Assyrians, being mostly of Arabian Bedouin stock. There is very little similarity between Iraqi Arabs and Assyrians. Iraqi Arabs are tribal and many of the tribes trace their origins to various area of Arabia. Many of these tribes often moved with their women and children, and this why our mtDNA also is very different from that of Assyrians. Yet Palestinian Muslims have the same mtDNA as the Christian and Samaritian and especially the Samaritans. Have you seen Gilgemesh genetic results he does not differ at all from the other "Levantines" he is Muslim. The comparison is not really the same.

And ironically, the founder of modern Arab nationalism, Michel Aflaq, was a Greek Orthodox Syrian.

[Selurong]

The Palestinian state should be in Palestine not in Sinai.

BTW the original Hebrews had always been the Levantines, they never really left Israel and they simply changed religion with every new conqueror. They were Christian under the Byzantines and they were Muslim under the Ottoman Empire however they were still genetically Hebrew. Its horrible that the half European and half Ashkenazis of Israel who were converts to Judaism and don't have ancient ties to the land just waltz into the land and claim it as theirs to detriment of the people who have been living there for ages, the Palestinians.

The self absorbed "Chosen People", the modern fake Jews who are mostly descended from European converts to Judaism, bullying the true Hebrews, the Palestinians who simply changed religion to Islam sickens me.

[Maleficent]

forget the Muslim thing for a second. The PLO had nothing to do with Islam. btw...Muslims are "Abdullah" not Abdul-zion.

Are you a zionist or not?

Most Palestinian Christians have historically been against Zionism as well. Though many probably are not happy with the recent Islamist turn in Palestinian nationalism during the past 20 years or so. But it doesn't change the fact that the majority of Palestinian Christians are against Zionist, which makes sense, because they lost out as much as the Muslims did.

It is a correct statement indeed that the Palestinian Cause has been hijacked by Islamism for quite some time now.

Anyway....

When the Palestinian-Christians are smart enough to go away from Muslims and rid themselves of dhimmi behavior and status, and undo the process of Arabization.....they often get called "Zionist" in the process. I don't care, either way. I don't have time for that petty behavior.

[zhaoyun]

It is a correct statement indeed that the Palestinian Cause has been hijacked by Islamism for quite some time now.

Anyway....

When the Palestinian-Christians are smart enough to go away from Muslims and rid themselves of dhimmi behavior and status, and undo the process of Arabization.....they often get called "Zionist" in the process. I don't care, either way. I don't have time for that petty behavior.

Only by ignorant extremists.

It is well known that Palestinian Christians were heavily involved with modern Palestinian nationalism.