Slavic = Germanic minus certain influences?

[Dombra]

If proto-germanic never received paleo-European (and Finnic) influence, would we have ended up with something similar to Slavic? Did the Nordic melody* remove potential fiss and hisses?

*Similar accents found in both Icelandicic and Finnish and to certain extents in Swedish and Norwegian, probably of paleo-European origin

[Vorg]

As for expansion into Europe, it was carried out by the tribes who lived in the more western areas of the pit culture (c. 3300-2800 BC.). It was there that lived carriers of subclades R1b1a2a1, which occurred as well as carriers of Samara subclades R1b1a2a2, from Samara Mesolithic hunter who lived approx. 5500 BC Apparently, they, as I have already pointed out, were the first who brought to Central Europe Indo-European speech, or rather, it Italo-Celtic branch, and first created the Baden archaeological culture, and then Globular Amphora culture. A few centuries later from a different (northern?) area of ​​the Yamna culture was a new wave of migration of Indo-European tribes who spoke the language of the Balto-Slavic branch and were mostly carriers of haplogroup R1a. In the north of Central Europe, it is superimposed on the Italo-Celtic language substrate and gave rise to Germanic language.

[Äijä]

As for expansion into Europe, it was carried out by the tribes who lived in the more western areas of the pit culture (c. 3300-2800 BC.). It was there that lived carriers of subclades R1b1a2a1, which occurred as well as carriers of Samara subclades R1b1a2a2, from Samara Mesolithic hunter who lived approx. 5500 BC Apparently, they, as I have already pointed out, were the first who brought to Central Europe Indo-European speech, or rather, it Italo-Celtic branch, and first created the Baden archaeological culture, and then Globular Amphora culture. A few centuries later from a different (northern?) area of ​​the Yamna culture was a new wave of migration of Indo-European tribes who spoke the language of the Balto-Slavic branch and were mostly carriers of haplogroup R1a. In the north of Central Europe, it is superimposed on the Italo-Celtic language substrate and gave rise to Germanic language.

Good story.

[ЛыSSый]

Actually germanians now are half-blooded slavics in a reason they assimilated in 19 st slavics in western germany and in 1945-47 years a lot of germanian woman wanted and got choldren from superior race of winners. Wanna finnaly find some money and time for doing genetical test - grandfather and other relatives sayd to us that we have some unnamed half-blooded relatives from them.

[blubb]

I think this is about linguistics here?
My guess is that pre-proto-Germanic language was much closer to Italo-Celtic than Balto-Slavic because it was mainly carried by the U106 people before they brought it North where ethnogenesis happened. I'd even say modern Germanic in core is still closer to Italo-Celtic

[TheGoldenSon]

In the rakija induced opinion of my cousin, Germans are just Slavs with speech impediment, hence the term "Njemci".