Y-DNA Movement In Europe Through Ages Illustrated In Maps.

[Ülev]

British, French and other westerners are from Central Asia? I don't get it

son, look here:





more here: http://komediowo.pl/gid,16686521,img...qticaid=618b59

edit: Russians vs movie stars

[Dema]

Ditch your Sumerian theory, you are native to the Balkans like the rest of us

I just started with Sumerians, i will go thru Akkadians, Babylonians, Assyrians and who knows what else i think i got plenty of room to play with : D Ofc Sumerians are grandfathers as far as we know.

Seems that M205 is really native in Fertile Crescent -


Also by researches it is very possible that it both originated and expanded there - https://j2-m172.info/2016/10/possibl...ph1089-y22066/
Also we know we are in Balkan max 1500-1600 years, so i might have really lived thru these civilizations and get out just before Arab conquer.

Dont ruin my trip, i am in love with my hg lol

[Wrong]

I just started with Sumerians, i will go thru Akkadians, Babylonians, Assyrians and who knows what else i think i got plenty of room to play with : D Ofc Sumerians are grandfathers as far as we know.

Seems that M205 is really native in Fertile Crescent -


Also by researches it is very possible that it both originated and expanded there - https://j2-m172.info/2016/10/possibl...ph1089-y22066/
Also we know we are in Balkan max 1500-1600 years, so i might have really lived thru these civilizations and get out just before Arab conquer.

Dont ruin my trip, i am in love with my hg lol

Very pale folks before the Arabs

[Hamlet]

British, French and other westerners are from Central Asia? I don't get it

(Indo-European admixture varies pretty much as a function of R1 concentration, one example I don't understand though is the Basques being so R1b despite being indigenous pre-IE European)

[Trojet]

I would not take these maps seriously at all (have seen it all). All it is is someone guessing how Y-DNA make up looked in the past without any kind of evidence.

[Trojet]

The biggest flaw is he claims "I2a1'" was in western Balkans since 2000BC. The western Balkan I2a1 falls under the CTS10228 (Dinaric) subclade and it's heavily connected to Slavic migrations.

[Wrong]

The biggest flaw is he claims "I2a1'" was in western Balkans since 2000BC. The western Balkan I2a1 falls under the CTS10228 (Dinaric) subclade and it's heavily connected to Slavic migrations.

I would not take these maps seriously at all (have seen it all). All it is is someone guessing how Y-DNA make up looked in the past without any kind of evidence.

Agreed. My first thoughts really.

There's too much of a gap between South Slavs and Paleo-Balkanites in terms of Northeastern admixture that the only logic is the huge amount of I2a1b-Slavic clade brought southwards recently.

[XenophobicPrussian]

Useless map based on nothing done by some 400 lb guy from his New Jersey basement.

Not a single I1 found where its homeland is shown(only I1 found in a Swedish HG and a Croatian farmer), R1b/R1a were in the exact same areas and were the majority haplogroup as west as the Baltics/Ukraine, no G2a in Greece/Anatolia/Balkans 7k B, no E in the Levant(Natufians were all E), Unetice shown as R1b when nearly all Unetice were I2.

There's a giant ancient y-dna database, use it.

[Dema]

Very pale folks before the Arabs

I agree, this guy looks very pale and light skinned, i dont see any Arabic or African influence on him. They were for sure whiter then their neighbors Egyptians. I think Egyptians were in middle of white and black.

[Trojet]

Useless map based on nothing done by some 400 lb guy from his New Jersey basement.

LOL.