R1a diversity in Balkans

[Kelmendasi]

There is no Slavic cluster of I2a. Read a book.

How many times do I have to tell you the same thing over and over again? I2a-Din is a Slavic marker, you are the one that needs to read updated books and sources as your still fapping over the 2014, 2015 etc theory on I2a-Din being Illyrian lol, this theory has been debunked now

[Kelmendasi]

What?

R1b are Frankish conquerors of Gaul
R1b are Lombard conquerors of Italy

Those are Germanic peoples.

Celts were mainly R1b

[Laberia]

You are clueless.

Ottomans moved a lot of Muslim Albanians(arnaut) in South Serbia,because those places where left vacant by Serbs migating towards North.Most of northern Serbs are Medieval Kosovars,so norther Serbs are actually the most "Southern" Serbs as most of today's southern serbs migrants from central Serbia.

Do you have any document to prove that Ottomans moved Albanians in South servia? Because is well documented the ethnic cleansing of Albanians from their native lands in today South servia.

[Deymark]

How many times do I have to tell you the same thing over and over again? I2a-Din is a Slavic marker, you are the one that needs to read updated books and sources as your still fapping over the 2014, 2015 etc theory on I2a-Din being Illyrian lol, this theory has been debunked now

i2a-din is not slavic marker, there is no actual proof for this, just obsolete theories from albanians.
In balkans I2a-din is located in the mountains, while R1a in plains, so I2a-din exists before slavs, because steppe people never settle in mountains.

[Laberia]

When i read a couple of posts here, to my mind came this :

[Bosniensis]

Celts were mainly R1b

Yeah right they were... Franks have slaughtered 90% of Celtic populace in Gaul,
Saxons have slaughtered everything in Britain.

They were not nice people.

Also you have a research somewhere explained that I2 was presented in a large %
in Ancient Gaul.

[Kelmendasi]

I2a are probably Celts from Gaul who fled from Frankish occupation in 4th-5th century.
I2a is certainly Not Slavic.

Bosniaks are mixture of Illyrian-Celtic ancient tribes while Serbs are Illyrian-Thracian (Triballians).
Romans used to call us Illyrians no matter the details.

No they didn't. The Illyrian movement of South Slavs was far later and it had no genetic or cultural basis, it was all geographical and political

[IncelSlayer]

How many times do I have to tell you the same thing over and over again? I2a-Din is a Slavic marker, you are the one that needs to read updated books and sources as your still fapping over the 2014, 2015 etc theory on I2a-Din being Illyrian lol, this theory has been debunked now

>I2A-din is a slavic marker.
Were it says so?
However,theres no point arguing ,the facts are that I2 and slavic phenotypes are inversely related

[Voskos]

When i read a couple of posts here, to my mind came this :

gomar fluturon

[Laberia]

I don't think you are wrong either, could be truth. I have a little knowledge of Albanians.

Then avoid to spread BS about us in this forum.