| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 1,875 Given: 2,197 |
How? Any sources?Originally Posted by Sikeliot
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 40,069 Given: 10,740 |
Their DNA?
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 2,656 Given: 332 |
The academics think that there was a connection with Basque, or Etruscan or Minoan, or all of them, since the island apparently in remote ages was populated from different directions. It's an hystorical fact that the ancient Shardana, one of the sea peoples were the ancient Sardinians. And apparently the sea peoples were in some way related with Minoans and Etruscans.
The Basque hypothesis have also some proofs on his behalf; on the mountains of central Sardinia, where the free Nuragic tribes found shelter from the Roman invasion there are 30-40% of place names that are not in Latin or in actual Sardinian, but they make sense if compared to Basque vocabulary. There is also the DNA similarity between Sardinian and Basques, the haplogroup I2a1 - I-M26 (over 40% of Sardinian population), that in Europe can be found in such high percentages only in Sardinia, southern Corsica, Basque country, Canaries islands and Azores islands.
I2a1 - I-M26
https://i2a1tree.files.wordpress.com...1545.jpg?w=960
https://i2a1tree.files.wordpress.com...5026.jpg?w=960
Last edited by Mens-Sarda; 06-10-2017 at 07:34 AM.
Non Auro, Sed Ferro, Recuperanda Est Patria (Not by Gold, But by Iron, Is the Nation to be Recovered) - Marcus Furius Camillus (Roman General)
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 3,848 Given: 3,647 |
https://www.yfull.com/tree/I-L160/
Basque are not getting any M26 from what I seeI-Y3991PF4088/S5312/V2447 * Y3991formed 5600 ybp, TMRCA 5600 ybpinfo
https://www.familytreedna.com/public...ction=yresults
In fact theres only about 4 I haplo results for basque. Majority R1b
I2a FTDNA result summary
https://www.yfull.com/tree/I-L160/...I2a1 (I-F1915) M26+ F1915+ L247-) .................................................. .................................................. ....................4
...I2a1 (I-L247) M26+ F1915+ L247+ (Castro need L247 test)............................................. ........................................6
...I2a1 (I-L672 '19-22')M26+L672+L160- PF6947- DYS413 = 19,22............................................. .............................16
...I2a1 (I-l672 'France') M26+L672+L160- PF6947- DYS391=9 DYS425=null .................................................. ........25
...I2a1 (I-L672 'generic')M26+L672+L160- all are likely PF6947-.................................................. .............................19
...I2a1 (I-PF6947) M26+ L672+ PF6947+ L160- .................................................. .................................................. ...17
...I2a1 (I-L672)M26+L672+L160 status unknown, Geno 2.0 or L160 or PF4088 recommended, email for advice ...53
...I2a1b (I-L160) M26+L672+L160+ Geno 2.0 or PF4088 recommended email admins for advice...........................72
..I2a1b (I-L160) M26+L672+L160+ Z118- Geno 2.0 or PF4088 or PF6950 recommended, email ...23
...I2a1b (I-F1295*) M26+ L672+ L160+ F1295+ PF6950- .................................................. ......................................3
..I2a1b (I-PF6950) M26+L672+L160+F1295+PF6950+ .................................................. ..........................................6
..I2a1b (I-PF4088* 'DYS425=10') M26+ L672+ L160+ PF4088+ CTS11338- we recommend CTS8386 ..................8
...I2a1b (I-PF4088* 'DYS462=13') M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338- 111 markers recommended...................7
...I2a1b (I-PF4088*)M26+ L672+ L160+ PF4088+ some are CTS11338- F168- others need CTS11338 or Geno.20 ..41
...I2a1b (I-PF4189)M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338+PF4189+PF4190- .................................................. .......7
...I2a1b (I-PF4190) M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338+PF4189+PF4190+ Casula and Winter are PF4393+....3
..I2a1b..(I-CTS787)M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338+CTS787+ but Z118- .................................................. ....2
...I2a1b..(I-Z118)M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338+CTS787+Z118+Z10 6- .................................................. ....5
...I2a1b..(I-Z106)M26+L672+L160+PF4088+CTS11338+CTS787+Z118+Z10 6+................................................ ......23
https://www.familytreedna.com/public...ction=yresults
I-M223 the most common one is not Sardinian
I-M170 is too basal
I-L1237 isnt
I-Z140 isnt sardinian
I-M253 is too basal
I-Y3712 is not sardinian
I-Y10890 is not sardinian
I-Y7067 isnt
Seems like its not even there but if one is there its extremely rare in Spain
I don't know where they are finding M26. But the I2a project doesnt give is the origins for their (sardinian)
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 1,875 Given: 2,197 |
Is there any peer-reviewed study about those groups?
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 40,069 Given: 10,740 |
The new Sarno et al study showed that southern Italian, Sicilian, Cretan, and Aegean islanders are more or less one genetic unit.
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 4,385 Given: 1,891 |
The list of oldest languages by first written accounts:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...itten_accounts
Sardinian is the closest to Latin than Italian.
Some of my threads:
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 40,069 Given: 10,740 |
My guess of closeness to Latin is: Sardinian > Italian > Spanish > Romanian > Portuguese > French
Portuguese and French are likely furthest, even though Portuguese is generally close to Spanish. A lot of its forms are clearly removed, like articles and spelling.
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 4,385 Given: 1,891 |
Yes, that should be the correct version.
Some of my threads:
| Thumbs Up |
| Received: 1,633 Given: 994 |
For some weird reason, probably it's force of habit, I find easier to read the French than other Romance languages.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Afghanistan
United Kingdom
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks