Are Bosniaks Poles?

[Jana]

Bosniaks (and many Bosnian Christians) are an intermediary population between Serbians and Croatians. Many of them plot with both Serbs and Croats and many on their own.

Yes, I agree with that 100%

[Jana]

How ? Bosniaks are mostly geneticly conected whit Serbs, especialy this who are I2a1b..they are quite similar as western Serbs..Really can't see what are u talking about..
Btw what about difference beatwen south and NW Croats?
Think more about that..Many Croats have roots in estern herzegovina btw..And most of them are stokhavian .

We are different than NW Croats, does that suprise you ?
Just like you Banija Serb are different than Torlak, or Montenegrin Serb.

Western Serbs and Bosniaks are similar , no doubt.

[HungryLion]

Bosniaks (and many Bosnian Christians) are an intermediary population between Serbians and Croatians. Many of them plot with both Serbs and Croats and many on their own.

Croats have their presence in west bosnia in some point.
Others are nothing than western Serbs.

[HungryLion]

We are different than NW Croats, does that suprise you ?
Just like you Banija Serb are different than Torlak, or Montenegrin Serb.

Western Serbs and Bosniaks are similar , no doubt.

Not really ..bc I know many south Croats are more close to Serbs than NW Croats, so no surprise.

Serbs have very similar % of I2a1b everywhere, unlike Croats...

I really can't judge by autosomal dna, ofc Montenegrin will be more south bc of their geographical position and life style under the Turk ocupation...Still major tribes are mostly I2a1b...Ofc significant pressence of balkan native ppl to E-V13, no doubt .

[Vožd]

They are not Croats by any means.
You can't change history..Try to find Croats among small grup of bosniaks in western bosnia, but good luck.
There is no source about Croats setle in Bosnia, in other hand you have plently about Serbs who settled Bosnia.
Also Frank's said Serbs were huge majority in Dalmatia.
It comes again somewhere on same borders, as I said try to find Croats in far west of Bosnia, but good luck.

Many islamized Croats were expelled to Bosnia after fall of Otomans in today parts of Croatia.

[HungryLion]

I Croats were in western Bosnia, I can't see problem ..
South and estern of Vrbas are Serbs...

[Jana]

Not really ..bc I know many south Croats are more close to Serbs than NW Croats, so no surprise.

Serbs have very similar % of I2a1b everywhere, unlike Croats...

I really can't judge by autosomal dna, ofc Montenegrin will be more south bc of their geographical position and life style under the Turk ocupation...Still major tribes are mostly I2a1b...Ofc significant pressence of balkan native ppl to E-V13, no doubt .

Autosomal difference between you and Montenegrin Serb is ocean big. I do not care for ydna. They have lot of E-V13 in the end.

All Croats have I2a1b dominant except North (and maybe Kvarner)

[HungryLion]

Many islamized Croats were expelled to Bosnia after fall of Otomans in today parts of Croatia.

Yes, some of them..not many, also some of hungarians etc...

[HungryLion]

Autosomal difference between you and Montenegrin Serb is ocean big. I do not care for ydna. They have lot of E-V13 in the end.

All Croats have I2a1b dominant except North (and maybe Kvarner)

Well Y is quite important...That how u see your origins more or less..

That is what I said, I2a1b is low in part were Serbs never come. Nw Croatia..
Even some western Bulgarians of Serbian origins who sing about Lazar and Marko Mrnjavčević, so caled Šops, have over 30% I2a1b.

[Jana]

Yes, some of them..not many, also some of hungarians etc...

Many. Entire Slavonian population was expelled, some numbers say 300 000. Without Lika and Dalmatia.
Some Bosnian muslims have more medieval Slavonian blood than some Slavonian Croats.