Are the Scots Germanic?

[Septentrion]

I'd say they're a Celtic-Germanic mix.

On the scale of most Germanic to most Celtic:

English
Scottish
Irish

I don't know where the Welsh would fit in.

Most Germanic

English
Scottish
Welsh
Irish

[Peterski]

Wales has a higher percent of R1b-U106 than Scotland.

Based on samples from Busby 2011:

England (n=484):

213 x R1b-P312 (44%)
110 x R1b-U106 (23%)

Ratio of P312 to U106 2:1

Wales (n=129):

90 x R1b-P312 (70%)
13 x R1b-U106 (10%)

Ratio of P312 to U106 7:1

Scotland (n=168):

114 x R1b-P312 (68%)
11 x R1b-U106 (6,5%)

Proportion of P312 to U106 10:1

Ireland (n=476):

387 x R1b-P312 (81%)
25 x R1b-U106 (5,3%)

Ratio of P312 to U106 15:1

[Peterski]

Most Germanic

English
Scottish
Welsh
Irish

Wales might be more Germanic. The map from Eupedia is not reliable.

But Scotland has a higher Viking input and Wales higher Anglo-Saxon.

[Tong]

Mixed

[Jovan Vladimir]

Mostly Celtic, but with Germanic influence.