Bulgarians on G25

[celticdragongod]

Distance to: CDG_scaled
0.08232693 Slavic
0.08613949 Bulgarian_34
0.13931556 Thracian
0.15585646 pre-Slavic
0.17849384 Anatolian
0.25977423 Turkic
0.38522429 Romani
0.47151877 MAR_EN

Target: CDG_scaled
Distance: 5.9297% / 0.05929650
68.4 Slavic
30.8 Thracian
0.8 Romani

[axlredneck]

I just would speculate that Q-F16045 and N-A9416 are of Oghuz origin, although they are Turkic without doubt.

Are you implying that these are Oghuz Y-lines or that they aren't?

N-A9416 was found in a medieval Turk from Mugla.


Your Y-line is ofcourse enigmatic...

[Annihilus]

Target: annihilus_v2_scaled
Distance: 2.7634% / 0.02763376 | ADC: 0.25x RC
44.6 Anatolian
43.2 Bulgarian_34
12.2 Turkic

Distance to: annihilus_v2_scaled
0.06143369 Bulgarian_34
0.07049669 pre-Slavic
0.07142406 Anatolian
0.08432911 Thracian
0.16129478 Slavic
0.21902101 Turkic
0.35225991 Romani
0.43800968 MAR_EN

[oszkar07]

In your oppinion are

a) North Macedonians originally the same people as Bulgarians but splintered off and developed their
own identity and nuanced/specific culture.

b) are North Macedonians a historically seperate people with historical seperate identity but are similiar to Bulgarians.

C) North Macedonians a mixture of A & B.

D) North Macedonians a mixture of slavic speaking Bulgarians and Serbs.

I have asked this question here a few times and interestingly people seem to wanna avoid answering it.
Which seems weird because if someone asked are Bosnians originally Serb or Croats or Bosniaks, people are quite happy to give their oppinions and care little bout offending anyone.
But the Bulgarian - North Macedonian question often seems to be avoided.



Target: Oszkar
Distance: 3.7241% / 0.03724087
65.2 Slavic
34.2 Thracian
0.6 Turkic

[majevica]

Target: majevica_scaled
Distance: 1.8988% / 0.01898751
56.8 Slavic
31.6 Thracian
11.2 Anatolian
0.4 Turkic

[axlredneck]

In your oppinion are

a) North Macedonians originally the same people as Bulgarians but splintered off and developed their
own identity and nuanced/specific culture.

b) are North Macedonians a historically seperate people with historical seperate identity but are similiar to Bulgarians.

C) North Macedonians a mixture of A & B.

D) North Macedonians a mixture of slavic speaking Bulgarians and Serbs.

I have asked this question here a few times and interestingly people seem to wanna avoid answering it.
Which seems weird because if someone asked are Bosnians originally Serb or Croats or Bosniaks, people are quite happy to give their oppinions and care little bout offending anyone.
But the Bulgarian - North Macedonian question often seems to be avoided.

No, they're not the same people.



Balkan_IA = IA inhabitants of North Macedonia.
Hellenic_IA = Mycenaeans

[ooops]

No, they're not the same people.



Balkan_IA = IA inhabitants of North Macedonia.
Hellenic_IA = Mycenaeans

Macedonians were all the time identified as Bulgarians. They were brainwashed by Communists.
Regional differences exist among the French, Italians, Poles etc.
Also, those percentages of Slavic blood in the Balkans are internet pseudoscience.

[Kaspias]

Are you implying that these are Oghuz Y-lines or that they aren't?

N-A9416 was found in a medieval Turk from Mugla.


Your Y-line is ofcourse enigmatic...

Didn't know that N, thanks

[axlredneck]

Bulgarian Y-DNA n=1170

E 22%
G 5.5%
H 0.6%
I1 4.1%
I2 22.3%
J1 3.1%
J2a 7.3%
J2b 5%
L 0.4%
N 0.6%
Q 0.5%
R1a 16%
R1b 10.8%
T 1.8%

[axlredneck]

Any TA Bulgarians who wanna share their G25 coordinates?