Spaniards; Jewish self-haters?

[Annihilus]

It's more of an ethnic group.

The links are 2 years old. If there's a more recent study please post it.

Ethnic groups are based on culture, if the culture had an dead end, it is simply gone. You can't link that to genetics, especially over such a time frame where one has multiple ancestors.

[pinguino]

That's ridiculous. Spaniards are constantly taking shit for being 'not European enough'. Spaniards aren't Jews, even if a minority have Jewish ancestry then they are still not Jews, they have been disconnected from Jewish culture for centuries. They certainly aren't self-hating Jews, that's just bullshit.

As a rabine explained me once, Spaniards aren't descendants of Jews. However, Spaniards have HEBREW blood. How lucky people.

[pinguino]

We don't call people today by the religion their ancestors might have practiced. There is is no christian dna, there is no muslim dna, there is no jewish dna. It's just a religion for christ sake.

Technically, Spaniards ancestry is marrano (that in Spanish means pig)

[Philo]

Those studies considered haplogroup J to be jewish. If that's true, then a large part of Europe is jewish

J1C3 Is semitic not jewish. If anybody named that haplogroup jewish than they're huge idiots. J2 definitely is'nt jewish.

As a rabine explained me once, Spaniards aren't descendants of Jews. However, Spaniards have HEBREW blood. How lucky people.

Sure. I hope you we're serious.

[Anglojew]

A signed copy of the Edict of Expulsion of the Jews

Ferdinand was part-Jewish himself.

Wasn't Juan De Coloma a converso too?

[Ibericus]

J1C3 Is semitic not jewish. If anybody named that haplogroup jewish than they're huge idiots. J2 definitely is'nt jewish.

Well that study included J2, G2, many of the E, T and other stuff as Jewish. That's why is so moronic. Following that methodology, countries like Greece or Italy would be 40 to 60% jewish.

[Damião de Góis]

J1C3 Is semitic not jewish. If anybody named that haplogroup jewish than they're huge idiots. J2 definitely is'nt jewish.

Yes that's what i was saying.

[pinguino]

The moronic conclusion is that you can distinguish jewish and non-jewish populations looking at genetic markers.

[Lábaru]

Ferdinand was part-Jewish himself.

And Pinocchio!

[pinguino]

And Cervantes!