Catholics: Most Holy Family Monastery

[Sol Invictus]

http://mostholyfamilymonastery.com/

Huge information resource.

[Lutiferre]

Huge information resource.

Information? You must be kidding. All you will get is extremely biased sedevacantist propagandism.

Another example of fringe Americanism in it's constant search for conspiracies, just in the religious sphere. And thats how you get the result: crackpot Americans who think they can establish a papacy in their backyard.

The European traditionalists (FSSP notably, and even SSPX) at least recognize the importance of being in communion with Rome, as Catholics.

[Sol Invictus]

I'm actually very surprised at your reactionary response.
The site is actually very much pro-Catholic.

[Lutiferre]

I'm actually very surprised at your reactionary response.
The site is actually very much pro-Catholic.

But this is an extremist traditionalist sedevecantist schismatic sect, which promotes division among Christians instead of unity, and that is in itself much like protestantism. Anything they say about Rome is unreliable.

There are many traditionalists (which are not schismatic sects) in communion with Rome.

The developments of Vatican II have often been extremely exaggerated and misinterpreted by such sects, so I can only guess what you will get from that site will be just as misinterpretive.

[Sol Invictus]

I can only guess what you will get from that site will be just as misinterpretive.

Thus it shows just how closed-minded you are.

I'll pray for you.

[Lutiferre]

Thus it shows just how closed-minded you are.

I'll pray for you.

No. I have come across the site before, so it's not out of close-mindedness but out of experience.

I am simply warning you against relying on anything a schismatic sect like this has to say. I had no bad intents.

But by all means, it's up to yourself whether you want to rely on some backyard papacy in America for the interpretation of Rome and Vatican II, or actually consult some who are somewhat balanced.

[Poltergeist]

I read something from that website before. It is some kind of Jansenist cult.

No genuine Catholic traditionalism.

There is a long time that I grew wary of all kinds of these faux "Catholic traditionalists" who seem not to know how to do anything else, but only to incessantly lash out at the Second Vatican Council and to invoke some pre-conciliary "golden age" which in fact never existed. The Second Vatican Council has to be seen in its proper context, with its pluses and minuses.

As much as the modern chaos in the Church is deplorable, the Jansenist narrow-mindedness and madness is no solution to it.

[Murphy]

http://www.catholicintl.com/catholic...imondradio.htm
http://www.catholicintl.com/catholic...dimondbros.htm
http://www.catholicintl.com/epologet...ch/dimond3.htm
http://www.catholicintl.com/epologet...vacantists.htm

http://www.catholicintl.com/epologet...evacantism.htm
http://www.catholicintl.com/epologet...san_o_sed1.htm

http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9507fea1.asp

Oh and the Dimond Brothers are not actually Religious brothers and are in no way affiliated with the Order of St. Benedict as they claim. Even still, they dishonestly call themselves "Brother" and call their house/trailer Most Holy Family Monastary. It's about as valid as if Sally and Elfichka got an apartment together and called it a convent.

They are liars and schismatics. You will also forgive me if I wont let a Protestant decide who is better for a Catholic to listen to... witches and devils or The Magisterium.

Regards,
Eóin.