Has anyone got different Gedmatch results after ordering 23andme, Ftdna?

[Insuperable]

Is it possible? Do you know anyone who got different results after ordering both 23andme and Ftdna? I am not having in mind autosomal transfer or something like that or negligible decimal differences. I don't know do various companies use the same genotyping technology, there should always be some kind of variable accompanying error and so on. That is why I ask.

[Not a Cop]

Is it possible? Do you know anyone who got different results after ordering both 23andme and Ftdna? I am not having in mind autosomal transfer or something like that or negligible decimal differences. I don't know do various companies use the same genotyping technology, there should always be some kind of variable accompanying error and so on. That is why I ask.

From what i've seen differrence for major components is usually 1-2% at max.

[Thrax]

There are differences yes, I even get some different matches.

[Linebacker]

There was a thread here I think about some guy that ordered multiple kits and got different results each time,but I don't know if the difference was dramatic or not,I think it wasn't,but the fact that there is a difference kind of gives these kind of tests a wobbly image.

[Highlands]

Would love to know if my high "east med" is real.

[gültekin]

according to FTDNA i'm partly German :lol:

[Iloko]

I have my raw data from all three companies and here's how it turned out...



HarappaWorld(AncestryDNA raw data):

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 SE-Asian 59.41
2 NE-Asian 30.41
3 Papuan 2.48
4 S-Indian 2.27
5 Caucasian 1.25
6 Baloch 1.22
7 Beringian 0.8
8 SW-Asian 0.67
9 NE-Euro 0.62
10 Mediterranean 0.48
11 American 0.39

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 kinh (1000genomes) 5.45
2 vietnamese (xing) 7.77
3 lahu (hgdp) 8.84
4 dai-chinese (1000genomes) 9.72
5 dai (hgdp) 11.58
6 khmer-cambodian (xing) 16.71
7 thai (xing) 20.87
8 cambodian (hgdp) 24.06
9 singapore-malay (sgvp) 26.92
10 burmanese (chaubey) 35.4
11 miao (hgdp) 36.05
12 singapore-chinese (sgvp) 38.05
13 garo (chaubey) 38.52
14 iban (xing) 39.15
15 khasi (chaubey) 39.62
16 she (hgdp) 40.36
17 chinese (xing) 40.66
18 han-chinese-south (1000genomes) 41.74
19 samoan (xing) 42.07
20 han (hgdp) 42.12

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 78.7% vietnamese (xing) + 21.3% singapore-malay (sgvp) @ 2.79
2 77.1% vietnamese (xing) + 22.9% cambodian (hgdp) @ 3.15
3 74.5% vietnamese (xing) + 25.5% thai (xing) @ 3.2
4 95.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.1% aus (reich) @ 3.42
5 91.6% kinh (1000genomes) + 8.4% tongan (xing) @ 3.43
6 96% kinh (1000genomes) + 4% melanesian (hgdp) @ 3.54
7 91% kinh (1000genomes) + 9% samoan (xing) @ 3.56
8 70.3% vietnamese (xing) + 29.7% khmer-cambodian (xing) @ 3.6
9 85.1% dai (hgdp) + 14.9% nepalese-b (xing) @ 3.6
10 94.6% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.4% romanian-b (behar) @ 3.62
11 68.8% iban (xing) + 31.2% japanese (1000genomes) @ 3.63
12 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% kurd (harappa) @ 3.69
13 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% iranian (behar) @ 3.7
14 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% iraqi-arab (harappa) @ 3.7
15 97% kinh (1000genomes) + 3% papuan (hgdp) @ 3.7
16 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% turkish (harappa) @ 3.73
17 94.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.1% pashtun (harappa) @ 3.73
18 95.2% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.8% uzbekistan-jew (behar) @ 3.74
19 95.1% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.9% stalskoe (xing) @ 3.75
20 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% ashkenazy-jew (behar) @ 3.75




Harappaworld(FTDNA raw data):

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 SE-Asian 59.42
2 NE-Asian 30.36
3 Papuan 2.48
4 S-Indian 2.29
5 Baloch 1.27
6 Caucasian 1.22
7 Beringian 0.86
8 SW-Asian 0.71
9 NE-Euro 0.51
10 Mediterranean 0.5
11 American 0.4

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 kinh (1000genomes) 5.48
2 vietnamese (xing) 7.82
3 lahu (hgdp) 8.88
4 dai-chinese (1000genomes) 9.71
5 dai (hgdp) 11.56
6 khmer-cambodian (xing) 16.67
7 thai (xing) 20.82
8 cambodian (hgdp) 24.01
9 singapore-malay (sgvp) 26.87
10 burmanese (chaubey) 35.42
11 miao (hgdp) 36.09
12 singapore-chinese (sgvp) 38.1
13 garo (chaubey) 38.54
14 iban (xing) 39.1
15 khasi (chaubey) 39.61
16 she (hgdp) 40.41
17 chinese (xing) 40.71
18 han-chinese-south (1000genomes) 41.79
19 samoan (xing) 42.04
20 han (hgdp) 42.17

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 78.6% vietnamese (xing) + 21.4% singapore-malay (sgvp) @ 2.8
2 76.9% vietnamese (xing) + 23.1% cambodian (hgdp) @ 3.16
3 74.3% vietnamese (xing) + 25.7% thai (xing) @ 3.22
4 91.5% kinh (1000genomes) + 8.5% tongan (xing) @ 3.45
5 95.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.1% aus (reich) @ 3.47
6 91% kinh (1000genomes) + 9% samoan (xing) @ 3.58
7 96% kinh (1000genomes) + 4% melanesian (hgdp) @ 3.59
8 85.2% dai (hgdp) + 14.8% nepalese-b (xing) @ 3.6
9 70.1% vietnamese (xing) + 29.9% khmer-cambodian (xing) @ 3.61
10 68.8% iban (xing) + 31.2% japanese (1000genomes) @ 3.64
11 94.6% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.4% romanian-b (behar) @ 3.66
12 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% kurd (harappa) @ 3.72
13 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% iranian (behar) @ 3.73
14 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% iraqi-arab (harappa) @ 3.73
15 97% kinh (1000genomes) + 3% papuan (hgdp) @ 3.76
16 94.8% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.2% pashtun (harappa) @ 3.76
17 95% kinh (1000genomes) + 5% turkish (harappa) @ 3.77
18 95.2% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.8% uzbekistan-jew (behar) @ 3.77
19 53.9% iban (xing) + 46.1% chinese-american (hapmap) @ 3.78
20 83.8% kinh (1000genomes) + 16.2% thai (xing) @ 3.79




Harappaworld(23andme V4 raw data):

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 SE-Asian 59.27
2 NE-Asian 30.25
3 Papuan 2.43
4 S-Indian 2.3
5 Caucasian 1.49
6 Baloch 1.27
7 Beringian 0.93
8 SW-Asian 0.63
9 NE-Euro 0.55
10 American 0.48
11 Mediterranean 0.41

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 kinh (1000genomes) 5.64
2 vietnamese (xing) 7.9
3 lahu (hgdp) 8.91
4 dai-chinese (1000genomes) 9.86
5 dai (hgdp) 11.69
6 khmer-cambodian (xing) 16.62
7 thai (xing) 20.74
8 cambodian (hgdp) 24
9 singapore-malay (sgvp) 26.86
10 burmanese (chaubey) 35.33
11 miao (hgdp) 36.09
12 singapore-chinese (sgvp) 38.1
13 garo (chaubey) 38.46
14 iban (xing) 39.14
15 khasi (chaubey) 39.48
16 she (hgdp) 40.41
17 chinese (xing) 40.71
18 han-chinese-south (1000genomes) 41.79
19 samoan (xing) 42.06
20 han (hgdp) 42.17

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 78.5% vietnamese (xing) + 21.5% singapore-malay (sgvp) @ 2.96
2 74% vietnamese (xing) + 26% thai (xing) @ 3.24
3 76.8% vietnamese (xing) + 23.2% cambodian (hgdp) @ 3.29
4 95.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 4.1% aus (reich) @ 3.65
5 94.4% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.6% romanian-b (behar) @ 3.66
6 69.9% vietnamese (xing) + 30.1% khmer-cambodian (xing) @ 3.68
7 91.5% kinh (1000genomes) + 8.5% tongan (xing) @ 3.69
8 85% dai (hgdp) + 15% nepalese-b (xing) @ 3.69
9 94.7% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.3% kurd (harappa) @ 3.69
10 94.7% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.3% iranian (behar) @ 3.71
11 94.7% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.3% iraqi-arab (harappa) @ 3.72
12 94.7% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.3% turkish (harappa) @ 3.73
13 94.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.1% uzbekistan-jew (behar) @ 3.74
14 68.8% iban (xing) + 31.2% japanese (1000genomes) @ 3.75
15 94.8% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.2% stalskoe (xing) @ 3.76
16 94.6% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.4% pashtun (harappa) @ 3.77
17 94.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.1% lebanese-muslim (haber) @ 3.78
18 94.8% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.2% azeri (harappa) @ 3.78
19 94.9% kinh (1000genomes) + 5.1% syrian (behar) @ 3.79
20 96% kinh (1000genomes) + 4% melanesian (hgdp) @ 3.79

[Iloko]

I'll post my Eurogenes K13 if you want.

[Insuperable]

^Negligible difference.