Guessing game: Spaniard (Andalusian), Italian (Sicilian), Greek

[Deneb]

As alwais, I'll reveal their names later.

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/7313ED6C-584A-46F5-9ECC-A8CC8D073868_zpsjq99ccth.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/7313ED6C-584A-46F5-9ECC-A8CC8D073868_zpsjq99ccth.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/8DC499E4-BA05-4C4C-BA5F-FBEFBD5D1521_zpsc1y0c7ic.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/8DC499E4-BA05-4C4C-BA5F-FBEFBD5D1521_zpsc1y0c7ic.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/4BC5BCD6-D7A7-4AC3-A42D-EF12EBB9D7F6_zpsca8q1y0s.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/4BC5BCD6-D7A7-4AC3-A42D-EF12EBB9D7F6_zpsca8q1y0s.jpg.html)

[Alessio]

Sp, Si, Gr or Sp, Gr, Si
Difficult one ;)

[Raikaswinþs]

Spanish, Greek , Sicilian?

The first one must be spanish

[Raikaswinþs]

As alwais, I'll reveal their names later.

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/7313ED6C-584A-46F5-9ECC-A8CC8D073868_zpsjq99ccth.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/7313ED6C-584A-46F5-9ECC-A8CC8D073868_zpsjq99ccth.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/8DC499E4-BA05-4C4C-BA5F-FBEFBD5D1521_zpsc1y0c7ic.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/8DC499E4-BA05-4C4C-BA5F-FBEFBD5D1521_zpsc1y0c7ic.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/4BC5BCD6-D7A7-4AC3-A42D-EF12EBB9D7F6_zpsca8q1y0s.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/4BC5BCD6-D7A7-4AC3-A42D-EF12EBB9D7F6_zpsca8q1y0s.jpg.html)

really the middle one is the least Spanish of the three to me. But he is still within the mediterranean range so ... The third one looks more pan med too, but he would pass better in Spain. The first ine thiugh...hus looks are quite Spanish and of the darkest dpectrum (just like the OP likes)

[Oneeye]

Spanish, Sicilian, Greek? Maybe the last one is Spanish? First looks the most Iberian to me.

[Queen B]

Second must be the Greek

[Oneeye]

really the middle one is the least Spanish of the three to me. But he is still within the mediterranean range so ... The third one looks more pan med too, but he would pass better in Spain. The first ine thiugh...hus looks are quite Spanish and of the darkest dpectrum (just like the OP likes)

The first doesn't look darker to me, he just has wet, sweaty hair. He does have some thick eyebrows though that give him swarth points.

[Raikaswinþs]

Spanish, Sicilian, Greek? Maybe the last one is Spanish? First looks the most Iberian to me.

he has features that are more frequenty associated with Spaniards but the third one would be a much more neutral type and perhaps more common even than the first. Anyway, it would be nice if the OP posted a closer phito of the first one with better light.

[Oneeye]

he has features that are more frequenty associated with Spaniards but the third one would be a much more neutral type and perhaps more common even than the first. Anyway, it would be nice if the OP posted a closer phito of the first one with better light.


First one has a facial hair pattern I associate with Spanish. And that jaw, and eyeshape.

[Tana]

First one is Greek, second is Spanish and third is Sicilian.

[Raikaswinþs]

First one is Greek, second is Spanish and third is Sicilian.

yeah Im going to go with first one greek aswell. he has a pseudo spanish vibe but the nose is definitelly off, it would be too easy

[Sikeliot]

Spanish, Greek, Sicilian.

Either way #3 looks most Sicilian, he has close spaced eyes and a bit Jewish looking but not really exotic. I could see #2 as Spanish also but he looks very Peloponnesian.

Artabro I have to give it to you these are all representative for Southern Europe IMO. :)

[spanish catalan]

sicilian
greek
spanish

very easy

[Bagot]

Spanish, Greek, Sicilian.

Either way #3 looks most Sicilian, he has close spaced eyes and a bit Jewish looking but not really exotic. I could see #2 as Spanish also but he looks very Peloponnesian.

Artabro I have to give it to you these are all representative for Southern Europe IMO. :)

According to the Spanish Caxtiltēcati the third is the one that passes better in Spain. I don't see anything Jewish about him.

[Tana]

http://i.imgur.com/mVWSYyS.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/trCCed8.jpg

Honestly, he could be from anywhere in Southern Europe.

[Raikaswinþs]

my final is greek ; Spanish/Sicilian and Sicilian/ Spanish. Too hard to tell

[Bagot]

my final is greek ; Spanish/Sicilian and Sicilian/ Spanish. Too hard to tell

At some extent they are all interchangeable IMO.

[Raikaswinþs]

According to the Spanish Caxtiltēcati the third is the one that passes better in Spain. I don't see anything Jewish about him.

the three can pass innspain in more or less degree imo. but it is just my opinion. Thenlast one is the most neutral med, therefore the bestbfit for the threr countries. The middle one could be an unusuak type in Spain, but not rare either. My firsy guess was spanish greek italian, but now I think the first is likely greek and the other two too hard to tell.

[Sikeliot]

I would be very surprised if the third is Spanish, his eye region really throws it off for him to be Spanish. I stuck with my original guess. I have no difficulty telling Iberians from southern Italians.

[Raikaswinþs]

I would be very surprised if the third is Spanish, his eye region really throws it off for him to be Spanish. I stuck with my original guess. I have no difficulty telling Iberians from southern Italians.

you have never been yo either italy or spain. the third one could be either or. precisely the third one is the most generic of the three. I would go with the second one as Spanish because the OP likes the most unusual Spanish types. But because the three are nit very representative, itbis hard to tell.

[Sikeliot]

you have never been yo either italy or spain. the third one could be either or. precisely the third one is the most generic of the three. I would go with the second one as Spanish because the OP likes the most unusual Spanish types. But because the three are nit very representative, itbis hard to tell.

To me, the third one is the least Spanish looking of them all. He doesn't look generic Med to me, not with the shape of his eyes. I could guess right away which was Sicilian, but it took me longer to decide between 1 and 2 for Spanish and Greek.

[Raikaswinþs]

To me, the third one is the least Spanish looking of them all. He doesn't look generic Med to me, not with the shape of his eyes. I could guess right away which was Sicilian, but it took me longer to decide between 1 and 2 for Spanish and Greek.
hendoesn't look generic to you because you donlt know ehat mediterranean eurooe looks likr; nit having ever been there.

the three have been chosen to be ambiguous. I had a boarding school teacher looking just like the thurd one. His eyes I have seen a million times. He maybe Italian, but not a ckear cut case. Nine if them are clear cut. Nevertheless someone has whistled me the answer via pm. But I won't tell not to spoil the fun

[Sikeliot]

hendoesn't look generic to you because you donlt know ehat mediterranean eurooe looks likr; nit having ever been there.

the three have been chosen to be ambiguous. I had a boarding school teacher looking just like the thurd one. His eyes I have seen a million times. He maybe Italian, but not a ckear cut case. Nine if them are clear cut. Nevertheless someone has whistled me the answer via pm. But I won't tell not to spoil the fun

I think my answer is correct for the reasons I gave, and I really do not care what you think of my posts or what I said.

[XvThomas_LysergicV]

1. Spanish

2. Greek

3. Italian

[Raikaswinþs]

I think my answer is correct for the reasons I gave, and I really do not care what you think of my posts or what I said.

Well of course you shouldn't care about anyone's opinion on such topics. Specially about what some guy on the internet thinks lol. But is not your guesses that are odd
It's the reasons you provided to justify them that look suspicious to me :-p

[Sikeliot]

Well of course you shouldn't care about anyone's opinion on such topics. Specially about what some guy on the internet thinks lol. But is not your guesses that are odd
It's the reasons you provided to justify them that look suspicious to me :-p

I don't care what you think, so don't bother telling me. Just have him reveal the answer.

[Aodhan]

Spanish-Italian-Greek

[Percivalle]

They are all searchable in a google image search, I have found them so I don't say anything about them. But it wasn't so easy to guess them correctly.

[kantez]

do one with lebanese and valencians/balearic islanders

[Raikaswinþs]

I don't care what you think, so don't bother telling me. Just have him reveal the answer.

I'm not just telling you, you know, just stating an opinion. I can't choose when he reveals the answer.

[Deneb]

Honestly I thought this was going to be extremely easy, because I picked them stereotypically: east med, berid and alpine. Surprisingly only Tana got it right.

1 Greek: Panagiotis Nikas, footballer
2 Andalusian: Juan Carlos Duarte, mayor of San Juan del Puerto (Huelva)
3 Sicilian: Gianfilippo Bancheri, sicilian mayor of Delia

[Sikeliot]

Honestly I thought this was going to be extremely easy, because I picked them stereotypically: east med, berid and alpine. Surprisingly only Tana got it right.

1 Greek: Nikos Panagiotis, greek, footballer
2 Andalusian: Juan Carlos Duarte, mayor of San Juan del Puerto (Huelva)
3 Sicilian: Gianfilippo Bancheri, sicilian mayor of Delia

"East Med" isn't real. The first is in the Atlanto-Med or Pontid range, which is why people guessed him as Spanish fairly often here.

#2 definitely has a Greek look though. The Sicilian was obvious to me and seeing I got it right is reaffirming.

Of the three ethnic groups I can most easily tell Sicilians apart, the only exception is if the Greek looks very Balkan.

[Deneb]

"East Med" isn't real. The first is in the Atlanto-Med or Pontid range, which is why people guessed him as Spanish fairly often here.

#2 definitely has a Greek look though. The Sicilian was obvious to me and seeing I got it right is reaffirming.

Of the three ethnic groups I can most easily tell Sicilians apart, the only exception is if the Greek looks very Balkan.

You got 1/3 I think you are a sore loser. I don't see anyone here justifying their mistakes, but you...

[Alessio]

"East Med" isn't real. The first is in the Atlanto-Med or Pontid range, which is why people guessed him as Spanish fairly often here.

#2 definitely has a Greek look though. The Sicilian was obvious to me and seeing I got it right is reaffirming.

Of the three ethnic groups I can most easily tell Sicilians apart, the only exception is if the Greek looks very Balkan.

I think you have a point here, although I had several different combinations in my head. Next time I'm going for my intuition again.

[Sikeliot]

You got 1/3 I think you are a sore loser. I don't see anyone here justifying their mistakes, but you...

I don't care if I mixed up the others, I only care if I can recognize my own, and I can.

[Faklon]

Honestly I thought this was going to be extremely easy, because I picked them stereotypically: east med, berid and alpine.

Honestly now, east-med isn't a subrace but a spectrum for higher-skulled types suggested by Lundman.

Berid isn't considered the most typical in Iberia in regards to anthropology but classic as well taller/atlanto-med types are.

In any case, I have noticed certain picking partners also deviating from your introduction as "I'm Spaniard and didn't stand out among young Greeks when I visited Athens".

Now, I don't know if it's a reaction to Sikeliot's, Raine's or else's silly conceptions and reactions or some deeper agenda but it certainly deviates from one point to another.