Guess: German, Norwegian, British

[Deneb]

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/78897AF3-01B4-4E66-9F7A-387D59D3B64C_zpsskhjpp1t.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/78897AF3-01B4-4E66-9F7A-387D59D3B64C_zpsskhjpp1t.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/1762B8E7-709B-49A2-9B23-0D20A92ACCF3_zpsrqppdjhw.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/1762B8E7-709B-49A2-9B23-0D20A92ACCF3_zpsrqppdjhw.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/DA6574F1-49C6-4D81-B030-B0875FD19D58_zpsxr1rlptv.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/DA6574F1-49C6-4D81-B030-B0875FD19D58_zpsxr1rlptv.jpg.html)

[Gooding]

First Norwegian
Second British
Third German
I'm probably wrong, but it's my guess.

[Infinite]

British
German
Norwegian

[jerney]

British
Norwegian
German

[abcd123]

First one certainly looks British,I can even hear his accent.About the other two,I don't know,it could go both ways.Let's say:
British
Norwegian
German

[spanish catalan]

british
norwegian
german

very easy

[Imamudin]

1. German
2. British
3. Norwegian

[Cuore di Tenebra]

German
Norwegian
British

[Neon Knight]

Norwegian
German
British

[Berahthraban]

1. Norweigan
2. German
3. British

I feel very certain about this, but we will see :D

[Warrior]

The 2rd might be british, but he looks far better than the average british male truth to be told.

[abcd123]

1. Norweigan
2. German
3. British

I feel very certain about this, but we will see :D

0/0

[Linebacker]

The second one is definitely the Norwegian.Looks like that you only see in Scandinavia.

Then I think first one is the German and 3rd one is the Brit.

[Imamudin]

Norwegian
German
British

Are you kidding? The second looks typical British with that pink skin tone, freckles and ginger hair.

[Warrior]

Are you kidding? The second looks typical British with that pink skin tone, freckles and ginger hair.

He doesn't look typical white English, let alone typical british.... there are brits like him, but a minority.

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

Norwegian
British
German

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

The 2rd might be british, but he looks far better than the average british male truth to be told.

what's up klaus

[Imamudin]

He doesn't look typical white English, let alone typical british.... there are brits like him, but a minority.

But more typical British than anything else.

[joshua rumble]

Are you kidding? The second looks typical British with that pink skin tone, freckles and ginger hair.

number 2 does not have ginger hair at all, by any stretch of the imagination.

number 1 has '' pinker skin'' than 2nd????

pink skin has never been a select British thing?

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

Well, the first one is probably either British or Norwegian, the second one is probably British and the third one is either British or German.

[abcd123]

But more typical British than anything else.

No,the first one looks far more british than the second.

[Warrior]

what's up klaus

You are confusing me with someone else.

I stated that because I have been in England for some time.

[Deneb]

Jerney, abcd123 and Spanishcatalan got it right. The correct answer is so

British (Jon Schofield)
Norwegian (Kjetil Broch)
German (Luis Brethauer)

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

Jerney, abcd123 and Spanishcatalan got it right. The correct answer is so

British (Jon Schofield)
Norwegian (Kjetil Broch)
German (Luis Brethauer)

I'm very surprised the second one is Norwegian - he just seems odd in any country, but out of the 3 I would say British for sure! As for the other two, I'm not surprised the third one is German and I am definitely not surprised the first one is British...

[blubb]

Just going by probabilities here...
1) German (probably North)
2) Norwegian (natural peroxide blonde hair on adult male natives simply doesn't exist at least here in the South-West)
3) British (because the highest amount of red hair can be found on those isles)

[Dylan]

1. British
2. German
3. Norwegian

[Dylan]

Jerney, abcd123 and Spanishcatalan got it right. The correct answer is so

British (Jon Schofield)
Norwegian (Kjetil Broch)
German (Luis Brethauer)

the German guy would pass as Norwegian very well. Of course this isn't much of a surprise, but he would pass much better than most germans.

[Deneb]

Interestingly most people guessed the German guy, but mixed the british up with the norwegian guy.

[Imamudin]

number 2 does not have ginger hair at all, by any stretch of the imagination.

number 1 has '' pinker skin'' than 2nd????

pink skin has never been a select British thing?

Of course, you are just used to it, but British people are worldwide known for having a pink skin.

[Imamudin]

No,the first one looks far more british than the second.

They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.

[Dr. Robotnik the Subbotnik]

They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.

How can the third not be British? I thought he looked really British.

[jerney]

the chinky eyes gave away the Norwegian for me. Of course you can find Brits with chinky eyes too, but the eyes plus the angular/sharp features and platinum hair had to mean Norway

[joshua rumble]

Of course, you are just used to it, but British people are worldwide known for having a pink skin.
ugh no i think you have no idea what you are talking about tbh i have seen many people from all over northern Europe through travel and pink skin is not isolated to uk by any means,
some of the most pink skin people i have seen have been from Iceland

They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.
what i see people like him everyday????

[blubb]

They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.

I noticed it already in this thread half a year ago: http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?165990-The-Germanic-populations-according-to-Eurogenes-K13
Do you think we are a Slavic people or something? We're not as Eastern as you think, there's a bigger genetic gap between us and Poles than there is between us and even Iberians, let alone French, Benelux and Britain. Of course I say that as a West German (I'm personally 1/16 Slav max but people still sometimes notice it because it's such an exotic component in our area!), East Germans have some Germanised West Slav and Baltic in them, making them so different from us that French are closer to us than they are to us, genetically

[Imamudin]

How can the third not be British? I thought he looked really British.

Not so much, more Central Germanic.

[abcd123]

They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.

The second one can have a slight British vibe,especially to a foreigner,but his look would be somewhat uncommon.Freckles and platinum blonde hair aren't very common in UK,the freckled ones are usually Scots and Irish,and the are usually ginger not blonde.

[Alessio]

The last one looks Dutch too

[Imamudin]

I noticed it already in this thread half a year ago: http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?165990-The-Germanic-populations-according-to-Eurogenes-K13
Do you think we are a Slavic people or something? We're not as Eastern as you think, there's a bigger genetic gap between us and Poles than there is between us and even Iberians, let alone French, Benelux and Britain. Of course I say that as a West German (I'm personally 1/16 Slav max but people still sometimes notice it because it's such an exotic component in our area!), East Germans have some Germanised West Slav and Baltic in them, making them so different from us that French are closer to us than they are to us, genetically

Sorry, I can't follow you? What do you mean?

[Deneb]

the chinky eyes gave away the Norwegian for me. Of course you can find Brits with chinky eyes too, but the eyes plus the angular/sharp features and platinum hair had to mean Norway

Those light yellow eyebrows are rare away from Scandinavia I think.

[Deneb]

The last one looks Dutch too

Very faelid indeed.

[blubb]

Sorry, I can't follow you? What do you mean?

Well then let me ask you directly: Do you think we are closer to Poles, Czechs, Russians... than we are to Brits?

[Imamudin]

Well then let me ask you directly: Do you think we are closer to Poles, Czechs, Russians... than we are to Brits?

To Poles and Czechs yes. You share a border with them, not with Britain.

[blubb]

To Poles and Czechs yes. You share a border with them, not with Britain.

Land borders aren't the same as genetic borders. There used to be a Germanic-Slavic transition area in the past, but not any more since after WW2. After the expulsion, Western Poland has been resettled by East Slavic Ukrainians and Belarusians, sharpening the Oder line
I did a K13 admixture similarity analysis back in April which you saw, today I made a brand new one considering K15 (methodology is the same as in the thread before I just linked to you), here the results for us West Germans:

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=61109&d=1442704347

As you can see, the overlap with Slavic peoples, even the most neighbouring ones such as Poles, is rather low, let alone Russians, compared to our overlap with Benelux, Britain and France

61109

[Imamudin]

Land borders aren't the same as genetic borders. There used to be a Germanic-Slavic transition area in the past, but not any more since after WW2. After the expulsion, Western Poland has been resettled by East Slavic Ukrainians and Belarusians, sharpening the Oder line
I did a K13 admixture similarity analysis back in April which you saw, today I made a brand new one considering K15 (methodology is the same as in the thread before I just linked to you), here the results for us West Germans:

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=61109&d=1442704347

As you can see, the overlap with Slavic peoples, even the most neighbouring ones such as Poles, is rather low, let alone Russians, compared to our overlap with Benelux, Britain and France

61109

No one has talked about Russians. But Germans, Poles and Czechs have mixed a lot in history. Germans have also assimilated many Slavs like Sorbs, Wends, Polabians, etc. It's more the Dutch who overlap with British people, but Germans not nearly as much.

[blubb]

No one has talked about Russians. But Germans, Poles and Czechs have mixed a lot in history. Germans have also assimilated many Slavs like Sorbs, Wends, Polabians, etc. It's more the Dutch who overlap with British people, but Germans not nearly as much.

Again, you have to keep in mind that Germany is very heterogenuous. The Slavic absorption you think of only happened in the North-East (Brandenburg, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, to a lesser extent Upper Saxony). Then there is the North and North-West (Schleswig-Holstein, Niedersachsen, parts of Nordrhein-Westfalen) which is mostly of Nordic/original Germanic stock, and additionally similar to Anglo-Saxon invaders. Then you have the South-West (Rhineland-Palatinate, parts of Hessen, Baden-Württemberg but especially left of the Rhine) where there is very high Celtic (Gaulish) admixture - being part of Rome for 500 years limited the amount of Germanic invaders from the North around here, therefore we are more similar to French, Benelux and Britain than we are to any sort of Slavs (there is no Baltid or Dinarid, let alone Uralid or Mtebid, input here, which can be found in Poles, Russians and Balkanites, at all). Lastly you have the South-East (Bavaria and Austria) which have, along the original Celtic (it was centre of Hallstatt culture) and Germanic invaders - significant Balkan (Dinarid) input.

But as I said earlier, even modern East Germans despite their Wendish input aren't similar to modern Western Poles at all, because Western Poland has been resettled with highly Siberian-admixed East Slavs

[Imamudin]

Again, you have to keep in mind that Germany is very heterogenuous. The Slavic absorption you think of only happened in the North-East (Brandenburg, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, to a lesser extent Upper Saxony). Then there is the North and North-West (Schleswig-Holstein, Niedersachsen, parts of Nordrhein-Westfalen) which is mostly of Nordic/original Germanic stock, and additionally similar to Anglo-Saxon invaders. Then you have the South-West (Rhineland-Palatinate, parts of Hessen, Baden-Württemberg but especially left of the Rhine) where there is very high Celtic (Gaulish) admixture - being part of Rome for 500 years limited the amount of Germanic invaders from the North around here, therefore we are more similar to French, Benelux and Britain than we are to any sort of Slavs (there is no Baltid or Dinarid, let alone Uralid or Mtebid, input here, which can be found in Poles, Russians and Balkanites, at all). Lastly you have the South-East (Bavaria and Austria) which have, along the original Celtic (it was centre of Hallstatt culture) and Germanic invaders - significant Balkan (Dinarid) input.

But as I said earlier, even modern East Germans despite their Wendish input aren't similar to modern Western Poles at all, because Western Poland has been resettled with highly Siberian-admixed East Slavs

And what about the millions of pre-war East Germans which went to West Germany after the war?

Baltid (proper) and Dinarid can rarely be found among Poles or West Slavs, and Uralid and Mtebid are entirely absent among them.

[blubb]

And what about the millions of pre-war East Germans which went to West Germany after the war?

Baltid (proper) and Dinarid can rarely be found among Poles or West Slavs, and Uralid and Mtebid are entirely absent among them.

While I personally do actually have some input from there, it's not that many who do here, and hasn't significantly changed the genetics. If we look at Eurogenes K15 ( https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19c_bZjUV_RouKyGyLHmMDw57WwAVabXFJOaso_gcuRE/edit#gid=1872836177 ), we get for the Baltic component (which peaks in Balto-Slavs except ex-Yu)

W German: 10.5%
N German: 13.4%
E German: 18.1%
Austrian: 18.3%

SW English: 9.7%
SE English: 9.9%
W Scottish: 10.3%
Irish 11.2%

Meanwhile:

Poland (as whole): 28.0%
S Poland: 27.0%
Russia Smolensk: 29.9%
Belarus: 32.0%
Ukraine: 27.3%

So you can see, even our Easterners aren't that Eastern (still slightly closer to British islanders than to the Westernmost Slavs), and West Slavs fit better with East Slavs than with East Germans. Unfortunately there's no Czech sample but South Poland should be a good enough proxy

You simply won't find people looking like Walujew here

[Antimage]

And what about the millions of pre-war East Germans which went to West Germany after the war?

Baltid (proper) and Dinarid can rarely be found among Poles or West Slavs, and Uralid and Mtebid are entirely absent among them.

Wrong.

[Imamudin]

While I personally do actually have some input from there, it's not that many who do here, and hasn't significantly changed the genetics. If we look at Eurogenes K15 ( https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19c_bZjUV_RouKyGyLHmMDw57WwAVabXFJOaso_gcuRE/edit#gid=1872836177 ), we get for the Baltic component (which peaks in Balto-Slavs except ex-Yu)

W German: 10.5%
N German: 13.4%
E German: 18.1%
Austrian: 18.3%

SW English: 9.7%
SE English: 9.9%
W Scottish: 10.3%
Irish 11.2%

Meanwhile:

Poland (as whole): 28.0%
S Poland: 27.0%
Russia Smolensk: 29.9%
Belarus: 32.0%
Ukraine: 27.3%

So you can see, even our Easterners aren't that Eastern (still slightly closer to British islanders than to the Westernmost Slavs), and West Slavs fit better with East Slavs than with East Germans. Unfortunately there's no Czech sample but South Poland should be a good enough proxy

You simply won't find people looking like Walujew here

I have never said Germans were related to Russians. I have only spoken about West Slavs, particularly Poles and Czechs.

[Antimage]

I have never said Germans were related to Russians. I have only spoken about West Slavs, particularly Poles and Czechs.

I'm not entirely sure about czechs, but poles look very different than germans... to me poles look more similar to balkan slavs and russian than to germans...

[Imamudin]

I'm not entirely sure about czechs, but poles look very different than germans... to me poles look more similar to balkan slavs and russian than to germans...

You have no idea what Poles look like. I have lived there and they have their own look but are much more like Germans than like Russians.

[Charles Bronson]

German
Norwegian
British

[Antimage]

You have no idea what Poles look like. I have lived there and they have their own look but are much more like Germans than like Russians.

I actually do. The poles I saw had a generic slavic look, they didn't look german at all, they were from Krakow if I remember correctly

[blubb]

I have never said Germans were related to Russians. I have only spoken about West Slavs, particularly Poles and Czechs.

And I'm telling you there's not much difference between West and East Slavs, and we are distant to both of them

[Imamudin]

And I'm telling you there's not much difference between West and East Slavs, and we are distant to both of them

Of course there is, you are just biased because you're German yourself.

[blubb]

Of course there is, you are just biased because you're German yourself.

Keep in mind I'm not talking culture etc., but genetics only - and they show what I just said unless you can provide me with other sources

[JBoscherville]

Are you kidding? The second looks typical British with that pink skin tone, freckles and ginger hair.


They both look very British actually. But the third can't be British.

Lmao, what are you talking about? The Third guy could easily be British. That second guy isn't even close to typical British, he doesn't look British at all. The first and third are the British looking ones :confused:

[joshua rumble]

You have no idea what Poles look like. I have lived there and they have their own look but are much more like Germans than like Russians.
well no every pole i have ever met has looked very Slavic to me allot more so than German.

[Äijä]

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/78897AF3-01B4-4E66-9F7A-387D59D3B64C_zpsskhjpp1t.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/78897AF3-01B4-4E66-9F7A-387D59D3B64C_zpsskhjpp1t.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/1762B8E7-709B-49A2-9B23-0D20A92ACCF3_zpsrqppdjhw.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/1762B8E7-709B-49A2-9B23-0D20A92ACCF3_zpsrqppdjhw.jpg.html)
http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j358/flallel/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/DA6574F1-49C6-4D81-B030-B0875FD19D58_zpsxr1rlptv.jpg (http://s1081.photobucket.com/user/flallel/media/Mobile%20Uploads/2015-08/DA6574F1-49C6-4D81-B030-B0875FD19D58_zpsxr1rlptv.jpg.html)

Posting without reading the thread, Norwegian, German and British, and I think it was easy.

[Imamudin]

well no every pole i have ever met has looked very Slavic to me allot more so than German.

Yes, can be, but they are both Central Europeans and had plenty of contact in history.

While the only connection Brits have to Germany are the Anglo-Saxons who are a minority in Britain since 60-80% of you are just native Britons/Celts.

[Imamudin]

Posting without reading the thread, Norwegian, German and British, and I think it was easy.

Wrong.

1. British
2. Norwegian
3. German

[joshua rumble]

Yes, can be, but they are both Central Europeans and had plenty of contact in history.

While the only connection Brits have to Germany are the Anglo-Saxons who are a minority in Britain since 60-80% of you are just native Britons/Celts.

you are so misinformed its scary, no one here seems to agree with you we are all living in the area's of discussion and your from fucking Chechnya
I cant be bothered to continue with this discussion its like talking to a brick.
You have already been linked a chart with genetic similarities between nations open your fucking eyes.

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?165990-The-Germanic-populations-according-to-Eurogenes-K13

[Imamudin]

you are so misinformed its scary, no one here seems to agree with you we are all living in the area's of discussion and your from fucking Chechnya
I cant be bothered to continue with this discussion its like talking to a brick.

I live in Germany so I must know it. British people are more like French, Spanish and Dutch people, but not so much like Germans, and least of all like North or East Germans. In Germany no one views British people as relatives or anything.

[Oneeye]

Norwegian
German
British


This was my guess.

[abcd123]

This was my guess.

Incorrect,oldie.

[Oneeye]

The arguments in these threads crack me up. xD It's a game. If none of these guys could "pass" as each others nationalities, then no one would play.

[Insuperable]

Edit:

Oops, I missed the post with correct guesses.

[blubb]

I live in Germany so I must know it. British people are more like French, Spanish and Dutch people, but not so much like Germans, and least of all like North or East Germans. In Germany no one views British people as relatives or anything.

Again, we're not talking about historical/political/cultural interactions here, but solely genetics and phenotypes, two entirely different stories. BTW do you live in Lusatia or Eastern Mecklenburg by any chance? Only there, the Slavic connection shows a little

[Äijä]

The arguments in these threads crack me up. xD It's a game. If none of these guys could "pass" as each others nationalities, then no one would play.

Agree, I can find those faces from Finland.

[joshua rumble]

I live in Germany so I must know it. British people are more like French, Spanish and Dutch people, but not so much like Germans, and least of all like North or East Germans. In Germany no one views British people as relatives or anything.

OK this is the last time i respond to you, look at the evidence before you comment your opinion
you are simply wrong
1st link show DNA correlation and similarities between nations

2nd link show similarity's only LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE


http://www.eupedia.com/europe/autosomal_maps_dodecad.shtml

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/sho...-Eurogenes-K13

[Imamudin]

Again, we're not talking about historical/political/cultural interactions here, but solely genetics and phenotypes, two entirely different stories. BTW do you live in Lusatia or Eastern Mecklenburg by any chance? Only there, the Slavic connection shows a little

Yes, Germans overlap more with West Slavs (who have significant German influence as well) than with British people.

Germans are not related to West Slavs, but a bit closer to them than to British people. How is that even a question? Germany was for centuries surrounded by Slavs, Germans have lived in Ukraine, Russia and everywhere all across Eastern Europe and all of them returned to Germany after the war.

[blubb]

Yes, Germans overlap more with West Slavs ... than with British people.

Not genetically at least, as I have shown you. You haven't posted any source confirming your claim yet while I have shown you the genetic data