Can you tell the good guys from the bad ones

[Era]

Not sure if this is the right sub forum, but I thought it could be related to taxonomy.

I will reveal answers later.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C28F00000578-0-You_wouldn_t_want_to_mix_these_two_ladies_up_one_a _society_beaut-a-9_1480368515295.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C46D00000578-0-One_of_these_women_was_a_1930s_Hollywood_star_marr ied_to_Clark_G-a-10_1480368554114.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C5CB00000578-0-From_an_icy_trek_to_a_col_heart_one_was_second_in_ command_on_Cap-a-11_1480368599413.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C66B00000578-0-Philanthropist_or_fraud_One_picture_is_one_of_the_ first_criminal-a-12_1480368613433.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C76700000578-0-One_changed_the_modern_world_by_inventing_the_Biro _while_the_oth-a-13_1480368633742.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C7DB00000578-0-It_s_healer_versus_poisoner_here_with_one_woman_a_ doctor_and_lea-a-14_1480368657491.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C7CB00000578-0-Spot_the_giver_and_taker_one_woman_was_a_violent_V ictorian_shopl-a-15_1480368675960.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/11/28/21/3AD5C82400000578-0-They_both_slicked_their_hair_back_but_one_was_vile _serial_killer-a-16_1480368696116.jpg

[Dominicanese]

i might

but honestly most women are bad

and men are 50/50 now endays

[♥ Lily ♥]

Depends what you call and mean by 'good' and 'bad'.

[Era]

Depends what you call and mean by 'good' and 'bad'.

For each row, one is is a murderer/serial killer and the other a philanthropist or scientist.

[magyar_lány]

The good guys are: 1A, 2B, 3B, 4B, 5B (MAYBE), 6A, 7B, 8A. I hope I didn't choose serial killers. ;)

[Profileid]

Bad guys:
1A
2B
3B
4A
5A
6B
7A
8A

[MellowD]

B G
B G
G B
B G
B G
G B
B G
B G

[Spyy]

2A for sure
3B
4A
5B
6A
7A (like 1A) and 8A sadic face

[Sakis]

Good

1A
2A
3B
4B
5A
6A
7B
8B

[Charles Bronson]

The woman in your signature is the most baddest.

[Poise n Pen]

Bad:
1B
2A
3B
4A
5 Tie but I will say A
6B
7B
8B

[Queen B]

Bad ?
1B
2A
3B
4A
5A
6B
7A
8A

[Seya]

B G
G B
G B
B G
G B
G B
B G
B G

[Seth MacFarlane]

For each row, one is is a murderer/serial killer and the other a philanthropist or scientist.

As if philanthropists and scientists cant be murderers xD

[Amud]

This is interesting, but it's a difficult exercise. We know from studies that people are fairly good at telling apart smart from dumb people, or ethical people from unethical people, but that isn't going on here. Serial killers can be very smart, and philanthropists and even scientists can be very unethical. I predict that it will be very hard for anyone to guess with accuracy much better than random.

[Dylan]

Good guys

1A
2A
3B
4B
5A
6A
7A
8b

really have no idea, just guesses based on facial features and expressions, which doesn't say enough, but thought i'd give it a go

[Hadouken]

1-B = bad

2-B = bad

3-B = bad

4-B = bad

5-A = bad

6-A = bad

7-B = bad

8-B = bad

how well did I do ?

[Poise n Pen]

This is interesting, but it's a difficult exercise. We know from studies that people are fairly good at telling apart smart from dumb people, or ethical people from unethical people, but that isn't going on here. Serial killers can be very smart, and philanthropists and even scientists can be very unethical. I predict that it will be very hard for anyone to guess with accuracy much better than random.

I let a guy who lost his job stay in my garage a couple months one time. Turned out later he is a possible serial killer. I was completely fooled and he looked much more like a wholesome person than any of the people in these pics.

[Era]

This is interesting, but it's a difficult exercise. We know from studies that people are fairly good at telling apart smart from dumb people, or ethical people from unethical people, but that isn't going on here. Serial killers can be very smart, and philanthropists and even scientists can be very unethical. I predict that it will be very hard for anyone to guess with accuracy much better than random.

I picked right 7/8. The only one I picked wrong the good person looks like somebody I dislike so that influenced my response. I will bring the article that comes with this

[MissProvocateur]

I'm going to be awful at this, but here we go. Bad guys:

1B
2A --- Was originally going to say the other, but she looks more like an actress.
3B
4A
5A
6B
7A
Uhh... Not sure about the last one. I'm going to guess 8A? The smile throws me off a little.

[Atvend]

1. Hard to tell, 1A's pose seems more like a forced facade therefore I'm going with 1A as bad.

2. My first reaction is 2B, that is the expression of pure self-absorption, but then I notice the quality of the photo. Probably some kind of a exhibitive celebrity. 2A bad, but only through power of deduction.

3. 3A's expression emanates ambition and noble motivations, 3B bad, but only through power of deduction.

4. I recognize one of the men.

5. Difficult to tell, 5A seems like a more down to earth, realist kind of person, therefore probably more capable of killing. 5A bad.

6. Without a shadow of a doubt 6B, half covered irises.

7. Weird, forced expression vs noble-ish attire and the impression of a maintained woman. 7A bad.

8. The smile seems unhinged, but is probably trying to throw us off. 8B bad.

[Poise n Pen]

I picked right 7/8. The only one I picked wrong the good person looks like somebody I dislike so that influenced my response. I will bring the article that comes with this

http://www.malevole.com/mv/misc/killerquiz/

Try this one.

[Era]

http://www.malevole.com/mv/misc/killerquiz/

Try this one.

http://i66.tinypic.com/el86ye.jpg

[Era]

Okay here's your answers. Spoilers for others who want to try also

1A Ruth Ellis – murderer, 1B Lillie Langtry – actress,
2A Irma Grese – Nazi SS guard, 2B Carole Lombard – Hollywood actress,
3A Admiral Edward ‘Teddy’ Evans – adventurer and hero, 3B John Haigh – murderer,
4A George Perry – con-artist who posed as a vicar, 4B John D Rockefeller – businessman/philanthropist,
5A Adolf Eichmann – Nazi war criminal, 5B Lazlo Biro – pen inventor,
6A Elizabeth Garrett Anderson – hospital founder 6B Mary Ann Cotton – serial killer
7A Lilian Rose Kendall – gangster known as the bobbed-haired bandit (pic of bob - hair) 7B Margaret Davies – philanthropist (pic of woman wearing hat)
8A Peter Manuel – mass murdering rapist, 8B EF Turby-Wells – engineer/inventor.



And the article

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3980130/So-s-goodie-baddie-really-tell-wrong-just-face-s-lips-eyes.html

[MellowD]

http://www.malevole.com/mv/misc/killerquiz/

Try this one.

It wasn't that hard...

https://s13.postimg.org/iq0e4vlqf/ssss.png

[DarknessWin]

B G
B G
G B
B G
B G
G B
B G
B G

Agree

Evil psychos are 1A,2A,3B,4A,5A,6B,7A,8A

[Annie999]

Serial killers:
1B - Hard to tell, but there's something in B's face that's unsettling.
2B - she looks evil, and also not a type of picture a scientist would take.
3A - weird murderer face
4A - I dont trust that stare
5B - creepy eyes
6A - hard one, but that smirk..
7A - these are the lips of a serial killer
8B - 'A' looks bad but it's a facade, B is the serial killer

Did I getit right? :p

Edit: I only got 2 right :lol:

[Iloko]

G - B
B - G
G - B
B - G
B - G
G - B
B - G
B - G

Can't wait for the reveal

Edit: I only got #1 wrong! :) yay

[Argentano]

the only ones i guessed correct where 7a and 8a

[Annie999]

I let a guy who lost his job stay in my garage a couple months one time. Turned out later he is a possible serial killer. I was completely fooled and he looked much more like a wholesome person than any of the people in these pics.

That's scary

[crazyladybutterfly]

hard to tell from just pictures... it's sometimes noticeable when a person is trying to play as the "good guy" while being totally the opposite .. but not always just look at bill clinton and at his huge charisma .. then look at what he has done.

anyway this is only a game so let me guess :

1 : B
2: A
3: B
4: B
5: B
6: A
7: B
8: A

[crazyladybutterfly]

I let a guy who lost his job stay in my garage a couple months one time. Turned out later he is a possible serial killer. I was completely fooled and he looked much more like a wholesome person than any of the people in these pics.

THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU TRUST WHITE PEOPLE

[Petalpusher]

All the A row, is bad.

[Hithaeglir]

Bad:

1A
2A
3B
4A
5B
6B
7A
8A

[Faklon]

When you compare serial killers with bankids it can get kinda hard I suppose.

[Ülev]

...

[♥ Lily ♥]

Ruth Ellis, (the last woman to be executed in the UK before Capital Punishment was abolished in Britain,) still has public sympathy from people in the UK as many people don't see her as a 'bad' person, but rather someone who was involved in a 'Crime of Passion.' She was emotionally pushed over-the-edge. People protested against her being hanged in Holloway Prison in North London, and some people to this day are still petitioning for Ruth Ellis to be pardoned by the UK government.

Ruth would not stop talking about her love for the man she killed until the day she was hanged at age 28. She said she wanted to die because she felt so heartbroken.

Her lover was said to have treated her cruelly and their unborn baby died when he punched her in the stomach causing her to have a miscarriage, and then in an act of revenge, she shot her cruel lover dead outside of the famous Magdala pub in north London (the pub is still there to this day.) Then she calmly waited for the police and admitted to shooting him and said she loved the man that she killed, but she said he had hurt both her and their baby.

She wasn't a serial killer;- she killed one man who punched their unborn baby to death.

http://www.camdennewjournal.com/sites/all/files/nj_camden/images/reviews/books/02-ruth%20ellis%20cutout_0.jpg?1347555768
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/42/94/03/429403d5cb0ed009365a8caf0cd7dbaf.jpg


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZW7lWebhZQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyrgmzLTzGc

[Era]

[...]

She was a prostitute who had previously aborted babies, including Blakely's and killed him, Blakely, in cold blood.

Ellis became pregnant for the fourth time but aborted the child, feeling she could not reciprocate the level of commitment shown by Blakely towards their relationship.[5]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruth_Ellis

[Bezprym]

Good:

1 A
2 A
3 B
4 B
5 A
6 A
7 A
8 A

Unless you already revealed the truth.

[Oneeye]

Good: B,A,A,B,B,A,B,B

[The Blade]

Killers:
1 - B
2 - A
3 - B
4 - A
5 - A
6 - B
7 - B
8 - people would expect to be A but I'll say B just to make it more interesting and because things are not always what they appear
Edit: I understood I have 5/8 correct.

[The Illyrian Warrior]

Interesting thread, tough call but I'll try.
Good ones:
1. A
2. A
3. A
4. B
5. A
6. not clear pic but I go with - A
7. B
8. B

PS. 5 out 8 got it right.

[The Blade]

http://www.malevole.com/mv/misc/killerquiz/

Try this one.
Interesting. Got 8/10 on it.

[Oneeye]

Wait, did I get all of them right? :D

[Marzipan]

I know some of these faces.

[GoneWithTheWind]

Bad guys:
1A
2B
3B
4A
5A
6B
7A
8A

Probably Christians

[Amud]

I let a guy who lost his job stay in my garage a couple months one time. Turned out later he is a possible serial killer. I was completely fooled and he looked much more like a wholesome person than any of the people in these pics.

Whoa, sounds like quite the story

[Mortimer]

good idea for a thread the good ones are 1a, 2a, 3a, 4b, 5b, 6b, 7b, 8b