Or this group could pass ?

[Anonymous211]

https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2017/03/16/19/afghan-girls-iran.jpg

[Hadouken]

huh ?

[lameduck]

they look iranians to me

[Hadouken]

they look iranians to me

what ? really ?

they dont look iranian at all

[Squall Leonhart]

Afghanistan or Pakistan IMO.

[Milo]

They can't pass outside Iran.

[lameduck]

Afghanistan or Pakistan IMO.

not really they look Iranian/arabs

[Hadouken]

iranian arabs maybe or something . if they end up being iranian then I am surprised . the iranians we have here in germany look very very different . but Iran is a big country with several ethnic groups so who knows .

[Squall Leonhart]

not really they look Iranian/arabs

Not sure what you mean. They could pass in Southern Iran perhaps and maybe Yemen or Oman.

[crazyladybutterfly]

yemenite

[Newsboy]

Southern to eastern Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and North India is where they pass

[RN97]

yemenite

+1

[Squall Leonhart]

Southern to eastern Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and North India is where they pass

They have a Northern South Asian Muslim look.

[Xacal]

Arabia

[Shah-Jehan]

Sindh & Balochistan.




iranian arabs maybe or something . if they end up being iranian then I am surprised . the iranians we have here in germany look very very different . but Iran is a big country with several ethnic groups so who knows .

The picture says they are Afghan immigrants in Iran.

[Squall Leonhart]

Sindh & Balochistan.





The picture says they are Afghan immigrants in Iran.

That explains it.

[RN97]

Sindh & Balochistan.





The picture says they are Afghan immigrants in Iran.

No offence to MA, he's mah nigga and stuff, but this is not how he claimed Afghans looked, lol.

[Squall Leonhart]

No offence to MA, he's mah nigga and stuff, but this is not how he claimed Afghans looked, lol.

What did he claim?

[Hadouken]

Sindh & Balochistan.





The picture says they are Afghan immigrants in Iran.

afghan wouldnt have been my guess either . I thought Jordan or gulf Arab countries or something

[Milo]

They can't pass outside Iran.

[Squall Leonhart]

They can't pass outside Iran.

They can pass in the Gulf Arab regions, Southern Levant(maybe), Afghanistan, Pakistan, and as Indian Muslims IMO.

[Shah-Jehan]

afghan wouldnt have been my guess either . I thought Jordan or gulf Arab countries or something

Well, lookwise maybe, but you can see Salwar Kameez in the background, so it would have to be something like Iran to India, Arabs don't wear that stuff.


and when I google Afghan children, I get these pics, pretty different, but fits the diversity IMO.

https://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&site=imghp&tbm=isch&source=hp&biw=1366&bih=662&q=afghan+children&oq=afghan+ch&gs_l=img.3.0.0l7j0i10k1j0l2.106.1633.0.2395.9.6.0. 3.3.0.79.424.6.6.0....0...1ac.1.64.img..0.9.429.X9 JiIHRXFIQ

[RN97]

What did he claim?

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?199546-Which-European-Near-Eastern-and-New-World-ethnicities-can-AFGHANS-pass-as

[Philip Latinowitz]

Yemen/ they have some horner influence in phenotypes

[Hadouken]

Well, lookwise maybe, but you can see Salwar Kameez in the background, so it would have to be something like Iran to India, Arabs don't wear that stuff.

hmm ok but I dont know such clothes so I couldnt tell lol

[Squall Leonhart]

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?199546-Which-European-Near-Eastern-and-New-World-ethnicities-can-AFGHANS-pass-as

He has OWD and was banned several times on Anthroscape and also Forumbiodiversity(as user Pakistani maybe) for trolling. Why would you take him seriously?

s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/profile/1873808/

s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/profile/2151121/

[RN97]

He has OWD and was banned several times on Anthroscape and also Forumbiodiversity(as user Pakistani maybe) for trolling. Why would you take him seriously?

He def. didn't seem like a troll to me. I have not seen many Afghans IRL, I doubted him at first, but kinda just gave up and took his word for it. Obv. not that they look like those light haired/eyed folks, but those other that he posted that are quite lighter than those in OP here.

[Milo]

http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?199546-Which-European-Near-Eastern-and-New-World-ethnicities-can-AFGHANS-pass-aslmao not just that, after posting those people he said this
http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?199546-Which-European-Near-Eastern-and-New-World-ethnicities-can-AFGHANS-pass-as&p=4160864&viewfull=1#post4160864

[Hadouken]

how is this 1 pic of a few afghan kids more representative than the pics MA posted ? that doesnt make sense either

owight gavnah posted many afghans . they are representative

[Squall Leonhart]

He def. didn't seem like a troll to me. I have not seen many Afghans IRL, I doubted him at first, but kinda just gave up and took his word for it. Obv. not that they look like those light haired/eyed folks, but those other that he posted that are quite lighter than those in OP here.

They have both light and dark people. However the OP skin color is not uncommon and if anything isn't even that dark.

[RN97]

how is this 1 pic of a few afghan kids more representative than the pics MA posted ? that doesnt make sense either

owight gavnah posted many afghans . they are representative

I'm not saying that they are, but how much can a group of 6-9 kids differ from the average? Certainly more representative than the individuals he posted..... It's hard to cherrypick groups.

[Squall Leonhart]

Which ones did 'owight gavanah post? I wouldn't take someone who creates 100s of socks on different Anthro forums(and Allempire) seriously. Lol.

[Hadouken]

I'm not saying that they are, but how much can a group of 6-9 kids differ from the average? Certainly more representative than the individuals he posted..... It's hard to cherrypick groups.

afghanistan is a big country plus has several different ethnic groups . it is not easy to make a uniform look for them . however as I said owight gavnah has posted a lot of afghan guys including many football players . the reason why people want to see these girl from OP as more typical is because they dont want afghans to go out of the curry border of imagination aka "you have to be in the same boat as us you understand ?!!!!!" . which is way more racist and owd than people like MA . nothing more nothing less .

[RN97]

lmao not just that, after posting those people he said this
http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?199546-Which-European-Near-Eastern-and-New-World-ethnicities-can-AFGHANS-pass-as&p=4160864&viewfull=1#post4160864

It depends on what he means by "really pale". Certainly there are no brown Romanians, but some have olive skin, I guess that's not pale to the average European. I can't see any non-Europeans considering Romanians dark by any measure.

[Hadouken]

Which ones did 'owight gavanah post? I wouldn't take someone who creates 100s of socks on different Anthro forums(and Allempire) seriously. Lol.

how many sock accounts do you have though ? to be fair

[Squall Leonhart]

how many sock accounts do you have though ? to be fair

On Anthroscape, I had two accounts. I lost the password to the first one(barely posted) and then I made a second account. First account here. On FBH I had two accounts and then I lost the password to the first one(never posted) and then I made a second one.

[RN97]

afghanistan is a big country plus has several different ethnic groups . it is not easy to make a uniform look for them . however as I said owight gavnah has posted a lot of afghan guys including many football players . the reason why people want to see these girl from OP as more typical is because they dont want afghans to go out of the curry border of imagination aka "you have to be in the same boat as us you understand ?!!!!!" . which is way more racist and owd than people like MA . nothing more nothing less .

My impression of Afghans was that they were somewhere between Iranians and Pathans (the Pashtuns at least). I'm not saying that they're Indians or something, but people tend to forget that a lot of Pakis look Afghan due to Pathans, so what's wrong with saying they have some connection to Pakis looks wise? He made them out to be Armenians or Kurds with some Euro looking people basically, how's that fair?
http://s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/topic/5884614/1/
Owight dude might be accurate.

[Hadouken]

On Anthroscape, I had two accounts. I lost the password to the first one(barely posted) and then I made a second account. First account here. On FBH I had two accounts and then I lost the password to the first one(never posted) and then I made a second one.

nice bro very nice

[Squall Leonhart]

My impression of Afghans was that they were somewhere between Iranians and Pathans (the Pashtuns at least). I'm not saying that they're Indians or something, but people tend to forget that a lot of Pakis look Afghan due to Pathans, so what's wrong with saying they have some connection to Pakis looks wise? He made them out to be Armenians or Kurds with some Euro looking people basically, how's that fair?
http://s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/topic/5884614/1/
Owight dude might be accurate.

Afghan Pashtuns and Pakistani Pashtuns are the exact same ethnicity. The Afghan ones are more Turkic influenced from Central Asia(only slightly) and are more Persianized in culture. Other than that there is no difference. And Pashtuns genetically cluster to their neighbors. Baloch are the most Iranian group in the region anyways.

[Milo]

It depends on what he means by "really pale". Certainly there are no brown Romanians, but some have olive skin, I guess that's not pale to the average European. I can't see any non-Europeans considering Romanians dark by any measure.That was not what I meant at all.
He's posted people like this
http://i56.tinypic.com/rhpufn.jpg
.
It is not humanly possible to be significantly paler than people like this

[Squall Leonhart]

That was not what I meant at all.
He's posted people like this
http://i56.tinypic.com/rhpufn.jpg
.
It is not humanly possible to be significantly paler than people like that

That guy is Pakistani:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/e2fvv/i_am_a_white_pakistani_pathan_i_have_pale_skin/

[Hadouken]

My impression of Afghans was that they were somewhere between Iranians and Pathans (the Pashtuns at least). I'm not saying that they're Indians or something, but people tend to forget that a lot of Pakis look Afghan due to Pathans, so what's wrong with saying they have some connection to Pakis looks wise? He made them out to be Armenians or Kurds with some Euro looking people basically, how's that fair?
http://s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/topic/5884614/1/
Owight dude might be accurate.

IMO Afghans have their own look somehow . many look like Persians too . not many can pass as Kurdish ..at least not in my area because I have seen enough to be sure of this (most footballers owight posted wouldnt pass either and look rather foreign to me) . I also have seen indid afghans ...but they tbh pashtuns/tajiks are their own thing and look their own thing . they have some indid and some north caucasus / balkan / even russian kind of people but both are not the norm

nothing more nothing less . they are neither much close to us only because they are iranic nor are they like indians only because they are geographically near there

[Milo]

That guy is Pakistani:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/e2fvv/i_am_a_white_pakistani_pathan_i_have_pale_skin/LOL so he's fine with posting pakistani pashtuns as afghans when they're pale, but not otherwise

[Squall Leonhart]

LOL so he's fine with posting pakistani pashtuns as afghans when they're pale, but not otherwise

Pashtun meant Afghan historically and Afghan/Pakistani ones are the same. Saying they are different is like saying Pakistani Punjabis and Indian ones are radically different.

[RN97]

IMO Afghans have their own look somehow . many look like Persians too . not many can pass as Kurdish ..at least not in my area because I have seen enough to be sure of this (most footballers owight posted wouldnt pass either and look rather foreign to me) . I also have seen indid afghans ...but they tbh pashtuns/tajiks are their own thing and look their own thing . they have some indid and some north caucasus / balkan / even russian kind of people but both are not the norm

nothing more nothing less . they are neither much close to us only because they are iranic nor are they like indians only because they are geographically near there

I've never seen a Pashtun pass for Russian TBH :p

[Shah-Jehan]

That guy is Pakistani:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/e2fvv/i_am_a_white_pakistani_pathan_i_have_pale_skin/

He does this regularly.

For e.g., in this thread http://www.forumbiodiversity.com/showthread.php/46237-Phenotypical-diversity-of-Afghans-Pashtuns

He wrote "Afghans" but posts the Chief Minister of KPK, Pakistan, Pervez Khattak

http://i1159.photobucket.com/albums/p633/drcypriot084/Mobile%20Uploads/pervez-khattak_zpsf8oc8wmk.jpg


also some random Pakistani model from Lahore, Punjab, Abdullah Ejaz,

http://i1159.photobucket.com/albums/p633/drcypriot084/Mobile%20Uploads/Abdullah-Ejaz-Top-Class-Model_zpsogsh3hlq.jpg


and God knows who else.

[Hadouken]

I've never seen a Pashtun pass for Russian TBH :p

thats because I am lying of course hehehehe :o . jk ...there are trust me

[Squall Leonhart]

Many Pashtuns look Nord-Indid.

[RN97]

He does this regularly.

For e.g., in this thread http://www.forumbiodiversity.com/showthread.php/46237-Phenotypical-diversity-of-Afghans-Pashtuns

He wrote "Afghans" but posts the Chief Minister of KPK, Pakistan, Pervez Khattak

http://i1159.pho/drcypriot084/Mobile%20Uploads/pervez-khattak_zpsf8oc8wmk.jpg


also some random Pakistani model from Lahore, Punjab, Abdullah Ejaz,

http://i1159.photobucket.com/albums/p633/drcypriot084/Mobile%20Uploads/Abdullah-Ejaz-Top-Class-Model_zpsogsh3hlq.jpg


and God knows who else.
He looks Norwegian, lol
http://i.imgur.com/O6hEumH.jpg

[Hadouken]

Many Pashtuns look Nord-Indid.

I worked with a guy who I guessed as hazara and he said he was pashtun

[Squall Leonhart]

He looks Norwegian, lol
http://i.imgur.com/O6hEumH.jpg

That is a lightened picture of Abdullah. He is darker in actuality.

http://s1.zetaboards.com/anthroscape/topic/5774784/1/

^ :lol: Have no idea what happened at the end.


I worked with a guy who I guessed as hazara and he said he was pashtun

Hazaras looks Mongoloid. lol What is your point? If you are trying to say the darker South Asian looking Afghans are Hazaras you're wrong because they are lighter than Pashtuns based on my experience and look Central Asian.

[Milo]

He looks Norwegian, lol
http://i.imgur.com/O6hEumH.jpgNo, this Norwegian happens to look like him.

[Hadouken]

Hazaras looks Mongoloid. lol What is your point? If you are trying to say the darker South Asian looking Afghans are Hazaras you're wrong because they are lighter than Pashtuns based on my experience and look Central Asian.

I know how hazaras look . one of my close friends is hazara

I didnt tell you that to prove any point . just wanted to share it because I find it interesting . the guy said he is afghan pashtun (which he probably was but I dont know) but looked hazara

[Squall Leonhart]

I know how hazaras look . one of my close friends is hazara

I didnt tell you that to prove any point . just wanted to share it because I find it interesting . the guy said he is afghan pashtun (which he probably was but I dont know) but looked hazara

Many have mixed, bro. Plus Pashtuns in Afghanistan have Mongoloid mixture.

[Hadouken]

Many have mixed, bro. Plus Pashtuns in Afghanistan have Mongoloid mixture.

they have more baltic admix than mongoloid . would you call them lithuanian too ?

the thing is that as I said pashtuns/tajiks look like pashtun/tajiks before anything else . only because there are people like the man who I just told about who might not even be really pashtun or mixed as you say ...it doesnt say anything . you know what I mean ?

[Shah-Jehan]

Many have mixed, bro. Plus Pashtuns in Afghanistan have Mongoloid mixture.

They don't, atleast on average, but Tajiks do. However, many Pashtuns can have epicanthal fold, probably an adaption to the mountains/hills.

e.g. Ayub Khan (Pakistani Pashtun, Tarin Tribe)

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/Muhammed_Ayub_Khan.JPG

or Imran Khan (Pakistani Pashtun, Niazi Tribe)
https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/imran-khan.jpg

[Squall Leonhart]

They don't, atleast on average, but Tajiks do. However, many Pashtuns can have epicanthal fold, probably an adaption to the mountains/hills.

e.g. Ayub Khan (Pakistani Pashtun, Tarin Tribe)

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/Muhammed_Ayub_Khan.JPG

or Imran Khan (Pakistani Pashtun, Niazi Tribe)
https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/imran-khan.jpg

In some areas there is mixture. however Tajiks are usually the more Mongoloid ones. I agree.

[Shah-Jehan]

In some areas there is mixture. however Tajiks are usually the more Mongoloid ones. I agree.

Highly doubt that, very few if any for Pashtuns. In real life, none of them look "mongoloid" to me, but a lot of Tajiks do. In Canada, afghans here are disproportionately Tajiks, and a lot can display such features within families. Some of my good friends have been Tajiks, they didnt look "mong" themselves but I've seen a lot of their family, and they show it.

[Squall Leonhart]

Highly doubt that, very few if any for Pashtuns. In real life, none of them look "mongoloid" to me, but a lot of Tajiks do. In Canada, afghans here are disproportionately Tajiks, and a lot can display such features within families. Some of my good friends have been Tajiks, they didnt look "mong" themselves but I've seen a lot of their family, and they show it.

Many Tajiks and Pashtuns have mixed though. Kabul in particular.