WTF ? Gedrosia calculator is fraud as shit

[gültekin]

Revenia Central Greece: Z394045

puntDNAL K12 Ancient Oracle

Kit Z394045

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 Anatolian_NF 56.62
2 European_HG 43.38

while :

Eurasia K14 Neolithic Oracle results:
Eurasia K14 Neolithic Oracle

Kit Z394045

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 Afansievo_Yamnaya 97.73
2 N_Amerindian 2.27

[gültekin]

2. razib khanoid
http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?207074-Indians-!-are-Yamnaya-(FTDNA)

[gültekin]

In 2014, he was a Kurd from North Iraq and his results were typical for a North Iraqi Kurd
"Here are my results for comparison. I am Kurmanji from N. Iraq."
http://www.anthrogenica.com/showthre...ll=1#post59840
https://i.hizliresim.com/1L90YD.png

Then in 2015, he mutated into a South Asian and his results became Balochi-like
http://www.anthrogenica.com/showthread.php?6112-Post-Eurasia-9-ASI-CHG-results&p=129520&viewfull=1#post129520
https://i.hizliresim.com/7qOp4v.png

[gültekin]

https://i.hizliresim.com/M0z46Q.png

[Hadouken]

he has been confronted already for that a few times ...also by Kurdish members . he is not a Kurd obviously and his results are very different from us .he is if I recall right either half kurd half pakistani OR from Balochistan and belongs to a tribe called "kurd" . one of the 2 . I didnt confront him though because I have given up with such things . there is no way to do anything against it . next thing you know there will be a malaysian guy saying he is kurdish and clustering with andids

but I dont understand your opening post and why the calculators are supposed to be frauding

[gültekin]

he has been confronted already for that a few times ...also by Kurdish members . he is not a Kurd obviously and his results are very different from us .he is if I recall right either half kurd half pakistani OR from Balochistan and belongs to a tribe called "kurd" . one of the 2 . I didnt confront him though because I have given up with such things . there is no way to do anything against it . next thing you know there will be a malaysian guy saying he is kurdish and clustering with andids

but I dont understand your opening post and why the calculators are supposed to be frauding
he could be even irish, who the fuck knows ?
the components what he use-created, is not what he named, check the op

[Hadouken]

he could be even irish, who the fuck knows ?
the components what he use-created, is not what he named, check the op

I am not knowledged enough to judge :-/

but are there any gedrosiadna calculators that you find good ? or do you find all of them bad ?

[Pahli]

I think the gedmatch kit has very few SNPs which gives it horrible results, here it is with MDLP World 22:

Kit Z394045

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 Atlantic_Mediterranean_Neolithic 50.81
2 Near_East 25.56
3 North-East-European 7.43
4 Sub-Saharian 6.39
5 West-Asian 6.08
6 East-South-Asian 2.4
7 Austronesian 0.78
8 Pygmy 0.38
9 Indo-Tibetan 0.17