Anglojew
03-17-2018, 10:08 AM
Please find the previous cached versions here (https://web.archive.org/web/20170117044838/http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?63590-My-Middle-East-peace-plan), here (https://web.archive.org/web/20140220083927/http://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?78147-My-Middle-East-Peace-Plan-(Part-2)&highlight=middle-east+peace+plan), here & here (https://web.archive.org/web/20170117044829/https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?118770-My-Middle-East-Peace-Plan%2599-Part-4-A-Palestinian-Persective-of-how-Greater-Israel-will-work).
Anglojew's Middle East Peace Plan
There seems to be no end in sight to the Arab-Israeli conflict which has gone on now for over a century. Although peace treaties now exist between Egypt and Israel and Jordan and Israel peace between Israel and the Southern Syrians now known as "Palestinians" alludes both parties. It is obvious that we need to look outside the box to find a solution.
My solution is multi-faceted but not too complicated and I believe will lead to real peace in the region.
My proposals are;
1. For Gaza to unite with Egypt like 1948-1967 (made even more easy with the Muslim brotherhood ruling both now as well as clan ties between the two [at the time of writing this]).
2. Complete Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank, East Jerusalem (with the the Jewish quarter of the old city etc [Mt Scopus] retained by Israel) as well as some minor land swaps along the "green line" as the 1967 border is an armistice line of cessation of fighting in 1948 rather than an official border and doesn't take topography for example. A wall/fence could be built along the border until both parties reach a state of mutual trust.
3. Palestine (West Bank)/Jordan economic (possibly political) federation as in 1948-1967. Jordan to control the West Bank's defence so the Israeli-Jordan peace treaty remains in force.
Why would Israel withdraw given the previous track record of land-for-peace not working after Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon and Gaza and only leading to increased violence from the Arabs? Because...
4. In return for complete withdrawal from said lands Israel gets a second territory, the world's little known other Jewish State; the Jewish Autonomous Oblast to be officially confederated with Israel as another state of the same nation.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140625232609im_/http://www.roitov.com/articles/jewishstate.jpg
This is a win-win situation. The Palestinians get their country and can federate with Jordan if they want. Fatah (The PA's ruling political party) suggested this as late as last week.
Israel gets more land for any it withdraws from as well as a trading base on the Chinese border; something any country would love in this "Chinese" century.
Russia gets the international prestige of forever solving the Middle East conflict thus obtaining even more favour with the region. Israel might even "buy" the State (like Alaska) but since its already meant to be for Jews this is debatable. It also gets a very valuable Israeli presence helping to defend its border against Chinese invasion of Siberia which is a very real possibility this century given increasing Chinese power and decreasing Russian population as well as increased Chinese migration to Siberia.
A happy situation for all.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140227062551im_/http://www.solargeneral.com/mirrors/national-vanguard/www.nationalvanguard.org/images/teaser/russia_israel_map.gif
In part one of my Middle-East Peace plan I outlined the steps necessary for true peace between Israel and the Palestinians (and other Arabs). To summerise, each people need to recognise the others territory and rights both on their own and each others land.
-Israeli final borders will be made up of territory within the 1967 borders (with minor adjustment as well as the Jewish Autonomous Oblast bordering China).
-Jerusalem will be shared along the 1967 borders with the old city ruled by both but full protection of religious rights guaranteed.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140225182502im_/http://www.geschichteinchronologie.ch/SU/EncJud_Birobidzhan-d/karte06-Birobidschan-orte-u-fluesse-2000ca.gif
-Palestine's final borders will be made up of Gaza, the West Bank and Jordan (with the Jordanian King acting as Head of State) but democracy in place eg a Prime Minister in real power.
Part Two of my peace plan is for Israel and Palestine/Jordan to form an economic confederation.
While neither all Jews nor all Palestinians may like it, Jews and Palestinians are intertwined and heavily related. 80% of Palestinians are of Jewish origin and about 80% of Jordan is Palestinian. Eventually a form of economic confederation will be the best solution for both Palestinians and Israelis. Obviously, the details need to be worked out but the two sides cannot ignore each other. I suggest foreign policy and defense be handled separately but many issues like infrastructure; power, water, housing, public transport as well as economic issues should be mutual. Health and education should be combined with religious issues (divorce, marriage, religious education etc) decided by each religious community (as is already the case in Israel).
Since Jews and Palestinians are closely related it's only natural that they should combine forces eventually. The current situation is no good for anyone and I think has been a mistake on the part of both groups who focused too much on differences and not on their unique shared commonality. There will still be a Palestine and an Israel but cooperation between the two on many important issues is to the mutual benefit of both peoples and bring both groups together eventually forming a solid partnership.
Greater Israel - A Practical Guide
By now regular readers of this forum will be aware that I've solved the so-called "Arab-Israeli" dispute by formulating My Middle-East Peace Plan™ and readers will also be aware of the need for a Greater Israel to unite the various Israelite descended peoples -for it is now a well known fact that Palestinians (Druze) and others- descend, like their Jewish brethren, from Israelites. My plan is the only one that takes into account historical, genetic AND religious issues, overcomes any problems AND unites all peoples under one identity.
After much consideration I've decided that Greater Israel shall maintain current Israeli laws (especially pertaining to each religion controlling their own births, deaths and marriages) but shall introduce a political system similar to Belgium. Greater Israel shall be a politically unified federal state, composed of states and provinces, with each having local economic autonomy.
The Federal State nevertheless retains important powers, for example in the area of foreign affairs, national defence, justice, finance, social security, important parts of national health and domestic affairs. However, the states and provinces have control over religious, local health and education and local economic matters.
It's interesting that both Jews and Palestinians present identities relate to the same land but during different historical epochs (Judea and Palestina respecitively). Besides the genetic kinship of Jews and Palestinians, from an Islamic perspective, reclaiming Palestinians true Israelite heritage as Bani Isra'il (Arabic:بني إسرائيل) is justified by The Quran, chapter 17 (Al-Isra), verse 104:
“ And thereafter We [Allah] said to the Children of Israel: 'Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd"
Greater Israel will initially be composed of two states, 3 provinces and the capital of Jerusalem.
The States are Judea and Palestina.
The provinces are Gaza, Druzia (in the Golan), and Khazaria (in the Jewish Autonomous Oblast (Russian: Евре́йская автоно́мная о́бласть) named after the Khazars in homage of their Siberian origins. Khazaria will be Greater Israel's only international territory initially (although there is room to expand to Septimania, Sicily etc).
Obviously, there is room to include other Israelite peoples (Alawites, more Druze, various Lebanese Christians, Mandeans etc) into the union in future.
Greater Israel will have observer status in the Arab league until gaining full membership.
Edit: I know believe Druzia should also include the following area (as well as the Golan):
https://web.archive.org/web/20170119055835im_/https://joshuaproject.net/assets/media/profiles/maps/m11620_sy.png
Palestinian Zionism
Since the break up of the Ottoman Empire and the creation of Israel the indigenous inhabitants of the former mandate of Palestine have been searching for identity. Under the Ottomans the territory known as "Palestine" was mainly part of Syria:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/19/Ottoman_empire.svg/2000px-Ottoman_empire.svg.png
http://en.academic.ru/pictures/enwiki/79/Ottoman_Syria_1918.png
Since then, with the advent of Zionism, the Palestinians have searched for their own nationalist movement. Groups such as the P.L.O. experimented with Pan-Arabism, while groups such as Hamas experimented with Islamism, in a flawed search for identity but neither ideology has taken hold because Palestinians know they're not really Arabs but rather Arabised, Islamised indigenous Levantines with some Arab admixture (Here I've shown mainly ruled by foreign clans).
The Palestinians are, like Jews, Judeans rather than Arabs. Both Islamism and Pan-Arabism have failed them. Zionism should not fail them also.
As I've recounted both My Middle-East Peace Plan™ and here Palestinian nationalism ultimately has its roots in exactly this i.e. the nationalism of Palestine and will never succeed whilst non-indigenous Arabic or Islamic ideologies supplant indigenous Palestinian religion and language. The indigenous language of Palestine is Hebrew and the indigenous religion of Palestine is Judaism (and the Christianity of Jesus).
It has been a moral failing on the part of Zionists to not give Palestinians a third nationalist option: that is to embrace their own Hebrew heritage and be welcomed in to the people of Israel. All genetic tests prove that Palestinians like Jews share partial descent from Israelite ancestors (be they Samaritans or Judeans) . They too deserve to reap the benefits of Zionism.
Palestinians are the real "lost tribes of Israel" and now is the time to welcome them back into the fold.
Anglojew's Middle East Peace Plan
There seems to be no end in sight to the Arab-Israeli conflict which has gone on now for over a century. Although peace treaties now exist between Egypt and Israel and Jordan and Israel peace between Israel and the Southern Syrians now known as "Palestinians" alludes both parties. It is obvious that we need to look outside the box to find a solution.
My solution is multi-faceted but not too complicated and I believe will lead to real peace in the region.
My proposals are;
1. For Gaza to unite with Egypt like 1948-1967 (made even more easy with the Muslim brotherhood ruling both now as well as clan ties between the two [at the time of writing this]).
2. Complete Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank, East Jerusalem (with the the Jewish quarter of the old city etc [Mt Scopus] retained by Israel) as well as some minor land swaps along the "green line" as the 1967 border is an armistice line of cessation of fighting in 1948 rather than an official border and doesn't take topography for example. A wall/fence could be built along the border until both parties reach a state of mutual trust.
3. Palestine (West Bank)/Jordan economic (possibly political) federation as in 1948-1967. Jordan to control the West Bank's defence so the Israeli-Jordan peace treaty remains in force.
Why would Israel withdraw given the previous track record of land-for-peace not working after Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon and Gaza and only leading to increased violence from the Arabs? Because...
4. In return for complete withdrawal from said lands Israel gets a second territory, the world's little known other Jewish State; the Jewish Autonomous Oblast to be officially confederated with Israel as another state of the same nation.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140625232609im_/http://www.roitov.com/articles/jewishstate.jpg
This is a win-win situation. The Palestinians get their country and can federate with Jordan if they want. Fatah (The PA's ruling political party) suggested this as late as last week.
Israel gets more land for any it withdraws from as well as a trading base on the Chinese border; something any country would love in this "Chinese" century.
Russia gets the international prestige of forever solving the Middle East conflict thus obtaining even more favour with the region. Israel might even "buy" the State (like Alaska) but since its already meant to be for Jews this is debatable. It also gets a very valuable Israeli presence helping to defend its border against Chinese invasion of Siberia which is a very real possibility this century given increasing Chinese power and decreasing Russian population as well as increased Chinese migration to Siberia.
A happy situation for all.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140227062551im_/http://www.solargeneral.com/mirrors/national-vanguard/www.nationalvanguard.org/images/teaser/russia_israel_map.gif
In part one of my Middle-East Peace plan I outlined the steps necessary for true peace between Israel and the Palestinians (and other Arabs). To summerise, each people need to recognise the others territory and rights both on their own and each others land.
-Israeli final borders will be made up of territory within the 1967 borders (with minor adjustment as well as the Jewish Autonomous Oblast bordering China).
-Jerusalem will be shared along the 1967 borders with the old city ruled by both but full protection of religious rights guaranteed.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140225182502im_/http://www.geschichteinchronologie.ch/SU/EncJud_Birobidzhan-d/karte06-Birobidschan-orte-u-fluesse-2000ca.gif
-Palestine's final borders will be made up of Gaza, the West Bank and Jordan (with the Jordanian King acting as Head of State) but democracy in place eg a Prime Minister in real power.
Part Two of my peace plan is for Israel and Palestine/Jordan to form an economic confederation.
While neither all Jews nor all Palestinians may like it, Jews and Palestinians are intertwined and heavily related. 80% of Palestinians are of Jewish origin and about 80% of Jordan is Palestinian. Eventually a form of economic confederation will be the best solution for both Palestinians and Israelis. Obviously, the details need to be worked out but the two sides cannot ignore each other. I suggest foreign policy and defense be handled separately but many issues like infrastructure; power, water, housing, public transport as well as economic issues should be mutual. Health and education should be combined with religious issues (divorce, marriage, religious education etc) decided by each religious community (as is already the case in Israel).
Since Jews and Palestinians are closely related it's only natural that they should combine forces eventually. The current situation is no good for anyone and I think has been a mistake on the part of both groups who focused too much on differences and not on their unique shared commonality. There will still be a Palestine and an Israel but cooperation between the two on many important issues is to the mutual benefit of both peoples and bring both groups together eventually forming a solid partnership.
Greater Israel - A Practical Guide
By now regular readers of this forum will be aware that I've solved the so-called "Arab-Israeli" dispute by formulating My Middle-East Peace Plan™ and readers will also be aware of the need for a Greater Israel to unite the various Israelite descended peoples -for it is now a well known fact that Palestinians (Druze) and others- descend, like their Jewish brethren, from Israelites. My plan is the only one that takes into account historical, genetic AND religious issues, overcomes any problems AND unites all peoples under one identity.
After much consideration I've decided that Greater Israel shall maintain current Israeli laws (especially pertaining to each religion controlling their own births, deaths and marriages) but shall introduce a political system similar to Belgium. Greater Israel shall be a politically unified federal state, composed of states and provinces, with each having local economic autonomy.
The Federal State nevertheless retains important powers, for example in the area of foreign affairs, national defence, justice, finance, social security, important parts of national health and domestic affairs. However, the states and provinces have control over religious, local health and education and local economic matters.
It's interesting that both Jews and Palestinians present identities relate to the same land but during different historical epochs (Judea and Palestina respecitively). Besides the genetic kinship of Jews and Palestinians, from an Islamic perspective, reclaiming Palestinians true Israelite heritage as Bani Isra'il (Arabic:بني إسرائيل) is justified by The Quran, chapter 17 (Al-Isra), verse 104:
“ And thereafter We [Allah] said to the Children of Israel: 'Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd"
Greater Israel will initially be composed of two states, 3 provinces and the capital of Jerusalem.
The States are Judea and Palestina.
The provinces are Gaza, Druzia (in the Golan), and Khazaria (in the Jewish Autonomous Oblast (Russian: Евре́йская автоно́мная о́бласть) named after the Khazars in homage of their Siberian origins. Khazaria will be Greater Israel's only international territory initially (although there is room to expand to Septimania, Sicily etc).
Obviously, there is room to include other Israelite peoples (Alawites, more Druze, various Lebanese Christians, Mandeans etc) into the union in future.
Greater Israel will have observer status in the Arab league until gaining full membership.
Edit: I know believe Druzia should also include the following area (as well as the Golan):
https://web.archive.org/web/20170119055835im_/https://joshuaproject.net/assets/media/profiles/maps/m11620_sy.png
Palestinian Zionism
Since the break up of the Ottoman Empire and the creation of Israel the indigenous inhabitants of the former mandate of Palestine have been searching for identity. Under the Ottomans the territory known as "Palestine" was mainly part of Syria:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/19/Ottoman_empire.svg/2000px-Ottoman_empire.svg.png
http://en.academic.ru/pictures/enwiki/79/Ottoman_Syria_1918.png
Since then, with the advent of Zionism, the Palestinians have searched for their own nationalist movement. Groups such as the P.L.O. experimented with Pan-Arabism, while groups such as Hamas experimented with Islamism, in a flawed search for identity but neither ideology has taken hold because Palestinians know they're not really Arabs but rather Arabised, Islamised indigenous Levantines with some Arab admixture (Here I've shown mainly ruled by foreign clans).
The Palestinians are, like Jews, Judeans rather than Arabs. Both Islamism and Pan-Arabism have failed them. Zionism should not fail them also.
As I've recounted both My Middle-East Peace Plan™ and here Palestinian nationalism ultimately has its roots in exactly this i.e. the nationalism of Palestine and will never succeed whilst non-indigenous Arabic or Islamic ideologies supplant indigenous Palestinian religion and language. The indigenous language of Palestine is Hebrew and the indigenous religion of Palestine is Judaism (and the Christianity of Jesus).
It has been a moral failing on the part of Zionists to not give Palestinians a third nationalist option: that is to embrace their own Hebrew heritage and be welcomed in to the people of Israel. All genetic tests prove that Palestinians like Jews share partial descent from Israelite ancestors (be they Samaritans or Judeans) . They too deserve to reap the benefits of Zionism.
Palestinians are the real "lost tribes of Israel" and now is the time to welcome them back into the fold.