PDA

View Full Version : A Turkish 23andme result.



Voskos
04-12-2018, 09:19 PM
https://i.imgur.com/gZxQDl9.png

Sikeliot
04-12-2018, 09:21 PM
That's quite high East Asian.

Jana
04-12-2018, 09:28 PM
Is he Crimean Tatar ? 12% mongoloid will show as much more on gedmatch, and he scores more east european than balkan, which could imply east slavic admixture.

Voskos
04-12-2018, 09:30 PM
Is he Crimean Tatar ? 12% mongoloid will show as much more on gedmatch, and he scores more east european than balkan, which could imply east slavic admixture.

Just a random Turk from Turkey. I don't know about their ancestry.

Leto
04-12-2018, 10:53 PM
Very mixed. I think more East Asian than the average. Plus he obviously has some extra Eastern and Southeastern European input.

Bobby Martnen
04-12-2018, 10:56 PM
That's quite high East Asian.

High East Asian is normal in Turks (with the exception of Balkan and Cypriot Turks), they tend to get whitewashed quite a bit on anthroforums.

Leto
04-12-2018, 10:57 PM
High East Asian is normal in Turks (with the exception of Balkan and Cypriot Turks), they tend to get whitewashed quite a bit on anthroforums.
They are 10% mongoloid on average, no more. 1/8 East Asian on 23andme for a Turk is the highest I've seen so far.

Kivan
04-12-2018, 10:59 PM
High East Asian is normal in Turks (with the exception of Balkan and Cypriot Turks), they tend to get whitewashed quite a bit on anthroforums.

:picard1:

Bobby Martnen
04-12-2018, 11:00 PM
:picard1:

What? It's true. Turks have significant admixture from Central Asia, which makes sense, because that's where their language comes from.

Mexicans also have high Spanish admixture.

Kivan
04-12-2018, 11:04 PM
What? It's true. Turks have significant admixture from Central Asia, which makes sense, because that's where their language comes from.

Mexicans also have high Spanish admixture.

Central Asian does not means 100% mongoloid. And you must be kidding, we are one of most brownwashed/trolled ethnicities in this forum.

Thracian
04-13-2018, 09:47 AM
Most likely s/he is a Tatar or an Anatolian Turkish mixed with a Kazakh or something else. I have never seen a Turk who scores 12.5% East Asian before that guy.

İrle
04-13-2018, 09:54 AM
Most likely s/he is a Tatar or an Anatolian Turkish mixed with a Kazakh or something else. I have never seen a Turk who scores 12.5% East Asian before that guy.

Anatolian Turks score in between 6-18% East Eurasian, his results are quite normal:

https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-HKjsPDMkfWY/Wh7EfeBL8GI/AAAAAAAAANM/Vo6HpnwN7ow8MCYBh9WZdLokDDsSZrzxgCLcBGAs/s1600/East_Eurasian.png

https://oghuzturksdna.blogspot.com.tr/2017/12/autosomal-admixture-maps-of-turkey.html

Jana
04-13-2018, 09:57 AM
Anatolian Turks score in between 6-18% East Eurasian, his results are quite normal:

https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-HKjsPDMkfWY/Wh7EfeBL8GI/AAAAAAAAANM/Vo6HpnwN7ow8MCYBh9WZdLokDDsSZrzxgCLcBGAs/s1600/East_Eurasian.png

https://oghuzturksdna.blogspot.com.tr/2017/12/autosomal-admixture-maps-of-turkey.html

They socre that on gedmatch, not on 23and me.

There is lot of mongoloid hiden in west asian reference set since it includes Anatolian Turks.

He can score up to 25%+ mongoloid on gedmatch, probably.

İrle
04-13-2018, 10:00 AM
They socre that on gedmatch, not on 23and me.

There is lot of mongoloid hiden in west asian reference set since it includes Anatolian Turks.

He can score up to 25%+ mongoloid on gedmatch, probably.

23andme doesn't ship kits to Turkey, so you probably haven't seen many examples. From my own experience, unlike MyOrigins, 23andme's ancestry report gives closer results to Gedmatch. So I really doubt that he/she scores %25 East Eurasian on Gedmatch.

Thracian
04-13-2018, 10:02 AM
Anatolian Turks score in between 6-18% East Eurasian, his results are quite normal:

https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-HKjsPDMkfWY/Wh7EfeBL8GI/AAAAAAAAANM/Vo6HpnwN7ow8MCYBh9WZdLokDDsSZrzxgCLcBGAs/s1600/East_Eurasian.png

https://oghuzturksdna.blogspot.com.tr/2017/12/autosomal-admixture-maps-of-turkey.html

They score on Gedmatch but not on 23andMe. Generally Anatolian Turks score over than 80% Western Asian on 23andMe. They also score less than 5% East Asian on 23andMe.

Jana
04-13-2018, 10:03 AM
23andme doesn't ship kits to Turkey, so you probably haven't seen many examples. From my own own experience, unlike MyOrigins, 23andme's ancestry report gives closer results to Gedmatch. So I really doubt that he/she scores %25 East Eurasian on Gedmatch.

Really ?

I score 25% East European on 23andme, and in reality I am more than 50% east European genetically.
Because Croatia is part of Balkan reference set. I think it's similar with Turkey ?

İrle
04-13-2018, 10:07 AM
Really ?

I score 25% East European on 23andme, and in reality I am more than 50% east European genetically.
Because Croatia is part of Balkan reference set. I think it's similar with Turkey ?

Well, I can't say how accurate 23andme on different ethnicities but when it comes to estimating East Eurasian admix, as far as I see 23andme often gives similar or closer results to Gedmatch.

altaic
10-29-2019, 04:28 PM
https://i.imgur.com/gZxQDl9.png

Do you have his/her updated beta results (10/2019) that you can share?

altaic
10-29-2019, 04:40 PM
They score on Gedmatch but not on 23andMe. Generally Anatolian Turks score over than 80% Western Asian on 23andMe. They also score less than 5% East Asian on 23andMe.

That is true. 23andme and GEDMatch has big variation in terms of data representation. This 1/8 East Asian on 23andme will show at least 20-25% Mongoloid on GEDMatch for sure.
As an example; My East Asian is 0.9% on 23andme and I am getting 3.5% to 5% total Mongoloid on the various calculators.

23andme East Asian 0.9%
Dodecad K12b 3.72% Mongoloid (2.4% Siberian, 1.11% East Asian, 0.21% SouthEast Asian)
HarappaWorld 4.08% Mongoloid (2.28% Siberian, 0.98% American, 0.49% NE Asian, 0.33% SouthEast Asian)
MDLP K23b 4.75% Mongoloid

Thracian
10-29-2019, 04:48 PM
That is true. 23andme and GEDMatch has big variation in terms of data representation. This 1/8 East Asian on 23andme will show at least 20-25% Mongoloid on GEDMatch for sure.
As an example; My East Asian is 0.9% on 23andme and I am getting 3.5% to 5% total Mongoloid on the various calculators.

23andme East Asian 0.9%
Dodecad K12b 3.72% Mongoloid (2.4% Siberian, 1.11% East Asian, 0.21% SouthEast Asian)
HarappaWorld 4.08% Mongoloid (2.28% Siberian, 0.98% American, 0.49% NE Asian, 0.33% SouthEast Asian)
MDLP K23b 4.75% Mongoloid

Exactly. I have 0.1% on 23andMe and about 3.5% on Gedmatch (if you count noises). I have slightly less Mongoloid than you on Dodecad K12b (2.36% Siberian+0.96% Southeast Asian+0.21% East Asian=3.53).