Are Austrians Germans?

[Mortimer]

There is often a debate as whether Austrians are truly German genetically or Northwest European and I found a new MyHeritage feature. You pick a country or nationality and it shows you what the average user from that country scores. I compared Austria and Germany. Austria has strong Balkan, Eastern European Component but so does Germany under the line they are both pretty similar.

Germany
https://s31.postimg.cc/rty67npq3/Ethnicitypercentfor_Germany_My_Heritage.jpg

Austria
https://s31.postimg.cc/atf9z1huj/Ethnicityperecent_Austria_My_Heritage.jpg

[cyberlorian]

There is often a debate as whether Austrians are truly German genetically or Northwest European and I found a new MyHeritage feature. You pick a country or nationality and it shows you what the average user from that country scores. I compared Austria and Germany. Austria has strong Balkan, Eastern European Component but so does Germany under the line they are both pretty similar.

Germany
https://s31.postimg.cc/rty67npq3/Ethnicitypercentfor_Germany_My_Heritage.jpg

Austria
https://s31.postimg.cc/atf9z1huj/Ethnicityperecent_Austria_My_Heritage.jpg

The summation of those percentages are far greater than 100 :confused:

[Mortimer]

The summation of those percentages are far greater than 100 :confused:

true, it actually means how many are of that ethnicity in german and austria. so 55% of austrians are northwest europeans and the same amount of germans are northwest europeans.

[TheForeigner]

Ethnicity isn't just about dna. Of course Austrians are Germans.

[Mortimer]

Ethnicity isn't just about dna. Of course Austrians are Germans.

I think they are, but some doubt it. Especially neighbours like slovaks, they want austrians to be closer to themselfes.

[Slavic Italian]

I look at them as Germans with a Slavic contribution.

[Teutonski]

How often you wanna ask this?

Yes they are Germans

[renaissance12]

Ethnicity isn't just about dna. Of course Austrians are Germans.


Sorry... Bavarians...( or other way round ? )

[StonyArabia]

Of course, they seem to have an Italian and Balkan input though

[renaissance12]

Of course, they seem to have an Italian and Balkan input though


Average Austrian People : Sebastian Kurz supporters in Austria...

https://www.aljazeera.com/mritems/Images/2017/10/15/5bba793349fd4d36a224953752d764ef_18.jpg

[Catarinense1998]

Yes.

[Teutonski]

Average Austrian People : Sebastian Kurz supporters in Austria...

https://www.aljazeera.com/mritems/Images/2017/10/15/5bba793349fd4d36a224953752d764ef_18.jpg

Are you on drugs? Even South Tirol Germans who are occupied by you look like a diferent universe compared to Italians.

Look at their Basketball Team

http://basketballaustria.at/files/basketballaustria/upload/gallery/MU18%202016%20TEAMFOTO.jpg

Ski Team

http://photaq.com/media/fmf/Image/image/69150/scaley/720;die_laufende_ski-saison_201718_bringt_frischen_wind_aus_oste.jpg

Football sadly has niggers, Turks and Balkanites

[renaissance12]

Are you on drugs? Even South Tirol Germans who are occupied by you look like a diferent universe compared to Italians.

Look at their Basketball Team


http://basketballaustria.at/files/basketballaustria/upload/gallery/MU18%202016%20TEAMFOTO.jpg


I don't count bottle blonde girl


Your AVATAR is your Kaiser or our Caesar ?

Austria Basket male team.. NOBODY has really blonde hair...

[Teutonski]

You AVATAR is your Kaiser or our Caesar ?

Austria Basket male team.. NOBODY has blonde hair...

Number 33? Above him brownish/red and 9 dark bloonde.

Who of them is black haired and swarthy like italians? Noone except one coach.

[renaissance12]

Number 33? Above him brownish/red and 9 dark bloonde.

Who of them is black haired and swarthy like italians? Noone except one coach.

Ok you are right.. 15-20 % of people in Austria have dark blonde hair...( and maybe they are not really Austrian ;) )



This is blond

http://www.maguardaunpo.it/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/capelli-uomo-3.jpg


This is not blonde at all..

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSsWwbpygcixOTEbcFi_Ua82LMt7FEgT Z-4NgDC60qwNf7IcfaF

[Teutonski]

Ok you are right.. 20% of people in Austria have dark blonde hair...( and maybe they are not really Austrian ;) )

Austrians are Germans nothing you can do about it, and I love how the ruling FPÖ already declearing South Tyrol as Austria again.

With Salvini and Lega Nord already establishing more autonomy rights the times for South Tyrol coming back to a German countries are better than ever.

I dont even hate Italians or Italy but Italians like you trying to boost their ego to declare Austrians are no German but more close to Italians.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/894922/Italy-Vienna-Rome-Austria-passport-Wien-Trentino-Sudtirol-EU-European-Union-video

[renaissance12]

Austrians are Germans nothing you can do about it, and I love how the ruling FPÖ already declearing South Tyrol as Austria again.

With Salvini and Lega Nord already establishing more autonomy rights the times for South Tyrol coming back to a German countries are better than ever.

I dont even hate Italians or Italy but Italians like you trying to boost their ego to declate Austrians are no German but more close to Italians.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/894922/Italy-Vienna-Rome-Austria-passport-Wien-Trentino-Sudtirol-EU-European-Union-video

Is it a problem for you if the typical austrian does not look like a primitive Viking ?... It is better for them :cool:

VIkings contribution to civilization is ZERO.. Their civilization led to NOTHING...( including discovery of america if it is true.. and not a fake fact to make ASUTRU follower happy )

[Teutonski]

Is it a problem for you if the typical austrian does not look like a primitive Viking ?... It is better for them :cool:

VIkings contribution to civilization is ZERO.. Their civilization led to NOTHING...( includind discovery of america if it is true.. and not a fake fact to make ASUTRU follower happy )

Do I give a damn shit about Vikings? Certainly not, I am not a nordicist. Fuck Vikings.

[renaissance12]

Do I give a damn shit about Vikings? Certainly not, I am not a nordicist. Fuck Vikings.

Do I give a damn shit about Tyrol ?.... I love VENICE.. i don't love the primitive people living the mountains in Italy or Austria ( and i live in the mountain... but i'm the exception that proves the rule. )

[Livin]

Yep they are!!!

[frdfgcg]

Of course no. Majority of the population Austria and even German are not Germans.
They are Alpinids and Dinarids.
True German can be only Nordid.
Only NWE nations can be considered true Germans. Swedes, Norwegians etc.

[Livin]

Of course no. Majority of the population Austria and even German are not Germans.
They are Alpinids and Dinarids.
True German can be only Nordid.
Only NWE nations can be considered true Germans. Swedes, Norwegians etc.

LOL!!!

Scandinavians are more on cromanoid blend.

The majority of them are Tronder and Borreby.

Hallstatt nordic is minority there.

[Teutonski]

Of course no. Majority of the population Austria and even German are not Germans.
They are Alpinids and Dinarids.
True German can be only Nordid.
Only NWE nations can be considered true Germans. Swedes, Norwegians etc.

Do you even know the difference of a GERMAN and a GERMANIC.

Swedes, Norwegians etc are GERMANICS not GERMANS.

[frdfgcg]

Ok.
Tronders, Hallstatt Nordids etc and all forms of true CM except for Baltids.
It is these phenotypes are true White phenotype.

[Bobby Martnen]

Yes, they are

[Slavic Italian]

This is always one of my closest populations on the Gedmatch calcs.

[decordoba]

The Austrians are not Germans, they are just German speaking.

Ppl from Salzburg and Upper Austria are Bavarians.

Ppl from Lower Austria and Steiermark are Bavarians with almost 50 % input of Slavs = Wenden, Veneti - equal to the Czechians and Slovenians.

And there are a lot of persons in the cities/towns living - whose ancestors immigrated from the Balkan, Hungary, and the eastern Slavic countries,... in the age of Austrian Empire

This is not the whole crowd - ther are much more immigrants,... this is equal to Germany.

[Teutonski]

The Austrians are not Germans, they are just German speaking.

Ppl from Salzburg and Upper Austria are Bavarians.

Ppl from Lower Austria and Steiermark are Bavarians with almost 50 % input of Slavs = Wenden, Veneti - equal to the Czechians and Slovenians.

And there are a lot of persons in the cities/towns living - whose ancestors immigrated from the Balkan, Hungary, and the eastern Slavic countries,... in the age of Austrian Empire

This is not the whole crowd - ther are much more immigrants,... this is equal to Germany.

Bavarians are ethnic Germans.

Your times of american propaganda is diying, I am glad Strache and Hofer identify as Germans and are Burschenschafter.

[Dibran]

No data for most of the Balkans.....kind of silly

[Kivan]

Yes.

[The-Hesse]

Yes, they are the better, more based germans.

[Thanas Django]

How often you wanna ask this?

Yes they are Germans

until you repeat to him what he wants to hear.

"Mortimer you are so German Hitler would give you a German medal for being extremely German. Enjoy living on herz 4 from my taxes. Hope your momma treats you to ben and jerries that she will pay with my taxes."

[Smeagol]

Of course they're Germans.

[Mortimer]

until you repeat to him what he wants to hear.

"Mortimer you are so German Hitler would give you a German medal for being extremely German. Enjoy living on herz 4 from my taxes. Hope your momma treats you to ben and jerries that she will pay with my taxes."

1. I didnt asked this often, eventhough he said I did, but I didnt. I just draw a comparison because it was a frequent discussion (not started by me though).
2.I dont live on Harz 4
3.I never said Iam German, I asked about native Austrians not about me

[JohnSmith]

Yes, but I would say they have more eastern influence from their history.

[MinervaItalica]

I don't know how they view each other irl but when i see some Wikipedia pages they (Germans and Austrians) fight a lot, especially about Mozart. :laugh:

[TheMaestro]

I think they are, but some doubt it. Especially neighbours like slovaks, they want austrians to be closer to themselfes.

Who said you this? Total bullshit, I live in Slovakia and I never heard Slovakian consider Austrians as themself. The only thing is Slovakians being Austrians therfore Germans and not Austrians Slovakians... You have many germanic influenced CzechoSlovakians..

[TheMaestro]

Germans and Austrians are like this...
https://i.imgur.com/V3bXPMf.jpg

Whoever says they dont look similar have never been in these countries, especially you can see somehow germanic traits at elder people.

[firemonkey]

Lukasz's (anthrogenica) K36 report for me.

23 Nordrhein-Westfalen 0,9421
26 Mecklenburg-Vorpommern 0,91518
33 Hessen 0,88185
55 Austria 0,74719
58 Tirol 0,71505

Does this suggest a significant difference though both could be called German?

[Jack_vorobey]

They're southern poles genetically.

[Bosniensis]

Original Austrian are Germans... but immigrations changed that a lot.

[J. Ketch]

They would be justified in considering themselves separate from Germans if they wanted to. They are genetically distinct from Northern Germans and are closer to other Central European populations.