Log in

View Full Version : Which one of my results is the most accurate?



Canoel
10-25-2018, 02:54 PM
I did my DNA test on MyHeritage and it gave me the following result:
81232

To the Central American category I wanted to break it down into Amerindian and Iberian, so I analyzed it in DNA.Land and it gave me the following result:

81233

I also wrote to McDonald Douglas and he told me this:

81234

The problem is that when loading the raw DNA in GEDmatch and analyzing it with Eurogenes K13, it gives me the following result:

Population
North_Atlantic 36.99
Baltic 11.97
West_Med 22.44
West_Asian 3.77
East_Med 13.69
Red_Sea 0.32
South_Asian 1.12
East_Asian 0.57
Siberian 0.11
Amerindian 7.75
Oceanian-
Northeast_African 1.27
Sub-Saharan-

There are approximately 7% more non-European genes with respect to the other analyzes.
Give me your opinion about it. Thank you

Argentano
12-05-2018, 01:46 AM
I did my DNA test on MyHeritage and it gave me the following result:
81232

To the Central American category I wanted to break it down into Amerindian and Iberian, so I analyzed it in DNA.Land and it gave me the following result:

81233

I also wrote to McDonald Douglas and he told me this:

81234

The problem is that when loading the raw DNA in GEDmatch and analyzing it with Eurogenes K13, it gives me the following result:

Population
North_Atlantic 36.99
Baltic 11.97
West_Med 22.44
West_Asian 3.77
East_Med 13.69
Red_Sea 0.32
South_Asian 1.12
East_Asian 0.57
Siberian 0.11
Amerindian 7.75
Oceanian-
Northeast_African 1.27
Sub-Saharan-

There are approximately 7% more non-European genes with respect to the other analyzes.
Give me your opinion about it. Thank you

My Heritage uses a Mestizo reference as amerindian so if you are 8% amerindian my heritage see it as 16% mestizo. Thats why you are having the double amerindian


Para my heritage amerindian usa como referencia a un mestizo, entonces si vos sos 8% amerindian my heritage lo toma como 16% mestizo (pero le pone amerindian)

The correct data is the 8% amerindian of gedmatch. El dato correcto es el de gedmatch

Vos sos aprox 92% euro 8% amerindio

Canoel
12-05-2018, 11:29 PM
My Heritage uses a Mestizo reference as amerindian so if you are 8% amerindian my heritage see it as 16% mestizo. Thats why you are having the double amerindian


Para my heritage amerindian usa como referencia a un mestizo, entonces si vos sos 8% amerindian my heritage lo toma como 16% mestizo (pero le pone amerindian)

The correct data is the 8% amerindian of gedmatch. El dato correcto es el de gedmatch

Vos sos aprox 92% euro 8% amerindio

Claro, MyHeritage no divide el centroamericano en amerindio y blanco. La duda mía era con respecto a gedmatch, ya que según la herramienta que realizaba me daba resultados diferentes, el Eurogenes K13 me daba 14% no blanco por lo que interpreté, pero si usaba otra herramienta me daba 8% solamente