Do South Tyrolese look Germanic to you?

[Token]

https://www.hotel-martinshof.com/fileadmin/user_upload/bilder/familie-oberhofer/slider/slider-1-familie-oberhofer-famiglia-family-martinshof-ahrntal-valle-aurina-south-tyrol.jpg

http://www.euroviews.eu/2012/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/P1010005.jpg

https://www.redrooster.it/smartedit/images/hoefe/vergroesserung/4225-oberegghof-dorf-tirol-14.jpg

http://www.xoventu.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/sam_full_136.jpg

https://www.haselrieder.info/sites/default/files/styles/popup/public/contentbilder/p1040047_neu_0.jpg?itok=tLnTfvh7

https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/660/media/images/64625000/jpg/_64625846_tight624cropgetty119282219.jpg

[nafz]

If by Germanic you mean Nordic, no.

They look Central Europeans.

Main types are predominantly Alpine, Dinarics, Norics, Subnordids and yes, Meds.

Pure Nordics exist but they are not the norm .

My experience is that the above are true not only for South Tyrol but also for Austria, South Germany, and Switzerland (I have been to all the places I mentioned).

[Sp_loa]

They look mostly Bavarian but some Southern European types do exist.

[Mo123]

SÜDTIROL IST NICHT ITALIEN
(South Tyrol is not Italy)

[Blondie]

They look central european, can pass in Hungary, Czechia, Slovenia too.

[Roy]

They do in a way but it depends on what for you is a "Germanic look" if you mean ''Nordidd' phenotype than I guess most of them don't fit the bill. They seem similar to Swiss (German & Ladin speaking cantons). Many can pass as Slavic people - Polish people too but they'd not exactly be super typical.

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

Not really. They remind me of Rhaeto-Romance speakers in Switzerland / indigenous Alpine people.

[Regrejknol]

From what I have seen, some of them look central european, others have a more south europe look.

[Joso]

These photos are not enough. But i think they look German, which is not necessarly the same thing as looking Germanic

[Sebastianus Rex]

Alpinoid stronk...some dinaroids also.

[Sebastianus Rex]

These photos are not enough. But i think they look German, which is not necessarly the same thing as looking Germanic

Germany is less nordic since WW2...millions of young nordic soldiers died in the Russian front and left no descendants.

[Regnera]

They are Germanic.
But they don't look typical Nordic/Germanic,they look central European.

[JMack]

If by Germanic you mean Nordic, no.

They look Central Europeans.

Main types are predominantly Alpine, Dinarics, Norics, Subnordids and yes, Meds.

Pure Nordics exist but they are not the norm .

My experience is that the above are true not only for South Tyrol but also for Austria, South Germany, and Switzerland (I have been to all the places I mentioned).

Agreed. I have been to most countries in Alps region and it seems the most common phenotypes are blends of Alpine, Med, CM, Dinaric and Norid. There's strong overlap between South Tyrol and Switzerland, Austria and some alpine regions of France and Italy.

Most of them are not Nordid and if you're not a complete wog it's not difficult to pass as a local there.

[Sebastianus Rex]

https://www.remocontro.it/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Tirol-costumi-jpg.jpg

[Tenma de Pegasus]

Mostly Alpines, Alpine-meds, Dinarids, Meds, Dinaro-Meds, Norids, East-meds and Pontids. Pass in Austria, Swiss Cantons and Hungary.

[Dna8]

Germanic and Germano Slavic aesthetics.

[renaissance12]

SÜDTIROL IST NICHT ITALIEN
(South Tyrol is not Italy)

It is Venetian land... Bah...

Venice Repubblic used to controll all the area till Brennero because Venice had the need of milions of pines....


https://c8.alamy.com/compit/mmrcme/inglese-estremamente-interessante-esempio-di-john-cary-importante-1799-mappa-del-veneto-membri-copre-bergamo-e-il-lago-di-costanza-a-est-passato-il-tirolo-venezia-e-mantova-per-listria-e-il-golfo-di-trieste-offre-uno-stupendo-dettaglio-e-codifica-a-colori-secondo-la-regione-tutti-in-tutto-uno-dei-piu-interessanti-e-attraenti-atlas-mappe-di-venezia-mantova-e-tirolo-a-comparire-nei-primi-anni-del-xix-secolo-preparato-nel-1799-da-giovanni-cary-per-la-questione-nella-sua-magnifica-1808-nuovo-atlante-universale-una-nuova-mappa-della-contea-del-tirolo-e-la-repubblica-di-venezia-ducato-di-mantova-c-c-dal-la-mmrcme.jpg

[Rouxinol]

They look German, because that's what they are, Germans, but not specifically Germanic.

[Dna8]

Germanic and Germano Slavic aesthetics.

And Germanic aesthetics predominate.

[renaissance12]

Questi vanno d'accordo solo quando c'è da bere....quelli con la barbona sono Trentini e gli altri da Innsbruk credo..

http://1.citynews-trentotoday.stgy.ovh/~media/original-hi/54184606470185/foto-fratellanza-2.jpg


Questi sono idioti che vivono dall'altra parte della vallata dove vivo io... Se ci parli insieme mi vergogno che abbiano un accento veneto come il mio.. Sono TONTI come tutti quelli nati nelle montagne da quelle parti.
Io per fortuna sono nato dall'altra parte. Ti rubano i fiori dai giardini di notte.. e rubano galline e conigli tra di loro..

http://resc.deskline.net/images/TRN/1/f6dd9a7e-8554-449b-8107-c03b5533dd18/99/image.jpg

[renaissance12]

Il nuovo che avanza...

http://www.giornaletrentino.it/image/policy:1.957172:1502013416/image/image.jpg?f=3x2&w=627&$p$f$w=caf6c4a

[Catarinense1998]

They look Italians to me.

[gıulıoımpa]

Alpine/subnordid or Alpine + noric/dinaric with CM here and there is the dominant pheno, not unusual in the alpine arc

Many have a look a la Paolo Villaggio (though he is Ligurian so you see this look it's common all over northern Italy be it East or West)

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/58/Paolo_Villaggio_Fantozzi_2.png

https://www.gonews.it/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/VILLAGGIO_PAOLO.jpg

[renaissance12]

They look Italians to me.

But they want to be considered german as 70 % of french 80 % of english.. 99 % of Hungarian.. 99% of Slovenians and Croatians ...25% of Bulgarians ect ect... 1% of Italians...
I have no clue about Turks... It is better to ask their Brothers from Hungary to Albania and everything in between


The Schutzen with dark beard is from Hungary or Morocco..

[Benyzero]

Some of them obviously, I saw typical germanic face in northern Italy . But generally they don't

[Benyzero]

But they want to be considered german as 70 % of french 80 % of english.. 99 % of Hungarian.. 99% of Slovenian and Croatian ...25% of Bulgarians ect ect... 1% of Italians...
I have no clue about Turks... It is better to ask their Brothers from Hungary to Albania and everything in between

dumbass nigga again

[renaissance12]

dumbass nigga again

The Schutzen with dark beard is from Hungary ( gypsie tribes living nearby Budapest ) or Morocco..

http://www.giornaletrentino.it/image/policy:1.957172:1502013416/image/image.jpg?f=3x2&w=627&$p$f$w=caf6c4a

[Benyzero]

The Schutzen with dark beard is from Hungary ( gypsie tribes living nearby Budapest ) or Morocco..

http://www.giornaletrentino.it/image/policy:1.957172:1502013416/image/image.jpg?f=3x2&w=627&$p$f$w=caf6c4a

Can't you recognize your cousin?

[Norb]

Germany is less nordic since WW2...millions of young nordic soldiers died in the Russian front and left no descendants.

Agree 100%, no doubt there will be someone calling you a troll for this comment though

[renaissance12]

Can't you recognize your cousin?

I can recognize you....

[renaissance12]

Agree 100%, no doubt there will be someone calling you a troll for this comment though

It was a tragedy....

[JMack]

This Renaissance is a dumbass and likely not Italian (or someone with mental retardation).

South Tyroleans/Trentino people generally don't identify as Italians (even many Italian speaking ones) and you would be beat up for suggesting they are ''Italian'' there.
They are Italian nowadays because Italian is a nationality and so, but there are enough differences between South Tyroleans and Northern Italians, let alone Central and Southern Italians.

[renaissance12]

This Renaissance is a dumbass and likely not Italian (or someone with mental retardation).

South Tyroleans/Trentino people generally don't identify as Italians (even many Italian speaking ones) and you would be beat up for suggesting they are ''Italian'' there.
They are Italian nowadays because Italian is a nationality and so, but there are enough differences between South Tyroleans and Northern Italians, let alone Central and Southern Italians.


I was born and i live in this area...

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/it/thumb/e/e8/Altopianoasiago.jpg/260px-Altopianoasiago.jpg

In Trentino they speak Veneto like me.....

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/16/Languages_spoken_in_Italy.svg/800px-Languages_spoken_in_Italy.svg.png

[Benyzero]

renaissance12
https://i.imgur.com/JZM7az5.jpg

[Sebastianus Rex]

This Renaissance is a dumbass and likely not Italian (or someone with mental retardation).


I think he is son of immigrants...once he was triggered by a comment I made about Turks. :rolleyes:

[renaissance12]

I think he is son of immigrants...once he was triggered by a comment I made about Turks. :rolleyes:

My bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis bis grandfather ( go back to XVI century in Venice ) was an Ottoman/turk.. from dalmatia or Internal Croatia.... He was a trade business man.. who sold some mineral produced in Turkey ( mineral to make magnificent color )

[Token]

My bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis bis grandfather ( go back to XVI century in Venice ) was an Ottoman/turk.. from dalmatia or Internal Croatia.... He was a trade business man.. who sold some mineral produced in Turkey ( mineral to make magnificent color )

Exposed!

[Hrvoje Vukčić Hrvatinić]

My bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis-bis bis grandfather ( go back to XVI century in Venice ) was an Ottoman/turk.. from dalmatia or Internal Croatia.... He was a trade business man.. who sold some mineral produced in Turkey ( mineral to make magnificent color )

You are part Croat I knew it only par Croat blood can produce such badass motherfucker like you.

[Joso]

You are part Croat I knew it only par Croat blood can produce such badass motherfucker like you.

I am part Venetian, does it counts?

[Sebastianus Rex]

You are part Croat I knew it only par Croat blood can produce such badass motherfucker like you.

Dude, he is either Turk or Albanian.

[renaissance12]

Dude, he is either Turk or Albanian.

What is sure is the fact My Bis-Bis-Bis-........Bis Was A Ottoman Business-Man .Relations With Ottomans Was Very Important For Venice.

[Smeagol]

They look like South Germans which they are.

[renaissance12]

You are part Croat I knew it only par Croat blood can produce such badass motherfucker like you.

You Were Under Our Thumb. You Loved It

[renaissance12]

They look like South Germans which they are.

Or south germans look like Them.

[Kamal900]

Very, lol. They look like Dutch or Belgians to me.

[Morena]

Yes, of course they do.

[Aodhan]

no

[Aodhan]

Or south germans look like Them.

https://media.giphy.com/media/CaiVJuZGvR8HK/giphy.gif

[Papastratosels26]

Mostly Alpines