Log in

View Full Version : Cordedwhelp’s Ashkenazi Ancestry May Come from Danish Jews



Figaro
10-18-2019, 06:55 PM
My mother’s maiden name is Not increadibly rare in Scandinavia, but not one of the most common names and is one some danish Jews have been known to take. I have never known Precisely from which lineage her 5.8% AJ (per 23) originates. Tacking it onto her Belarusian side was always the most tempting, but she consistently behaves on 23 and eurogenes calcs as someone over half Eastern European.

Just today I have noticed on her 23 account a new match, bearing the name (although as a 3rd to distant cousin)...I have since sent him a request to connect and a message inquiring if his surname came out of Copenhagen. Interestingly, he scores tiny bits of broadly NW euro and some 0.2% Scandinavian. For an otherwise full AJ, these percentages are not the most typical. By the way, he’s a Q1b subclade.

Any input? Advice of where I should look next to confirm or deny?

Pine
10-19-2019, 11:48 AM
Interestingly, he scores tiny bits of broadly NW euro and some 0.2% Scandinavian. For an otherwise full AJ, these percentages are not the most typical. By the way, he’s a Q1b subclade.



Pretty normal.

Figaro
10-19-2019, 04:29 PM
Pretty normal.

Isn’t it usually more tiny bits in French +German though? I don’t know, maybe you’ve seen more Jewish 23andmr results than I have

Maybe I’m wrong, but this theory works out well, in that it explains how my mom is 1/16 AJ whilst still maintaining over 50% Eastern European ancestry. It probably isn’t any more likely from her southern German side, that sides pretty well accounted for.

Figaro
10-20-2019, 08:07 PM
A last bump for lil’ ‘ol me?

Jana
10-20-2019, 08:09 PM
Did you match from Denmark helped you learn anything new ?

Figaro
10-21-2019, 02:57 AM
Did you match from Denmark helped you learn anything new ?

Nah, they’re bein’ bashful...

I have not confirmed this guys paternal roots are from Denmark, but I think I may be right here, or pretty likely so. My mother’s maiden name is not “generically” Ashkenazi, and is a name I think would only get picked up by Jews living amongst Nordic-folk.

Evrim
10-21-2019, 03:35 AM
Q1b sounds remigration of Goths with Hunnic admixture.

Pine
10-21-2019, 05:14 AM
Isn’t it usually more tiny bits in French +German though? I don’t know, maybe you’ve seen more Jewish 23andmr results than I have

Maybe I’m wrong, but this theory works out well, in that it explains how my mom is 1/16 AJ whilst still maintaining over 50% Eastern European ancestry. It probably isn’t any more likely from her southern German side, that sides pretty well accounted for.

I've certainly seen Sephardim pop up with a little Scandinavian.

Pine
10-21-2019, 05:23 AM
Q1b sounds remigration of Goths with Hunnic admixture.

All the Jews and Arabs with Q1b are Goths with Hunnic admixture. Stick to incel topics.

Jana
10-21-2019, 05:26 AM
Nah, they’re bein’ bashful...

I have not confirmed this guys paternal roots are from Denmark, but I think I may be right here, or pretty likely so. My mother’s maiden name is not “generically” Ashkenazi, and is a name I think would only get picked up by Jews living amongst Nordic-folk.

Makes sense.

Figaro
10-21-2019, 03:24 PM
The mans y clade is specifically Q-Y2780. Anything of note regarding that clade?

Pine
10-22-2019, 09:17 AM
The mans y clade is specifically Q-Y2780. Anything of note regarding that clade?

It's just a subclade of the Western Jewish branch Q-Y2200, which is a subclade of the wider Jewish branch Q-Y2225. A Middle Eastern origin for it is unquestionable, given that Arabians are found with Q-Y2200. Furthermore, given the Jewish origin and the basal Jordanian at Q-Y2209*, an Israelite origin is very likely.

Also, given the particular subclade he's in, it's likely that he is the result of back migration from Eastern Europe, but I need to check more data for that.

Figaro
10-26-2019, 05:13 PM
No doubt this clade predates Turkics and Hun...possibly Indo-Iranian spread Yenesien line?

Lol...and Whatever it is worth; My Mom’s mytrueancestry haplogroup analytics does feature some frequency of Q.

Pine
10-26-2019, 05:41 PM
No doubt this clade predates Turkics and Hun...possibly Indo-Iranian spread Yenesien line?

Lol...and Whatever it is worth; My Mom’s mytrueancestry haplogroup analytics does feature some frequency of Q.

Yenesien?

Figaro
10-26-2019, 05:42 PM
Yenesien?

Yeniseian*. Pardon me.

Figaro
10-26-2019, 07:50 PM
So...if Q entered west asia/sw Asia around when it did, what culture may we associate with it? Something related to Kelteminar?

Figaro
10-28-2019, 04:53 PM
Final bump?

Smitty
12-06-2019, 02:44 AM
Interesting. Would the Danish censuses shed any light on that line, or have you already checked those? I think Danish Jews were a pretty small group.