Log in

View Full Version : It’s MDLP k16 modern accurate ??



Ahaddad
11-28-2019, 03:33 PM
MDLP k16 give strange results for some people, i have see many Lebanese gettin a Cypriot, some Iraqis get Armenian Gavar, some Armenians geting Georgia Laz, I don’t know why but results of K16 are very different of Mdlp k23 for example one Iraqi get Iraqi, Iraqi mandean, Jew Iraq or Mountain Jews in Mdlp k23 or k22 and no one Armenian in oracle, but when you put in Mdlp k 16 you see Armenian in 2 of distance in first of oracles and a lot of Armenians. See example of kit T107876

Rocinante
11-28-2019, 03:42 PM
it's not that accurate but interesting, i get Corsican (Corsica) @ 3.95 as first single population sharing, not being corsican of course.

Kyp
11-28-2019, 03:43 PM
It's pretty random in my experience.
My mother is closer to Scotland than to South Germany.

Ritz06
11-28-2019, 03:46 PM
Mine results are strange too..

# Population Percent
1 Caucasian 34.38
2 Steppe 19.81
3 Neolithic 19.73
4 NorthEastEuropean 14.7
5 Indian 6.75
6 SouthEastAsian 2.98
7 NearEast 1.15
8 NorthAfrican 0.34
9 Arctic 0.14

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 Romanian (Romania) 8.65
2 Gagauz (Gagauzia) 10.08
3 Bulgarian (Bulgaria) 10.31
4 Greek (Macedonia) 10.43
5 Macedonian (Macedonia) 10.85
6 Bulgarian (Bulgaria) 10.9
7 Romanian (Gorj) 10.93
8 Greek (Peloponnes) 11.06
9 Greek (Greece) 11.1
10 Greek (Thessaloniki) 11.5
11 Albanian (Albania) 11.65
12 Kosovar (Kosovo) 11.7
13 Romanian (Apuseni) 11.87
14 Moldavian (Molodva) 12.17
15 Montenegrian (Montenegro) 12.34
16 Italian (Abruzzo) 12.71
17 Serbian (Serbia) 12.89
18 Greek (Athens) 13.3
19 Italian (Friul) 13.34
20 Bosnian (Bosnia-Herzegovina) 13.81

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 52.4% English (England) + 47.6% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 2.72
2 51.3% French (WestFrance) + 48.7% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 2.96
3 58.1% English (England) + 41.9% Abkhazian (Gudauta) @ 3.04
4 51.1% Irish (Cork_Kerry) + 48.9% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.08
5 58.1% English (England) + 41.9% Georgian (Svanetia) @ 3.1
6 52.6% Scottish (Fife) + 47.4% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.12
7 55.2% English (England) + 44.8% Abkhazian_Lykhny (Lykhny) @ 3.15
8 57.3% English (England) + 42.7% Georgian (Georgia) @ 3.16
9 51.3% Scottish (Borders) + 48.7% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.23
10 50.1% French (France) + 49.9% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.27
11 50.7% Irish (Connacht) + 49.3% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.33
12 58.2% English (England) + 41.8% Georgians (Zugdidi) @ 3.39
13 50.7% Shetlandic (Shetland_Islands) + 49.3% Ossetian (North_Ossetia) @ 3.39
14 51.2% French (NorthwestFrance) + 48.8% Lezgin (Dagestan) @ 3.4
15 56% English (England) + 44% Adjar (Adjaria) @ 3.41
16 57.1% Irish (Leinster) + 42.9% Georgian (Svanetia) @ 3.42
17 56.9% Irish (Cork_Kerry) + 43.1% Abkhazian (Gudauta) @ 3.45
18 56.3% Irish (Leinster) + 43.7% Georgian (Georgia) @ 3.49
19 55.5% Tabasaran (Dagestan) + 44.5% Spanish (Spain) @ 3.49
20 54.1% Irish (Leinster) + 45.9% Abkhazian_Lykhny (Lykhny) @ 3.5

Kyp
11-28-2019, 03:50 PM
Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 50.9% Avar (Dagestan) + 49.1% Kosovar (Kosovo) @ 2.9
2 58.8% Azerbaijani_Dagestan (Azerbaijan_Dagestan) + 41.2% German (Germany) @ 3.01
3 52.6% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 47.4% Irish (Ireland) @ 3.06
4 59.3% Avar (Dagestan) + 40.7% Corsican (Corsica) @ 3.11
5 50.4% Kosovar (Kosovo) + 49.6% Dargin (Urkarah) @ 3.14
6 61.5% Avar (Dagestan) + 38.5% Italian (Bergamo) @ 3.15
7 62.8% Avar (Dagestan_Shangoda) + 37.2% Spanish (Spain) @ 3.15
8 60.2% Dargin (Urkarah) + 39.8% Italian (Bergamo) @ 3.24
9 56.4% Tabasaran (Dagestan) + 43.6% Corsican (Corsica) @ 3.3
10 52.5% Romanian (Apuseni) + 47.5% Azerbaijani_Dagestan (Azerbaijan_Dagestan) @ 3.31
11 55.3% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 44.7% Swede (Sweden) @ 3.31
12 51.3% Kosovar (Kosovo) + 48.7% Ava (Dagestan_Khunzakh) @ 3.32
13 51.6% Greek (Thessaloniki) + 48.4% Avar (Dagestan) @ 3.35
14 51.2% Albanian (Albania) + 48.8% Avar (Dagestan) @ 3.36
15 58% Dargin (Urkarah) + 42% Corsican (Corsica) @ 3.39
16 51.7% Avar (Dagestan) + 48.3% Romanian (Gorj) @ 3.41
17 57.4% Avar (Dagestan_Shangoda) + 42.6% Provencal (Provence) @ 3.43
18 57.5% Azerbaijani_Dagestan (Azerbaijan_Dagestan) + 42.5% French (EastFrance) @ 3.44
19 50.2% Abkhazian (Gudauta) + 49.8% Irish (Ireland) @ 3.44
20 51.2% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 48.8% Dane (Denmark) @ 3.46

MDLP K22 looks better

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 62.6% Serbian (derived) + 37.4% Azeri (derived) @ 3.32
2 50.3% Turk (derived) + 49.7% Austrian (derived) @ 3.35
3 65.1% Montenegrin (derived) + 34.9% Azeri (derived) @ 3.43
4 57.1% Austrian (derived) + 42.9% Kurd (derived) @ 3.58
5 67.2% Macedonian (derived) + 32.8% Azeri (derived) @ 3.6
6 64.9% Serbian (derived) + 35.1% Kurd (derived) @ 3.61
7 68% Bulgarian (derived) + 32% Kumyk (derived) @ 3.65
8 54.7% Austrian (derived) + 45.3% Azeri (derived) @ 3.67
9 71% Bulgarian (derived) + 29% Azeri (derived) @ 3.68
10 50.2% Turk (derived) + 49.8% German_V (derived) @ 3.76
11 69% Greek_Azov (derived) + 31% Czech (derived) @ 3.8
12 51.9% Turk (derived) + 48.1% Slovenian (derived) @ 3.81
13 50.5% Hungarian (derived) + 49.5% Turk (derived) @ 3.84
14 73.9% Gagauz (derived) + 26.1% Kumyk (derived) @ 3.84
15 66.4% Greek_Azov (derived) + 33.6% Slovenian (derived) @ 3.85
16 64.2% Greek_Azov (derived) + 35.8% Hungarian (derived) @ 3.86
17 66.5% Greek_Azov (derived) + 33.5% German (derived) @ 3.86
18 57.7% Austrian (derived) + 42.3% Armenian (derived) @ 3.91
19 64.9% Greek_Azov (derived) + 35.1% Austrian (derived) @ 3.92
20 68.4% Greek_Azov (derived) + 31.6% German-North (derived) @ 3.93

tipirneni
11-28-2019, 03:50 PM
MDLP 16 looks like giving extra weight to some Central Asian population.

Abdelnour
11-28-2019, 03:57 PM
G25 bro.

Pater Patota
11-28-2019, 04:24 PM
Kind of accurate for me

# Population Percent
1 Caucasian 49.73
2 Steppe 13.96
3 Neolithic 12.45
4 Indian 9.54
5 NorthEastEuropean 5.99
6 NearEast 4.4
7 Siberian 2.56
8 Subsaharian 0.53
9 SouthEastAsian 0.51
10 Australian 0.32


# Population (source) Distance
1 Azerbaijani (Azerbaijan) 5.68
2 Circassian (Circassia) 5.82
3 Kabardin (Kabardino-Balkaria) 5.89
4 Azerbaijani_Dagestan (Azerbaijan_Dagestan) 6.07
5 Armenian (Armenia) 6.18
6 Turk (Istanbul) 6.53
7 Ossetian (North_Ossetia) 6.59
8 Armenian (Chambarak) 6.71
9 Armenian (Erzrum) 6.74
10 Azerbaijani_Khachmaz (Azerbaijan_Khachmaz) 6.79
11 Turk (Adana) 6.8
12 Turk (Kayseri) 6.83
13 Azerbaijani_Agdzhabedi (Azerbaijan_Agdzhabedi) 7.22
14 Azerbaijani_Dagestan (Azerbaijan_Dagestan) 7.37
15 Adjar (Adjaria) 7.39
16 Greek (Azov) 7.58
17 Armenian (Dprabak) 7.8
18 Azeri (Azerbaijan) 7.88
19 Armenian (Yegvard) 7.92
20 Armenian (Martuni) 8.03


# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 65.3% Armenian (Armenia) + 34.7% Avar (Dagestan) @ 2.37
2 68% Armenian (Armenia) + 32% Ava (Dagestan_Khunzakh) @ 2.49
3 59.8% Armenian (Armenia) + 40.2% Lezgin (Dagestan) @ 2.57
4 80.2% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 19.8% Mishar-Tatar (Mordovia) @ 2.59
5 51.5% Kabardin (Kabardino-Balkaria) + 48.5% Armenian (Armenia) @ 2.6
6 63.2% Turk (Kayseri) + 36.8% Tabasaran (Dagestan) @ 2.63
7 57% Turk (Kayseri) + 43% Lezgin (Dagestan) @ 2.65
8 80% Georgian (Georgia) + 20% Kryashen (Bashkortostan) @ 2.66
9 66.3% Armenian (Armenia) + 33.7% Dargin (Urkarah) @ 2.67
10 51.9% Circassian (Circassia) + 48.1% Armenian (Armenia) @ 2.67
11 85.7% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 14.3% Saami_WGA (Lapland) @ 2.67
12 83.3% Adjar (Adjaria) + 16.7% Kryashen (Bashkortostan) @ 2.7
13 62.4% Armenian (Armenia) + 37.6% Kumyk (Stalskoe) @ 2.7
14 84.4% Adjar (Adjaria) + 15.6% Irish (Ireland) @ 2.72
15 85% Adjar (Adjaria) + 15% Russian (Kostroma) @ 2.74
16 83.3% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 16.7% Chuvash (Chuvashia) @ 2.75
17 63.9% Lezgin (Dagestan) + 36.1% Cypriot (Cyprus) @ 2.75
18 86.2% Adjar (Adjaria) + 13.8% Karelian (Karelia) @ 2.76
19 80.9% Georgian_Abkhazia (Abkhazia) + 19.1% Kryashen (Bashkortostan) @ 2.77
20 83.4% Georgian (Georgia) + 16.6% Finn (SouthFinland) @ 2.77

Ahaddad
11-28-2019, 04:31 PM
G25 bro.

Where this calculator?

JamesBond007
11-28-2019, 04:52 PM
MDLP k16 give strange results for some people, i have see many Lebanese gettin a Cypriot, some Iraqis get Armenian Gavar, some Armenians geting Georgia Laz, I don’t know why but results of K16 are very different of Mdlp k23 for example one Iraqi get Iraqi, Iraqi mandean, Jew Iraq or Mountain Jews in Mdlp k23 or k22 and no one Armenian in oracle, but when you put in Mdlp k 16 you see Armenian in 2 of distance in first of oracles and a lot of Armenians. See example of kit T107876

I could be wrong but I think MDLP calculators are probably optimized Lithuanians and also perhaps around that area generally.

Ahaddad
11-29-2019, 03:10 AM
Bump

Abdelnour
11-29-2019, 06:07 AM
Where this calculator?

You have to pay 12 USD to Davidski.

https://bga101.blogspot.com/2017/10/genetic-ancestry-online-store-to-be.html?m=1

Send him an email with Raw data file and he will give you coordinates.

Once you get the coordinates, paste them here and we can run some tests for you and show you a link to run the test yourself.

Thracian
11-29-2019, 08:40 AM
Not for me.