Log in

View Full Version : Caucasians not cluster with Europeans?



thenewestmember
01-09-2020, 07:08 AM
I saw this comments in this forum but hard me to believe. maybe they don't cluster in ancestral genes but cluster in somatic genes (body genes) right?

Kyp
01-09-2020, 07:25 AM
It's true. They don't cluster with Europeans (autosomal).
Closest populations are other West Asians.

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 07:33 AM
Yeah, in fact some west asians are even closer to pashtuns like me(slighlty) than to greeks and albanians even, if not as equally as close

catgeorge
01-09-2020, 07:34 AM
Continental Europeans don't score high west asian.

Greeks are the closest 10% West Asian v 60% in Caucasus - 10% is probably mainly from Anatolia + Pontus

Greeks have 0% East Asian other than Turkish minority in Thrace versus ~15% East Asian in Caucasus so don't cluster

Quite a distance actually

asuvis
01-09-2020, 07:34 AM
I saw this comments in this forum but hard me to believe. maybe they don't cluster in ancestral genes but cluster in somatic genes (body genes) right?

Hajimurad
01-09-2020, 07:36 AM
Before Bronze Age majority of Europe (except North), Middle East (up to Indus river) and Caucasus were inhabited by Neolithic farmers, who stemmed from common ancestral population of Fertile crescent. After Indo-European invasion only Caucasians remained unmixed with invaders.

FinalFlash
01-09-2020, 07:37 AM
დიახ, ჩვენ მსგავსი ირანელები და თურქები ვართ.

უფრო ჰგავს სომხებს, ვიდრე ყველაფერს, შედარებით ლაპარაკს

FinalFlash
01-09-2020, 07:38 AM
Before Bronze Age majority of Europe (except North), Middle East (up to Indus river) and Caucasus were inhabited by Neolithic farmers, who stemmed from common ancestral population of Fertile crescent. After Indo-European invasion only Caucasians remained unmixed with invaders.

What about Steppe admixture? Caucasians, especially Northern Caucasians seem to have plenty of it.

Kyp
01-09-2020, 07:39 AM
Distance to: Georgian
3.74562411 Abhkasian
5.21743232 Georgian_imereti
10.57308848 Adygei
10.68881659 Ossetian
10.99009099 Turk_Meskhetian
11.99394847 North_Ossetian
13.25436532 Balkar
13.74912725 Laz
14.56931364 Kumyk
15.23274434 Kabardin
16.36186114 Kurdish
16.57763855 Talysh
16.68636569 Zaza
16.93680017 Chechen
17.50424520 Kurd_Kurmanji_Turkey
17.55608442 Turk_East_Black_Sea
17.66450679 Kurd_Iran
17.66871812 Lezgin
18.08897454 Armenian_East
18.16440475 Azerbaijani_Iran
18.42435073 Lor_Iran
18.61380402 Kurd_Sorani
18.62012621 Turk_East
18.96660223 Azerbaijani_Turkey
19.83603035 Iranian

Trouble
01-09-2020, 07:39 AM
Yup, Caucasians have lots of CHG(and proper CHG) which Europeans largely lack. Caucasians are closest to populations of the Iranian plateau. However it varies among the groups themselves for examples Chechens have lots of steppe which Georgians seem to lack.

Hajimurad
01-09-2020, 07:41 AM
What about Steppe admixture? Caucasians, especially Northern Caucasians seem to have plenty of it.

Which Caucasians do you mean? Ossetes, who speak Aryan language? Karachay-Balkar or Kumyk, who speak Turkic language?
I mean isolated speakers of aboriginal languages. Of course those aboriginals who live in lowlands mixed with Turkics and Russians.

FinalFlash
01-09-2020, 07:43 AM
Which Caucasians do you mean? Ossetes, who speak Aryan language? Karachay-Balkar or Kumyk, who speak Turkic language?
I mean isolated speakers of aboriginal languages. Of course those aboriginals who live in lowlands mixed with Turkics and Russians.

I mean all Northern Caucasians seem to have a lot of Steppe admixture. Avars, Tabassarans, and Chechens/Ingush especially. Ossetians and Circassians seem to have plenty too.

Hajimurad
01-09-2020, 07:56 AM
I mean all Northern Caucasians seem to have a lot of Steppe admixture. Avars, Tabassarans, and Chechens/Ingush especially. Ossetians and Circassians seem to have plenty too.

Tabasarans live near Derbent and have a lot of R1b-L23 haplogroup (definitely came from Azerbaijan but of which date I don't know).
Avars who live in mountains never mix with foreigners only those who live in plains (chiefly with Kumyks and Chechens).
Chechen republic had once numerous Turkic (their remnants - Kumyks of Braguny village) and Russian (from Stalin to Dudaev) populations. Lowland Chechens mixed with them but mountain Chechens didn't.
Ingush genetically are purest Vaynakhs. Only Ingush of Jeirakh (Dzheyrakh) mixed with Ossetes.
About Ossetes and Circassians - agree.

FinalFlash
01-09-2020, 07:58 AM
Tabasarans live near Derbent and have a lot of R1b-L23 haplogroup (definitely came from Azerbaijan but of which date I don't know).
Avars who live in mountains never mix with foreigners only those who live in plains (chiefly with Kumyks and Chechens).
Chechen republic had once numerous Turkic (their remnants - Kumyks of Braguny village) and Russian (from Stalin to Dudaev) populations. Lowland Chechens mixed with them but mountain Chechens didn't.
Ingush genetically are purest Vaynakhs. Only Ingush of Jeirakh (Dzheyrakh) mixed with Ossetes.
About Ossetes and Circassians - agree.

How sure are you? Every sample or average I've ever seen seemed to have all North Caucasians score an ample amount of Steppe admixture regardless of the calculator. If what you are saying is true then we really have to start questioning these samples that are available to us.

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 07:59 AM
DIstance to both pashtuns and albanians(didnt pick up greeks, because i didnt knew which greek group is avg and which isnt):

Distance to: Abkhasian
0.13335967 Albanian
0.13850278 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.13904105 Nomansman_scaled
0.14457730 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.14492243 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.15668695 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.15974823 Balochi


Distance to: Adygei
0.11757177 Albanian
0.12112065 Nomansman_scaled
0.12121328 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12542200 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12660111 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13852487 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14960230 Balochi


Distance to: Armenian
0.11209224 Albanian
0.14889518 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15449313 Nomansman_scaled
0.15924904 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15975658 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16227835 Balochi
0.17191933 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af


Distance to: Armenian_Hemsheni
0.12123702 Albanian
0.15362905 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15717272 Nomansman_scaled
0.16218114 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16261891 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.16726103 Balochi
0.17505045 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af



Distance to: Azeri
0.10154029 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10846024 Nomansman_scaled
0.10987665 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11055350 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11953811 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12024934 Albanian
0.12050909 Balochi


Distance to: Azeri_Dagestan
0.09588650 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.09926684 Nomansman_scaled
0.10266830 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10521887 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11575147 Albanian
0.11630660 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12027279 Balochi


Distance to: Azeri_Turkey
0.10400430 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11264099 Nomansman_scaled
0.11354796 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11508551 Albanian
0.11816876 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12476298 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12623321 Balochi


Distance to: Balkar
0.10987420 Nomansman_scaled
0.11011046 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11155881 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11312659 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12334811 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12340710 Albanian
0.14132752 Balochi


Distance to: Cypriot
0.08915391 Albanian
0.17404354 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.18276522 Nomansman_scaled
0.18526328 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.18533914 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.19164584 Balochi
0.19641340 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af



Distance to: Ingushian
0.11215943 Nomansman_scaled
0.11363626 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11700840 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11896768 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12237276 Albanian
0.13036595 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14230379 Balochi


Distance to: Iranian_Seyyed
0.08502644 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.09157374 Nomansman_scaled
0.09528826 Balochi
0.09585521 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.09592419 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10717415 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13881491 Albanian

Distance to: Iranian_Mazandarani
0.08856825 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.09045853 Nomansman_scaled
0.09154235 Balochi
0.09786890 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10054725 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11246347 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.15248056 Albanian


Distance to: Iranian_Lor
0.10207401 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10755967 Nomansman_scaled
0.11081537 Balochi
0.11312627 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11435126 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12501894 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13259985 Albanian



Distance to: Iranian_Fars
0.08579001 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.09125868 Nomansman_scaled
0.09619577 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.09730358 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.09836476 Balochi
0.10900348 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13344571 Albanian


More to go

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 08:00 AM
Distance to: Kumyk
0.10460924 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10526685 Nomansman_scaled
0.10798918 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10862897 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11265140 Albanian
0.11991278 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13495955 Balochi

Distance to: Karachay
0.10717622 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10781506 Nomansman_scaled
0.10955432 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11106936 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12017767 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12136549 Albanian
0.13856313 Balochi

Distance to: Iranian_Zoroastrian
0.09177255 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.09559226 Nomansman_scaled
0.10259029 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10304997 Balochi
0.10329946 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11692811 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12957061 Albanian



Distance to: Talysh_Azerbaijan
0.10534997 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10828891 Nomansman_scaled
0.11274966 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11410125 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11750714 Balochi
0.12596285 Albanian
0.12627046 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Tabasaran
0.09843068 Nomansman_scaled
0.10472615 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10674341 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10753560 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12339336 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12512111 Albanian
0.13245759 Balochi

Distance to: North_Ossetian
0.11131484 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11153815 Nomansman_scaled
0.11478446 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11718901 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12603480 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13359618 Albanian
0.14030031 Balochi

Distance to: Nogai
0.21386265 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.23175456 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.23204263 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.24399167 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.24779362 Nomansman_scaled
0.26830694 Balochi
0.30917123 Albanian

Distance to: Kurdish
0.11139277 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11504086 Nomansman_scaled
0.12090325 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12155444 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12168642 Balochi
0.12363102 Albanian
0.13434238 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Kumyk
0.10460924 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10526685 Nomansman_scaled
0.10798918 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10862897 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11265140 Albanian
0.11991278 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13495955 Balochi


Distance to: Turkish_Central
0.10035879 Albanian
0.11472365 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12116345 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12172674 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12244007 Nomansman_scaled
0.12926680 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14077772 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Balikesir
0.10419892 Albanian
0.11159426 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11486096 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11658811 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11867853 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11950839 Nomansman_scaled
0.14489507 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Aydin
0.10652146 Albanian
0.11614404 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11887575 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11972797 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12382133 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.12408023 Nomansman_scaled
0.14606727 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Adana
0.09933830 Albanian
0.11310554 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12044598 Nomansman_scaled
0.12130302 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12186571 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13046222 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13695628 Balochi

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 08:00 AM
Distance to: Turkish_Northwest
0.10238526 Albanian
0.11276942 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11481312 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11547732 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11934584 Nomansman_scaled
0.12063356 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14401610 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_North
0.10819116 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11057236 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11249254 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11528246 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11559340 Nomansman_scaled
0.11570310 Albanian
0.13905226 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Kayseri
0.09725727 Albanian
0.12107325 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12867011 Nomansman_scaled
0.12889641 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12982886 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13840143 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14425851 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul
0.07609230 Albanian
0.11796113 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12461268 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12481828 Nomansman_scaled
0.12511718 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13449262 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14747581 Balochi



Distance to: Chechen
0.10724010 Nomansman_scaled
0.11067395 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11346335 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11378879 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12416890 Albanian
0.12868536 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13876506 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Trabzon
0.10775806 Albanian
0.15638323 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.16147194 Nomansman_scaled
0.16603225 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16606647 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.17224798 Balochi
0.17843980 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Turkish_Southwest
0.10996903 Albanian
0.11068581 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11096432 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11325046 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11678509 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11748345 Nomansman_scaled
0.13899865 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_South
0.10486613 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.10540377 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10669377 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10870025 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11174944 Nomansman_scaled
0.12333362 Albanian
0.13384822 Balochi


Distance to: Georgian_Laz
0.12041574 Albanian
0.15343426 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15618604 Nomansman_scaled
0.16190185 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16195335 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.16981101 Balochi
0.17459633 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Georgian_Imer
0.13801295 Albanian
0.15014413 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15108985 Nomansman_scaled
0.15735857 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15859020 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16647464 Balochi
0.17088936 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af



As whole, theyre probably slightly closer to albanians than to pashtuns, but looking at the distances really show how close west asians are to euro cluster

Also, wtf is it with the smileys?

FinalFlash
01-09-2020, 08:04 AM
Distance to: Turkish_Northwest
0.10238526 Albanian
0.11276942 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11481312 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11547732 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11934584 Nomansman_scaled
0.12063356 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14401610 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_North
0.10819116 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11057236 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11249254 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11528246 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11559340 Nomansman_scaled
0.11570310 Albanian
0.13905226 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Kayseri
0.09725727 Albanian
0.12107325 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12867011 Nomansman_scaled
0.12889641 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12982886 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13840143 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14425851 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul
0.07609230 Albanian
0.11796113 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12461268 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12481828 Nomansman_scaled
0.12511718 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.13449262 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14747581 Balochi



Distance to: Chechen
0.10724010 Nomansman_scaled
0.11067395 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11346335 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11378879 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12416890 Albanian
0.12868536 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.13876506 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_Trabzon
0.10775806 Albanian
0.15638323 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.16147194 Nomansman_scaled
0.16603225 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16606647 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.17224798 Balochi
0.17843980 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Turkish_Southwest
0.10996903 Albanian
0.11068581 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.11096432 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.11325046 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.11678509 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11748345 Nomansman_scaled
0.13899865 Balochi

Distance to: Turkish_South
0.10486613 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.10540377 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.10669377 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.10870025 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.11174944 Nomansman_scaled
0.12333362 Albanian
0.13384822 Balochi


Distance to: Georgian_Laz
0.12041574 Albanian
0.15343426 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15618604 Nomansman_scaled
0.16190185 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16195335 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.16981101 Balochi
0.17459633 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af

Distance to: Georgian_Imer
0.13801295 Albanian
0.15014413 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15108985 Nomansman_scaled
0.15735857 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15859020 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16647464 Balochi
0.17088936 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af



As whole, theyre probably slightly closer to albanians than to pashtuns, but looking at the distances really show how close west asians are to euro cluster

Also, wtf is it with the smileys?

North Caucasians seem to lack the EEF admix that South Caucasians have hence why the latter are closer to the Euro cluster ironically despite scoring less Steppe admix.

catgeorge
01-09-2020, 08:04 AM
No.

Thats just manipulating figures for a biased or desired result.

Facts

https://i.imgur.com/5jbkEdu.png

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 08:10 AM
Also, some of the istanbul turks looks like turkified balkanites:


Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25098
0.03004374 Albanian
0.17203154 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.17772982 Nomansman_scaled
0.17848313 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.17963029 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.18626266 surbakhun
0.19008602 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.20405430 Balochi




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25095
0.06691810 Albanian
0.14278523 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.14388988 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.14560098 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.14869513 Nomansman_scaled
0.15372834 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.15393742 surbakhun
0.17729300 Balochi




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25081
0.08077274 Albanian
0.11901622 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12304202 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12376733 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12462175 Nomansman_scaled
0.12682675 surbakhun
0.13320149 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14871204 Balochi
(possibly some ancestry maybe?)




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul15781
0.03894723 Albanian
0.14910812 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15609862 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15614119 Nomansman_scaled
0.15841004 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16289939 surbakhun
0.16823486 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.17981083 Balochi



Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul15781
0.03894723 Albanian
0.14910812 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15609862 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15614119 Nomansman_scaled
0.15841004 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16289939 surbakhun
0.16823486 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.17981083 Balochi


I assume if they wouldnt had been added, istanbul turks would had been closer to pashtuns as well as other turks.

Interesting these samples are just labelled as turks. Not saying turks cant look euro without euro ancestry, but i can kind of now see why there are a good bunch of euro looking turks amongst turks.

Hajimurad
01-09-2020, 08:11 AM
How sure are you? Every sample or average I've ever seen seemed to have all North Caucasians score an ample amount of Steppe admixture regardless of the calculator. If what you are saying is true then we really have to start questioning these samples that are available to us.

I'd prefer more to rely on Y-DNA and MtDNA results than to autosomes. Haplogroups show from which ethnic group are your nearest relatives.

Kivan
01-09-2020, 08:14 AM
Also, some of the istanbul turks looks like turkified balkanites:


Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25098
0.03004374 Albanian
0.17203154 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.17772982 Nomansman_scaled
0.17848313 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.17963029 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.18626266 surbakhun
0.19008602 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.20405430 Balochi




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25095
0.06691810 Albanian
0.14278523 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.14388988 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.14560098 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.14869513 Nomansman_scaled
0.15372834 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.15393742 surbakhun
0.17729300 Balochi




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul25081
0.08077274 Albanian
0.11901622 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.12304202 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.12376733 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.12462175 Nomansman_scaled
0.12682675 surbakhun
0.13320149 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.14871204 Balochi
(possibly some ancestry maybe?)




Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul15781
0.03894723 Albanian
0.14910812 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15609862 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15614119 Nomansman_scaled
0.15841004 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16289939 surbakhun
0.16823486 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.17981083 Balochi



Distance to: Turkish_Istanbul:Istanbul15781
0.03894723 Albanian
0.14910812 AFG/pashtun_scaled
0.15609862 Pashtun:Pashtun2_8Af
0.15614119 Nomansman_scaled
0.15841004 Pashtun:Pashtun2_22Af
0.16289939 surbakhun
0.16823486 Pashtun:Pashtun2_20Af
0.17981083 Balochi


I assume if they wouldnt had been added, istanbul turks would had been closer to pashtuns as well as other turks.

Interesting these samples are just labelled as turks. Not saying turks cant look euro without euro ancestry, but i can kind of now see why there are a good bunch of euro looking turks amongst turks.

They are Balkan Turks. Turks from Macedonia and Thrace plot closer to other Balkanites, they are modelled as native Balkan + Central Asian. Don't say non sense.

catgeorge
01-09-2020, 08:15 AM
Again, No.

All these people don't have any Mediterranean, Atlantic, component so they won't cluster with any South Europeans - Caucasians have 0% Balkan and Italian admixture.

Nomansman
01-09-2020, 08:17 AM
They are Balkan Turks. Turks from Macedonia and Thrace plot closer to other Balkanites, they are modelled as native Balkan + Central Asian. Don't say non sense.

Well, turks with a lot of balkan admix in them.

thenewestmember
01-09-2020, 07:51 PM
what about somatic genes? I mean the genes responsible physical bodily traits?

Leto
01-09-2020, 08:01 PM
I mean all Northern Caucasians seem to have a lot of Steppe admixture. Avars, Tabassarans, and Chechens/Ingush especially. Ossetians and Circassians seem to have plenty too.
Yes

These are G25 models for North Caucasians I did a few months ago. No Lezgins unfortunately, they are the fourth largest Dagestani ethnic group but I guess Tabasarans should be pretty similar. By the way, Lezgins are the largest minority in Azerbaijan and they are stereotypically lighter than Azeris.

"sample": "Avar:Average",
"fit": 1.8229,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 64.17,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 32.5,
"Mongola": 1.67,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 0.83,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 0.83,

"sample": "Azeri_Dagestan:Average",
"fit": 2.2428,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 55.83,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 19.17,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 15.83,
"Mongola": 5,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 4.17,

"sample": "Chechen:Average",
"fit": 1.5447,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 69.17,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 21.67,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 5.83,
"Mongola": 3.33,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 0,

"sample": "Darginian:Average",
"fit": 2.189,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 61.67,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 37.5,
"Mongola": 0.83,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 0,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 0,

"sample": "Ingushian:Average",
"fit": 1.6729,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 72.5,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 18.33,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 5,
"Mongola": 3.33,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 0.83,

"sample": "Kumyk:Average",
"fit": 1.6715,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 54.17,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 20.83,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 10.83,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 8.33,
"Mongola": 5.83,

"sample": "Lak:Average",
"fit": 1.9879,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 63.33,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 34.17,
"Mongola": 2.5,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 0,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 0,

"sample": "Tabasaran:Average",
"fit": 1.5707,
"RUS_Maykop_Late": 62.5,
"Yamnaya_RUS_Samara": 30.83,
"Levant_Canaanite_MBA": 3.33,
"Anatolia_Barcin_C": 1.67,
"Mongola": 1.67,
The Caucasus region lies between the Black Sea (in the West) and the Caspian Sea (in the East). The closer to the Black Sea, the more Anatolian-like admixture. Conversely, Dagestan seems to have the largest percentage of European Hunter-Gatherer admixture. Except for the Kumyks that are a coastal Turkic-speaking ethnic group in Eastern Dagestan.