El_Abominacion LivingDNA

[El_Abominacion]

They updated two times for some reason, this is the most recent version

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200407/1c9cce6293d1f10baa2e53ed9522fab2.jpg
https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200407/4cd958098b33bc555ea0c2bcbbfb329b.jpg

[Thambi]

nice results. your south asian is lower than usual, while your east asian and african increased a bit.

[El_Abominacion]

nice results. your south asian is lower than usual, while your east asian and african increased a bit.

Thanks mate, yeah the South Asian does look quite low for some reason, I typically get 35-40%. The components though are interesting, they point towards what I currently assume about my South Asian ancestry. About 1/8 Indian from my dad’s side and 1/4 Pak Punjabi Kashmiri (from mums), with a bit of indigenous far Northern ancestry. The African is pretty consistent with most results, but for some reason my 23 v4 chip makes it really low at 6.6%. Apart from that it’s typically 8-11%

[waam]

Cool results. They Don't seem too far off from you paper trail ancestry. Did you get tested with 23andme as well?

[Tooting Carmen]

Interesting results indeed.

[Duffmannn]

https://image.freepik.com/vector-gratis/arco-iris-cubierto-nubes-fondo-cielo_1017-20124.jpg

[El_Abominacion]

Cool results. They Don't seem too far off from you paper trail ancestry. Did you get tested with 23andme as well?

Cheers, here’s my V5 report ^

https://you.23andme.com/published/reports/eea3db7400c44f6a/?share_id=99bbe64ba14a40a9

[waam]

Thanks! Aren't too far off from each other, cool.

[TheMaestro]

Its costs 39 dollars or not? I uploaded my kit, thought its for free.

[gixajo]

They updated two times for some reason, this is the most recent version

G]

Very interesting results.We need more people like you in this forum.

Do you know where were your Spanish grandmother from exactly?

[El_Abominacion]

Its costs 39 dollars or not? I uploaded my kit, thought its for free.

You can upload for free but they give you only your top 4 continental regions, if you want the full thing right now it’s the equivalent of £29

[El_Abominacion]

Very interesting results.We need more people like you in this forum.

Do you know where were your Spanish grandmother from exactly?

Thanks^

My Grandma was born in Santiago De Compostela. One of her parents was also from there, the other from Castilla y León. The Iberian being East Iberia seems weird considering this

[gixajo]

Thanks^

My Grandma was born in Santiago De Compostela. One of her parents was also from there, the other from Castilla y León. The Iberian being East Iberia seems weird considering this

I see the Basque flag in your avatar, I thought maybe she could have been Basque or half Basque,but LivingDna use to mark Basque usually also, and being form castilla y León and Galician ancestry, your grandmother herself should have been about 5-6% basque.

Anyway cool results.

[TheMaestro]

You can upload for free but they give you only your top 4 continental regions, if you want the full thing right now it’s the equivalent of £29

I cant unlock neither, I just see Europe highlighted thats all.

[El_Abominacion]

I cant unlock neither, I just see Europe highlighted thats all.
That’s weird, maybe you are using a different browser? Try it on Chrome

[El_Abominacion]

I see the Basque flag in your avatar, I thought maybe she could have been Basque or half Basque,but LivingDna use to mark Basque usually also, and being form castilla y León and Galician ancestry, your grandmother herself should have been about 5-6% basque.

Anyway cool results.

Thank you ^

My Mt haplogroup is supposed to be Basque in origin, also my avatar is from the book version of A Clockwork Orange (unless you were referring to the banner which seems more likely now). I only just noticed the similarity in the colour scheme as you pointed it out lol

https://media.giphy.com/media/LMUDDbZsPSJ6o/giphy.gif

I did also use to live in Santander, near to Basque country

[gixajo]

Thank you ^

My Mt haplogroup is supposed to be Basque in origin, also my avatar is from the book version of A Clockwork Orange (unless you were referring to the banner which seems more likely now). I only just noticed the similarity in the colour scheme as you pointed it out lol

https://media.giphy.com/media/LMUDDbZsPSJ6o/giphy.gif

I did also use to live in Santander, near to Basque country

Yes, I meant the banner. I called "avatar" to all that you have there, the image and all the information above and below it.

[TheMaestro]

That’s weird, maybe you are using a different browser? Try it on Chrome

Im using chrome bruv.

[El_Abominacion]

Im using chrome bruv.

Ah shit no clue then. I’d say try reuploading your data onto a new account

[-Invictus-]

https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/023/098/1038860.jpg

[calxpal]

Very cool results, so many categories! How did you feel about the accuracy?

[El_Abominacion]

Very cool results, so many categories! How did you feel about the accuracy?

Cheers, I feel it's mostly accurate. The only minor issues are the Iberian all being East Iberian seeing as my Spanish grandmother's family are from the North/West of the country. My French ancestry from my father's side of the family also appears to have been absorbed into this East Iberian category. The African categories are interesting but Coloured/Kleurlinge shouldn't be a category considering how mixed they are - not to mention they're exclusive to South Africa. It's a much more detailed analysis than most sites do though, so I appreciate that

[calxpal]

Cheers, I feel it's mostly accurate. The only minor issues are the Iberian all being East Iberian seeing as my Spanish grandmother's family are from the North/West of the country. My French ancestry from my father's side of the family also appears to have been absorbed into this East Iberian category. The African categories are interesting but Coloured/Kleurlinge shouldn't be a category considering how mixed they are - not to mention they're exclusive to South Africa. It's a much more detailed analysis than most sites do though, so I appreciate that
Good to hear :)

[JamesBond007]

Cheers, I feel it's mostly accurate. The only minor issues are the Iberian all being East Iberian seeing as my Spanish grandmother's family are from the North/West of the country. My French ancestry from my father's side of the family also appears to have been absorbed into this East Iberian category. The African categories are interesting but Coloured/Kleurlinge shouldn't be a category considering how mixed they are - not to mention they're exclusive to South Africa. It's a much more detailed analysis than most sites do though, so I appreciate that

Do you feel it's more accurate than Gedmatch or G25 (not sure if you did this) ? It seems to me things such as G25 are overhyped or at least the default data sheets. My LivingDNA is similar to my AncestryDNA. I don't want to highjack your thread with my info though. Basically, both AncestryDNA have me as Irish/Scottish with English admixture more or less with some Germanic admixture but in LivingDNA the Germanic is more absorbed into Scottish (e.g. small amounts of Norwegian) and English (continental Germanic). That being said that still seems more accurate than G25 which the default average of modern groups data sheet has my single closest population as Dutch and Norwegian rather than say Scottish AND it breaks down my heritage nmonte style as mostly Norwegian with some Spanish:picard2:

[El_Abominacion]

Do you feel it's more accurate than Gedmatch or G25 (not sure if you did this) ? It seems to me things such as G25 are overhyped or at least the default data sheets. My LivingDNA is similar to my AncestryDNA. I don't want to highjack your thread with my info though. Basically, both AncestryDNA have me as Irish/Scottish with English admixture more or less with some Germanic admixture but in LivingDNA the Germanic is more absorbed into Scottish (e.g. small amounts of Norwegian) and English (continental Germanic). That being said that still seems more accurate than G25 which the default average of modern groups data sheet has my single closest population as Dutch and Norwegian rather than say Scottish AND it breaks down my heritage nmonte style as mostly Norwegian with some Spanish:picard2:

I’ve been meaning to get G25 for a while but haven’t gotten round to it lol

For GEDmatch it’s a bit hard to say, the oracles though are super speculative for me even the 4 way ones. I usually get modelled as something like Somali + Thai + Romanian + Indian or another off mix. My mother is biracial and has it much better on Gedmatch, her 2 way fits are very accurate with low distances. It’s impressive really. For me though, I only really pay attention to the actual values.

Livingdna does appear to absorb admixtures, you could post your result here if you want. Funny you mention AncestryDNA as it also has me at 10% or so Ireland somehow, though I do have almost 10% NWE on 23andme.

[Chris596]

I’ve been meaning to get G25 for a while but haven’t gotten round to it lol

For GEDmatch it’s a bit hard to say, the oracles though are super speculative for me even the 4 way ones. I usually get modelled as something like Somali + Thai + Romanian + Indian or another off mix. My mother is biracial and has it much better on Gedmatch, her 2 way fits are very accurate with low distances. It’s impressive really. For me though, I only really pay attention to the actual values.

Livingdna does appear to absorb admixtures, you could post your result here if you want. Funny you mention AncestryDNA as it also has me at 10% or so Ireland somehow, though I do have almost 10% NWE on 23andme.

Speaking of GEDmatch, I have the same issue in some calculators, sometimes even the 3 or 2 way oracles are better for me than the 4 way ones.

Sometimes I get mixes likes English+French+Norwegian+Turkish - which is totally nonsense for me.

[JamesBond007]

I’ve been meaning to get G25 for a while but haven’t gotten round to it lol

I see


For GEDmatch it’s a bit hard to say, the oracles though are super speculative for me even the 4 way ones. I usually get modelled as something like Somali + Thai + Romanian + Indian or another off mix. My mother is biracial and has it much better on Gedmatch, her 2 way fits are very accurate with low distances. It’s impressive really. For me though, I only really pay attention to the actual values.

I see


Livingdna does appear to absorb admixtures, you could post your result here if you want. Funny you mention AncestryDNA as it also has me at 10% or so Ireland somehow, though I do have almost 10% NWE on 23andme.

Yeah, it does absorb values but it's logical , though. AncestryDNA likes to tell peole they are Irish and Scandinavian it seems so it does the opposite , sometimes, I think AncestryDNA extracted Norwegian from my Scottish which shows up as Orcadian etc.. on LivingDNA. Also, I'm 25% German/French but that mostly got absorbed into the English (in both services) which makes sense because , especially, the southern English are part German/French (I don't mean simply Anglo-Saxon but straight Kraut/French) :



https://i.postimg.cc/VNYFZwnQ/livingdna.png

[El_Abominacion]

I see



I see



Yeah, it does absorb values but it's logical , though. AncestryDNA likes to tell peole they are Irish and Scandinavian it seems so it does the opposite , sometimes, I think AncestryDNA extracted Norwegian from my Scottish which shows up as Orcadian etc.. on LivingDNA. Also, I'm 25% German/French but that mostly got absorbed into the English (in both services) which makes sense because , especially, the southern English are part German/French (I don't mean simply Anglo-Saxon but straight Kraut/French) :



https://i.postimg.cc/VNYFZwnQ/livingdna.png

Oh interesting, the breakdown looks extremely detailed for people from the British Isles. Which service do you overall think is most accurate?