Eurogenes k36 is the most accurate calculator

[Avicii86]

It has the largest sample size and is the most specific. It’s the only calculator I really trust.

[Dr_Maul]

I think its relatively accurate too, although it gives me a few weird things (0% Siberian when I usually get 1-2, gives me addition Italian, East Euro and North African, as well as 0% South Asian which I'm fairly certain is impossible for me) but its probably mainly meant for Europeans only

[Dušan]

I agree. K36 is the best.

[JamesBond007]

It has the largest sample size and is the most specific. It’s the only calculator I really trust.

what's the point ? it has no oracles. I only trust shit that tells me I''m Scottish. So that is Dodecad V3, PuntDNAL global, Michal's 25k from DNAgenics and to a lesser extant Eurogenes EUtest. I'm obviously not Dutch or English etc...


Tolan's k36 taux de similitude k36 map has me closest to the Dutch and the English which bollocks.

[RyoHazuki]

what's the point ? it has no oracles. I only trust shit that tells me I''m Scottish. So that is Dodecad V3, PuntDNAL global, Michal's 25k from DNAgenics and to a lesser extant Eurogenes EUtest. I'm obviously not Dutch or English etc...


Tolan's k36 taux de similitude k36 map has me closest to the Dutch and the English which bollocks.

"GEDmatch is amateur shit"
-Kevin

[InfamousAngel99]

Eh. I’d prefer it if I could see some oracles.
My results are a bit odd, too.

[JamesBond007]

"GEDmatch is amateur shit"
-Kevin

It is that is why the calculators can be radically different telling me I'm Irish, English, Dutch, German etc.. and they can't all agree with each other. For instance, my LivingDNA results and my AncestryDNA results are relatively similar not too drastically different.

[JamesBond007]

"GEDmatch is amateur shit"
-Kevin

Also G25 is only as good as it's dataset and the regular full datasheets on the website are trash and the custom calculators are made by retarded amateurs. Meanwhile the official G25 PCA tool made by Davidski has me plotting with the Scottish and lesser extant Irish etc.... G25 was made as a PCA tool but people mostly don't use it that way :


https://vahaduo.github.io/g25views/#NorthEurope

[Oneeye]

It has too much going on.

[Oneeye]

"GEDmatch is amateur shit"
-Kevin

Well, yeah it is literally amatuer created graphs.

[JamesBond007]

It has too much going on.

Yeah, dude, it's too ambitious or something. Actually, it's too complicated :

"everything should be made a simple as possible but no simpler."-- Albert Einstein.

[Ljubic]

You tell me Italian is a valid component?

[Luke35]

Lukasz made some fine ancestry estimates for me and for other's based on K36, I think of this calculator as a good one.

[JamesBond007]

Lukasz made some fine ancestry estimates for me and for other's based on K36, I think of this calculator as a good one.

Lukasz and that dutch dude Gert , or whatever, made me a report too and was saying I was Dutch or Scottish depending on the analysis well no thanks Dutch are closer related to the English so I was not appreciating the report too much but it is kind of impressive they were able to derive Scottish from that clusterf*ck known as K36 at all. So, overall I'm not impressed.

[Luke35]

Lukasz and that dutch dude Gert , or whatever, made me a report too and was saying I was Dutch or Scottish depending on the analysis well no thanks Dutch are closer related to the English so I was not appreciating the report too much but it is kind of impressive they were able to derive Scottish from that clusterf*ck known as K36 at all. So, overall I'm not impressed.

Hahahahaha. Well I'll say this, my K36 report is better than my MyHeritage report, no contest.

[Nassbean]

It's not with that logic I'm more european than north african

[JamesBond007]

Hahahahaha. Well I'll say this, my K36 report is better than my MyHeritage report, no contest.

Yeah, well, my k36 report is better than Eurogenes in general. Gauss was a genius then this dude Gert tried his least squared method , obviously he is not a genius, the Gaussian math has me as Scottish and the non-genius math as more Dutch.

[Avicii86]

It's not with that logic I'm more european than north african

Maybe it's more bias toward Europeans. But it nailed my Amerindian

[RyoHazuki]

Well, yeah it is literally amatuer created graphs.

I find it funny he was talking shit about it but in a few cases he is so sure it represents his ethnicity.

[RyoHazuki]

It is that is why the calculators can be radically different telling me I'm Irish, English, Dutch, German etc.. and they can't all agree with each other. For instance, my LivingDNA results and my AncestryDNA results are relatively similar not too drastically different.

But Gedmatch told you you are Scottish.