Should I use G25 scaled or unscaled?

[knez01]

I was wondering which one should I use, scaled one gives me better and more realistic results, but I've read that the unscaled version is supposedly more accurate?
What do you think?

[Luke35]

My results from scaled tend to resemble more closely my known ancestry. Seems to me a lot of people here have come to favor scaled as well. Maybe Davidski has written in his blog about the pro's and con's of scaled and unscaled idk, but I don't recall any discussions here on the forum about it.

[Luke35]

Okay, one of the "similar threads" linked below (thread founder, marco), contains in it a detailed, technical assessment. But still, there is no definitive conclusion drawn in the thread as to which method has the higher accuracy.

[knez01]

Okay, one of the "similar threads" linked below (thread founder, marco), contains in it a detailed, technical assessment. But still, there is no definitive conclusion drawn in the thread as to which method has the higher accuracy.

Aha, I find unscaled results very odd, I get lots of Japanese and South African for some reason, while in scaled I get none.
I don't know what to believe, after being on this site for months I've come to the conclusion that so much of genetic testing is very unreliable. From the same raw data I get wildly different results depending on the calculator, it's all so tiresome.

[Luke35]

Aha, I find unscaled results very odd, I get lots of Japanese and South African for some reason, while in scaled I get none.
I don't know what to believe, after being on this site for months I've come to the conclusion that so much of genetic testing is very unreliable. From the same raw data I get wildly different results depending on the calculator, it's all so tiresome.

I gathered from that other thread that unscaled can pick up on those distant ancestries more efficiently.

It's unreliable and inconsistent yes I agree. However, I really take a very light hearted approach to it nowadays, and just enjoy the process of picking apart my results, examining under a microscope, and then doing it all over again the next day. I find the "hobby" of ancestry analysis oddly cathartic.

[knez01]

I gathered from that other thread that unscaled can pick up on those distant ancestries more efficiently.

It's unreliable and inconsistent yes I agree. However, I really take a very light hearted approach to it nowadays, and just enjoy the process of picking apart my results, examining under a microscope, and then doing it all over again the next day. I find the "hobby" of ancestry analysis oddly cathartic.

The amount of tests available is ridiculous, you have to buy several packages to get a realistic representation of your ethnicity. And it makes me think that this whole genetic testing industry is nothing but a scam which is made to milk people out of their money. Just like how they removed the v3 chip from 23andme, what could be the reason except greed? Absolutely shameful.

[knez01]

Well I asked David which one to use, and he told me to use the scaled version, that's what I am going to do.

[Chris596]

I gathered from that other thread that unscaled can pick up on those distant ancestries more efficiently.

It's unreliable and inconsistent yes I agree. However, I really take a very light hearted approach to it nowadays, and just enjoy the process of picking apart my results, examining under a microscope, and then doing it all over again the next day. I find the "hobby" of ancestry analysis oddly cathartic.


Well I asked David which one to use, and he told me to use the scaled version, that's what I am going to do.

He also told me to use the scaled version more often cause it's supposedly more accurate.

Mr.G, knez01, etc. what are your results here (Marques K64) ? https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?325515-NEW-G25-calc-Marques-K64

This one gives me a ton of Germanic but it's probably an error because the rest of it is accurate, sometimes it happens idk why, there's another calc where my first match is a British sample, which is, of course impossible. The German there can be replaced probably by East European and/or Balkan in my case.

[Luke35]

The amount of tests available is ridiculous, you have to buy several packages to get a realistic representation of your ethnicity. And it makes me think that this whole genetic testing industry is nothing but a scam which is made to milk people out of their money. Just like how they removed the v3 chip from 23andme, what could be the reason except greed? Absolutely shameful.

I personally think it's more incompetence rather than scam on their part - but yeah they're out to make a buck ;)

For me 23andMe was the only company where I felt the ancestry report was very good. They did predict that I am split about equally between Germany and Hungary.