Weird Serbian and Danish Y-DNA prediction from morleydna.

[Aleksandar]

Serbian DNA Prediction. Ignore the title lol. (im an idiot.)

Serbian:
Y - SNP using Experimental tree
* I1 [I1-L759 (I1-CTS10140, I1-CTS10338)]
* A1 [A-CTS3331 (A-P305, A-V168)]
* I2a2a [I2-CTS10125 (I2-CTS429, I2-CTS5286)]
* J2a1i [J2-L88 (J2-L198)]
* S1c [S-P83]

Y-SNP using ISOGG'S tree
* I1 [I1-L64 (I1-L75, I1-L80)]
* S1c [S-P83]
* A1 [A-L985 (A-L986, A-L989)]
* J2a1i [J2-L88 (J2-L198)]
* I2a2a [I2-L34 (I2-L36, I2-L59)]

[vbnetkhio]

My wife and I did a Y-DNA prediction and it was a bit unexpected with the results.
I am Serbian and she's Danish, I come from a bit more mixed background than she does, her family roots are Denmark and Sweden from her fathers side. My fathers side is from Montenegro, Eastern Europe and Serbia, mothers side Hungary, Serbia, Roma relative/s from my grandmothers side. This makes me question this website quite a bit lol. What are your thoughts on this? Maybe someone with bit more knowledge can give me a take on these results also, What is the best way to get your YDNA tested?

Our Y-DNA predictions:

Serbian:
Y - SNP using Experimental tree
* I1 [I1-L759 (I1-CTS10140, I1-CTS10338)]
* A1 [A-CTS3331 (A-P305, A-V168)]
* I2a2a [I2-CTS10125 (I2-CTS429, I2-CTS5286)]
* J2a1i [J2-L88 (J2-L198)]
* S1c [S-P83]

Y-SNP using ISOGG'S tree
* I1 [I1-L64 (I1-L75, I1-L80)]
* S1c [S-P83]
* A1 [A-L985 (A-L986, A-L989)]
* J2a1i [J2-L88 (J2-L198)]
* I2a2a [I2-L34 (I2-L36, I2-L59)]


Danish:
Y - SNP using Experimental tree
* S1c [S-P83]
* E1a2 [E-P110]
* E1b1b1a1b7 [E-L250 (E-L251, E-L252)]
* C6 [C-CTS11798 (C-F993, C-V20)]
* J [J-YSC0000239 (J-CTS3936, J-CTS1068)]

Y-SNP using ISOGG'S tree
* J [J-12F2 (J-L134, J-M304)]
* S1c [S-P83]
* C6 [C-V20 (C-V71, C-V86)]
* E1a2 [E-P110]
* E1b1b1a1b7 [E-L250 (E-L251, E-L252)]

try this predictor too:

https://cladefinder.yseq.net/

maybe it gives different results.

BTW: women have only MTdna haplogroups. men have both y and mt.
of course she'll get a weird result if you try to predict an y-dna haplo for her.

[Aleksandar]

try this predictor too:

https://cladefinder.yseq.net/

maybe it gives different results.

BTW: women have only MTdna haplogroups. men have both y and mt.
of course she'll get a weird result if you try to predict an y-dna haplo for her.

I actually didnt even think about that, i knew it came from fathers for some reason i just thought both genders have it lol. Well now i sure do feel dumb. xD

[Aleksandar]

From https://cladefinder.yseq.net/ I got I1 first and I2 second.

[Jana]

From https://cladefinder.yseq.net/ I got I1 first and I2 second.

You are I1 haplogroup for sure, while your wife has no ydna because she's a female.

[Aleksandar]

Haha well good that that's confirmed, I am dumbfounded idk why i ran this through thinking it can give results, tbh i didnt even think of it as Y and X chromosomes, i didnt even registere that Y-DNA as that... I'm not the brightest person :D

[RenaRyuguu]

bump