Who looks more Jewish, Natalie Portman or Sandra Bullock?

[Odelia]

I used non-makeup photos so we see what's hiding beneath...

Nat (who is actually an Israeli Jew):
https://www.wonderwall.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2022/05/no-makeup-natalie-portman.jpeg?h=800

Sandra (who is of German, French and other NW European persuasions, in other words: a white euromutt American):
https://image.brigitte.de/13135008/t/j6/v2/w1440/r1/-/29--sandra-bullock-ist-die-neue-koenigin-im-ranking---1-1---spoton-article-1013093.jpg

[RogueState]

None of them have a "distinguish" Ashkenazi Jewish look, they could have been either Jewish or Gentile and I wouldn't be surprised

Stereotypical Ashkenazi Jewish look on a girl would be like this girl, Caroline Ellison, that worked for the infamous cryptomoney plateform, FTX, that went bankrupt recently :
https://blog.liquid.com/hubfs/Caroline.png

Or Janice from Friends (real name of the actress : Maggie Wheeler) :
https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTA5NjA1NDM4NDFeQTJeQWpwZ15BbWU3MDM2Mjk5MDQ@._ V1_UY1200_CR124,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg

[Tooting Carmen]

Many if not most European-looking Jews are Mischlings, and that is where much of the overlap occurs. Here is a crowd of Israelis:
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367429-State-the-main-phenotypes-of-these-Israelis

[Rædwald]

They've both almost certainly had plastic surgery so it's pointless to try really.

[RogueState]

Many if not most European-looking Jews are Mischlings, and that is where much of the overlap occurs. Here is a crowd of Israelis:
https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367429-State-the-main-phenotypes-of-these-Israelis

There is no such a thing as "Israeli" as an ethnicity, it's a too young Nation-State filled with Jews from all around the world, that have no "uniform" look
Maybe in 200 years after several generations of interethnic mixing among subgroup of Jews, that will create a stabilized "Israeli" blend

[Tooting Carmen]

There is no such a thing as "Israeli" as an ethnicity, it's a too young Nation-State filled with Jews from all around the world, that have no "uniform" look
Maybe in 200 years after several generations of interethnic mixing among subgroup of Jews, that will create a stabilized "Israeli" blend

But most of them (75% or so) are Jews of some sort, and they are much darker than Tzipi Livni and Bar Refaeli in most cases.

[Tooting Carmen]

Repeat

[RogueState]

But most of them (75% or so) are Jews of some sort, and they are much darker than Tzipi Livni and Bar Refaeli in most cases.

Talking about "Jews" as a group in terms of taxonomy doesn't make any sense, it's like talking about "Americans". There are different Jewish subgroups so it's pointless

If we talk about the Ashkenazi Jews, most of them passes as regular Europeans :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nme1I3H16aI

If we talk about Moroccan Jews, many are a mix of Levantines, Southern Europeans and indigenous Berbers :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCri0_Ox8S8

If we talk about Yemenite Jews, they are just like Gulf Arabs :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQK5jCEnIOA

[aherne]

There is no such a thing as "Israeli" as an ethnicity, it's a too young Nation-State filled with Jews from all around the world, that have no "uniform" look

Of course there is an Israeli look. Go there and see! As any ethnic group, Jews have variability but the native element is Arabid-Levantine... That is the fundamental component in Jews, as it was 2k year ago

[Marshall Theodore]

Portman

[Gallop]

I would say that both within a similar range; even though the temptation is to say Sandra