Can you tell apart Pakistani, Sri Lankan, Tamil, Filipinos, and Bangladeshis from each other???

[Khinerai]

Or do they all look alike to you?

[Melkiirs]

Or do they all look alike to you?

Why do you include Filipinos in this question? They are not South Asians.

[Khinerai]

Why do you include Filipinos in this question? They are not South Asians.

Majoroty of people in TA think filipinos are indistinguishable from South Asians

They pass in Sri Lanka no problem
https://i.ibb.co/5rJcG8b/MV5-BMj-U5-Zj-Y0-MTEt-Nj-Nj-OS00-Zj-I2-LWEx-MDYt-Y2-M3-MWUx-OTk3-OGZj-Xk-Ey-Xk-Fqc-Gde-QXVy-NTI5-Nj.jpg (https://ibb.co/McJNZVF)
https://i.ibb.co/cQX9YZ8/MV5-BOTlk-Mm-Uz-ZWUt-OTI1-MC00-ODYw-LWIz-M2-Et-Y2-Ix-Zm-E3-OTU3-Zj-Jk-Xk-Ey-Xk-Fqc-Gde-QXVy-NTI5-Nj.jpg (https://ibb.co/yqBC4Zk)

[Melkiirs]

Majoroty of people in TA think filipinos are indistinguishable from South Asians

They pass in Sri Lanka no problem

The stereotypical Western image of a Desi I would think is quite different. Then again that stereotype probably does not encapsulate the full diversity of the region.

Here are male morphs from India which better correspond to the typical perception:
https://i.ibb.co/RpMRmhc/CEFF8-B65-F6-D5-4346-8435-1-E6-F991-AC177.webp (https://ibb.co/BV70x4B)

[Khinerai]

The stereotypical Western image of a Desi I would think is quite different. Then again that stereotype probably does not encapsulate the full diversity of the region.

Here are male morphs from India which better correspond to the typical perception:
https://i.ibb.co/RpMRmhc/CEFF8-B65-F6-D5-4346-8435-1-E6-F991-AC177.webp (https://ibb.co/BV70x4B)

Im talking about averages, and to your average westerner who is interested in anthropology, there is no difference between these 2 phenotypes
https://i.ibb.co/WGbj6Ld/Screenshot-20230526-210404-Tik-Tok.jpg
https://i.ibb.co/ZG8Hs4g/Screenshot-20230501-124734-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/ydyhTvk)

[Melkiirs]

Im talking about averages, and to your average westerner who is interested in anthropology, there is no difference between these 2 phenotypes

If you don't mind could you post the links to where Filipinos were passed as South Asians or vice versa? I'm curious exactly what their classifications looked like.

[Sarin]

Usually , yes (excluding Filipinos). However , there are certain Pakistanis especially among 'Muhajirs' that can be indistinguishable from rest (excluding Filipinos) . I mean I have come across some UPites / Biharis that can , at the same time , easily pass off as a Tamil , Lankan & Bangladeshi . However , not as Filipinos since the common sort I talked about lacks Mongolid element . Though there are South Asians , cchiefly in & around Himalayan belt (& may be some Bangladeshis ?) , where Filipinos might have chance . Btw I have no real experience of Filipinos I must add ; only google .

[Khinerai]

If you don't mind could you post the link to where Filipinos were passed as South Asians or vice versa? I'm curious exactly what their classifications looked like.

Its a very common theme in anthro forums to push the idea that filipinos are dravidian with small amounts of southern mongoloid admixture.

https://i.ibb.co/B2R1F4t/Screenshot-20230623-222759-Samsung-Internet.jpg (https://ibb.co/fd7cL82)

[Khinerai]

Usually , yes (excluding Filipinos). However , there are certain Pakistanis (especially among 'Muhajirs') that can be indistinguishable from rest . I mean I have come across some UPites / Biharis that can , at the same time , easily pass off as a Tamil , Lankan & Bangladeshi . However , not as Filipinos since the common sort I talked about lacks Mongolid element . Though there are South Asians , cchiefly in & around Himalayan belt (& may be some Bangladeshis ?) , where Filipinos might have chance . Btw I have no real experience of Filipinos I must add ; only google .
There are people in this forum who think the average person in the Philippines is indistinguishable from tamils and asvadi

[Jambudvīpa]

Majoroty of people in TA think filipinos are indistinguishable from South Asians

They pass in Sri Lanka no problem
https://i.ibb.co/5rJcG8b/MV5-BMj-U5-Zj-Y0-MTEt-Nj-Nj-OS00-Zj-I2-LWEx-MDYt-Y2-M3-MWUx-OTk3-OGZj-Xk-Ey-Xk-Fqc-Gde-QXVy-NTI5-Nj.jpg (https://ibb.co/McJNZVF)
https://i.ibb.co/cQX9YZ8/MV5-BOTlk-Mm-Uz-ZWUt-OTI1-MC00-ODYw-LWIz-M2-Et-Y2-Ix-Zm-E3-OTU3-Zj-Jk-Xk-Ey-Xk-Fqc-Gde-QXVy-NTI5-Nj.jpg (https://ibb.co/yqBC4Zk)

...What the hell are you talking about? There is barely if any overlap between Desis and Filipinos.

[Jambudvīpa]

Usually , yes (excluding Filipinos). However , there are certain Pakistanis especially among 'Muhajirs' that can be indistinguishable from rest (excluding Filipinos) . I mean I have come across some UPites / Biharis that can , at the same time , easily pass off as a Tamil , Lankan & Bangladeshi . However , not as Filipinos since the common sort I talked about lacks Mongolid element . Though there are South Asians , cchiefly in & around Himalayan belt (& may be some Bangladeshis ?) , where Filipinos might have chance . Btw I have no real experience of Filipinos I must add ; only google .

I'm Bangladeshi and no Filipinos do not overlap with us.

[Jambudvīpa]

There are people in this forum who think the average person in the Philippines is indistinguishable from tamils and asvadi

who?

[Khinerai]

who?
https://i.ibb.co/B2R1F4t/Screenshot-20230623-222759-Samsung-Internet.jpg (https://ibb.co/fd7cL82)

[Jambudvīpa]

https://i.ibb.co/B2R1F4t/Screenshot-20230623-222759-Samsung-Internet.jpg (https://ibb.co/fd7cL82)

he's a moron. Filipinos are mixed with Negrito. Negritos and Dravidians are different.

[Khinerai]

he's a moron. Filipinos are mixed with Negrito. Negritos and Dravidians are different.

Unfortunately this narrative being pushed is all too common in anthro forums. Its being presented as fact, when in reality its far from the truth.

[Khinerai]

I'm Bangladeshi and no Filipinos do not overlap with us.

This half malay half filipina looks psuedo desi, well the northern type of desi
https://i.ibb.co/p0bKpcZ/Screenshot-20230604-094634-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/w0BQ1VC)
https://i.ibb.co/NY69Cdp/Screenshot-20230604-123349-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/HgDt4fY)
https://i.ibb.co/0B4wFzQ/Screenshot-20230604-094310-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/TKjCbNr)

[Jambudvīpa]

This half malay half filipina looks psuedo desi, well the northern type of desi
https://i.ibb.co/p0bKpcZ/Screenshot-20230604-094634-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/w0BQ1VC)
https://i.ibb.co/NY69Cdp/Screenshot-20230604-123349-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/HgDt4fY)
https://i.ibb.co/0B4wFzQ/Screenshot-20230604-094310-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/TKjCbNr)

too mongoloid.

[Khinerai]

too mongoloid.

Thats why I said psuedo, lol from a desis perspective she would be too mongoloid.

Compare her to a filipina who has an even stronger mongoloid phenotype she kind of does
https://i.ibb.co/WBtRgGh/20200822-090623.jpg (https://ibb.co/h2fTDL6)

[Jambudvīpa]

Thats why I said psuedo, lol from a desis perspective she would be too mongoloid.

Compare her to a filipina who has an even stronger mongoloid phenotype she kind of does
https://i.ibb.co/WBtRgGh/20200822-090623.jpg (https://ibb.co/h2fTDL6)

Even a little bit of Mongoloid is enough to significantly affect a phenotype, the genes must be dominant or something

[Incal]

If you don't mind could you post the links to where Filipinos were passed as South Asians or vice versa? I'm curious exactly what their classifications looked like.

He can't. He's just talking out of his ass like he always do.

[Sarin]

I'm Bangladeshi and no Filipinos do not overlap with us.

Ok . Idk what rough % but there are some Bengalis in this side of the border that have Mongolid influence (not sure if they won't be exotic among Filipinos though) :


https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSXOTvczakqMmgU-Bhbu0YhDf6uiNEkG9lenQ&usqp=CAU

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT1wXJm6fa6ZPCBsafYEWiL_Xq29tgzu E3e_w&usqp=CAU

[Jambudvīpa]

Ok . Idk what rough % but there are some Bengalis in this side of the border that have Mongolid influence (not sure if they won't be exotic among Filipinos though) :


https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSXOTvczakqMmgU-Bhbu0YhDf6uiNEkG9lenQ&usqp=CAU

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT1wXJm6fa6ZPCBsafYEWiL_Xq29tgzu E3e_w&usqp=CAU



Possible they're mixed with some ethnic minorities like Chakma or whatnot. the average Bangladeshi phenotype is pretty well represented by these footballers.

121689

[Sarin]

Possible they're mixed with some ethnic minorities like Chakma or whatnot. the average Bangladeshi phenotype is pretty well represented by these footballers.

121689

Hmm . Btw I also notice among Bangladeshis some North Indian / Pakistani sort , I guess probably Pathan mix ? Roughly how much % are such ? Do they mostly belong to a specific group/biradri ?

[Sarin]

Khinerai , will these random Himalayan desis (just a sample) be exotic among Filipinas ?

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQGbwXkESyC-TkQhxf4eTJhvGFXdoOmCRPG4Q&usqp=CAU

[Khinerai]

Khinerai , will these random Himalayan desis (just a sample) be exotic among Filipinas ?

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQGbwXkESyC-TkQhxf4eTJhvGFXdoOmCRPG4Q&usqp=CAU

They look sino-tibetan, they look very han chinese to me.
If you told me they were filipino, I would believe you

They would pass for filipino with chinese admixture
https://aphrodite.gmanetwork.com/entertainment/photos/photo/meet_kriesha_chu__the_first_filipina_k-pop_idol__k-pop_star_6_1515814787.jpg
https://i.ibb.co/LpNtLCH/mqdefault.jpg (https://imgbb.com/)

[Khinerai]

Ok . Idk what rough % but there are some Bengalis in this side of the border that have Mongolid influence (not sure if they won't be exotic among Filipinos though) :


https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSXOTvczakqMmgU-Bhbu0YhDf6uiNEkG9lenQ&usqp=CAU

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT1wXJm6fa6ZPCBsafYEWiL_Xq29tgzu E3e_w&usqp=CAU



First could pass in myanmar, possibly atypical in Philippines
Second would be exotic in the Philippines

[Sarin]

^ Interesting . Thanks .

[Madara123]

Usually , yes (excluding Filipinos). However , there are certain Pakistanis especially among 'Muhajirs' that can be indistinguishable from rest (excluding Filipinos) . I mean I have come across some UPites / Biharis that can , at the same time , easily pass off as a Tamil , Lankan & Bangladeshi . However , not as Filipinos since the common sort I talked about lacks Mongolid element . Though there are South Asians , cchiefly in & around Himalayan belt (& may be some Bangladeshis ?) , where Filipinos might have chance . Btw I have no real experience of Filipinos I must add ; only google .

Bangladeshis tend to be very East Brachid with significant Mongoloid admixture generally speaking. There is lots of range of course so yeah some UPs or Biharis can pass easily. Generally very different though and on average phenos and frequency etc I'd say the Gangetic Indians ups biharis etc in terms of facial feature and bone structure resemble South Indians or North Indians in Punjab and stuff more from what I've seen. Individual overlap exists from North to South to East to West tho, people from gujarat or punjab or tamil nadu and bihar can pass but overall frequency and rate and average phenos etc are diff

I'd say the Rohingyas and lower Assamese people pass better in Bangladesh due to the significant Mongoloid. Upper Assam is half to full mongoloid types tho so yeah. I was seeing some native Assamese Muslim types and Hindus too and they don't look that diff from people in Rangpur or Chittagong etc. Rohingyas too

[Madara123]

Usually , yes (excluding Filipinos). However , there are certain Pakistanis especially among 'Muhajirs' that can be indistinguishable from rest (excluding Filipinos) . I mean I have come across some UPites / Biharis that can , at the same time , easily pass off as a Tamil , Lankan & Bangladeshi . However , not as Filipinos since the common sort I talked about lacks Mongolid element . Though there are South Asians , cchiefly in & around Himalayan belt (& may be some Bangladeshis ?) , where Filipinos might have chance . Btw I have no real experience of Filipinos I must add ; only google .

I don't think Bangladeshis look like Filipinos but I've seen some tiktoks and posts online where there has been mixup to people unaware of the phenotypes of both countries

[Jambudvīpa]

Bangladeshis tend to be very East Brachid with significant Mongoloid admixture generally speaking. There is lots of range of course so yeah some UPs or Biharis can pass easily. Generally very different though and on average phenos and frequency etc I'd say the Gangetic Indians ups biharis etc in terms of facial feature and bone structure resemble South Indians or North Indians in Punjab and stuff more from what I've seen. Individual overlap exists from North to South to East to West tho, people from gujarat or punjab or tamil nadu and bihar can pass but overall frequency and rate and average phenos etc are diff

I'd say the Rohingyas and lower Assamese people pass better in Bangladesh due to the significant Mongoloid. Upper Assam is half to full mongoloid types tho so yeah. I was seeing some native Assamese Muslim types and Hindus too and they don't look that diff from people in Rangpur or Chittagong etc. Rohingyas too

I'm Bangladeshi and no we don't have "signiciant Mongoloid admixture" no one in my family or even my community growing up was ever perceived as Mongoloid.

[Khinerai]

I'm Bangladeshi and no we don't have "signiciant Mongoloid admixture" no one in my family or even my community growing up was ever perceived as Mongoloid.

Bangladeshi people look very indian to me. Its extremely hard to pick them apart

[renisenb]

You're confusing Melanesians with Veddoids. Veddoids have a CM-type heavy brow bone and deep eye sockets, and no Mongoloid at all in their eyes. Melanesians have Mongoloid eyes (monolid or double-eyelid with no depth in their socket). Both have SSA noses and lips. The closest looking to Veddoids are Australoids, they look very similiar. They should probably test the DNA of Veddoid jungle tribes in India and Australoids in Papua and Melanesian jungle tribes in Java to compare. If they match, it would be interesting to know when these races split off geographically. As far as i know, India split from Africa before Australia split from Africa.

To your original question:
Filipinos are completely different from desis (South Asians). They are Melanesians with more Mongoloid.
Of the desis, Bangladeshis have some Mongoloid (they are quite close to China after all), and Pakistanis also (from Central Asia etc). I can identify Bangladeshis from their eyes usually, their eye sockets are less deep-set. Pakistanis look more Europoid but also a tiny bit more Mongoloid and Veddoid too, compared to the more Europoid people in India. Singhalese (native Sri Lankans) are a mix of Veddoid and minor Mongoloid.
Tamils are Veddoid plus Caucasoid. It's rare to find a Caucasoid looking Singhalese, but easy to find a Caucasoid looking Tamilian. Tamilians are also quite a bit taller than Sri Lankans. If a person is dark-skinned, Veddoid looking and with no Mongoloid and short, it's hard to tell if they're Tamilian or Singhalese.

[Tooting Carmen]

Filipinos and to an extent Pakistanis are the most easily distinguishable of those groups. But I can sometimes tell the others apart too.

[Madara123]

I'm Bangladeshi and no we don't have "signiciant Mongoloid admixture" no one in my family or even my community growing up was ever perceived as Mongoloid.

I highly doubt ypu're Bangladeshi if you didn't already know this fact about Banglas having significant East Asian admix through the 15% Burmese blood...even non-Bangladeshis have pointed it out to me and online.

Indo Aryan lol a fcking language family

[Madara123]

Or do they all look alike to you?

Filipinos shouldn't be included in this wtf lol.

Bangladeshis are the most easy to tell apart according to my non-brown friends familliar with the above groups due to a slight Asian shift on avg according to then. I can't really tell Pakis and Indians apart unless it's the occasional Pashtun or something. Others seem to somewhat agree in their own words

[Madara123]

Bangladeshi people look very indian to me. Its extremely hard to pick them apart

What about that West Bengal female that you said could pass as Burmese? Can other Indians and Pakis pass as locals in Burma too? Bangladeshis have double the Burmese admix that West Bengalis have as well so I'm not sure how it's extremely hard when you said the West Bengali politician woman looks Burmese lol

[Khinerai]

What about that West Bengal female that you said could pass as Burmese? Can other Indians and Pakis pass as locals in Burma too? Bangladeshis have double the Burmese admix that West Bengalis have as well so I'm not sure how it's extremely hard when you said the West Bengali politician woman looks Burmese lol

Burma is like heavily mixed with people from the indian subcontinent, those mixed people arean anonamly in most of Southeast Asia

[Jambudvīpa]

Bangladeshi people look very indian to me. Its extremely hard to pick them apart

exactly

[Jambudvīpa]

I highly doubt ypu're Bangladeshi if you didn't already know this fact about Banglas having significant East Asian admix through the 15% Burmese blood...even non-Bangladeshis have pointed it out to me and online.

Indo Aryan lol a fcking language family

you are an absolute buffoon. I could post a picture of family and close friends you could not find one single guy who looks mongoloid influenced. This idea we have 15% EA admix is complete BS

[Khinerai]

you are an absolute buffoon. I could post a picture of family and close friends you could not find one single guy who looks mongoloid influenced. This idea we have 15% EA admix is complete BS
Its the same shit I get, but is anthrotards here telling me filipinos are dravidian with minimal mongoloid admixture

[Madara123]

you are an absolute buffoon. I could post a picture of family and close friends you could not find one single guy who looks mongoloid influenced. This idea we have 15% EA admix is complete BS

You're not Bangladeshi so of course they won't lol. Eithet that or you're that Kulin guy or Son Goku from brownpundits that hates the East Asian percentages and wants to be Indian or Paki so badly. That much is obvious. The BEB median gets 15.6% Burmese. 84% of which is "pure" East Asian.

This is what leads to the East Brachid phenotype which is the most common type amongst Bangladeshis. Majority Indid with some contact Mongoloid influence

Target: Bengali_Bangladesh:Median_scaled
Distance: 1.1304% / 0.01130428
45.2 Telugu_HG03772.SG_outlier_scaled
29.0 Telugu_HG04025.SG_outlier_scaled
15.6 Burmese
10.2 Sintashta_MLBA

It's 13% on Harappaworld
bengali harappa 47% 27% 2% 4% 7% 2% 6% 1% 1% 1% 1% 1%

Razib confirms it here
https://www.brownpundits.com/2020/02/14/most-bangladeshis-are-10-to-20-east-asian/

[Madara123]

Its the same shit I get, but is anthrotards here telling me filipinos are dravidian with minimal mongoloid admixture

FiIlipinos are completely different, who even brought them up here? Filipinos are like 80-90% East Asian

[Jambudvīpa]

You're not Bangladeshi so of course they won't lol. Eithet that or you're that Kulin guy or Son Goku from brownpundits that hates the East Asian percentages and wants to be Indian or Paki so badly. That much is obvious. The BEB median gets 15.6% Burmese. 84% of which is "pure" East Asian.

This is what leads to the East Brachid phenotype which is the most common type amongst Bangladeshis. Majority Indid with some contact Mongoloid influence

Target: Bengali_Bangladesh:Median_scaled
Distance: 1.1304% / 0.01130428
45.2 Telugu_HG03772.SG_outlier_scaled
29.0 Telugu_HG04025.SG_outlier_scaled
15.6 Burmese
10.2 Sintashta_MLBA

It's 13% on Harappaworld
bengali harappa 47% 27% 2% 4% 7% 2% 6% 1% 1% 1% 1% 1%

Razib confirms it here
https://www.brownpundits.com/2020/02/14/most-bangladeshis-are-10-to-20-east-asian/

in what world is the east brachid the most common phenotype amongst Bangladeshis? you are waffling big time. 121933 This is the Bangladesh national football team, how is it possible that not a single one of them is the East Brachid phenotype if its the most common one in the country. I could send pictures of my family or the community I grew up in and you wouldn't see a single East Brachid amongst them.

Some people on border regions like in Sylhet or Chittagong may have some admix but I will say for Dhaka specifically the admix is very low and not detectable phenotypically.

[Jana]

friend son is just half Bangladeshi and he is over 9% mongoloid on Harappa...and yeah his father looks East Brachid.

S-Indian 24.77 Pct
Baloch 15.98 Pct
Caucasian 9.81 Pct
NE-Euro 24.9 Pct
SE-Asian 3.81 Pct
Siberian 1.05 Pct
NE-Asian 2.94 Pct
Papuan 0.57 Pct
American 0.99 Pct
Beringian 0.37 Pct
Mediterranean 12.82 Pct
SW-Asian 1.62 Pct
San -
E-African 0.21 Pct
Pygmy 0.14 Pct
W-African -

[Madara123]

in what world is the east brachid the most common phenotype amongst Bangladeshis? you are waffling big time. 121933 This is the Bangladesh national football team, how is it possible that not a single one of them is the East Brachid phenotype if its the most common one in the country. I could send pictures of my family or the community I grew up in and you wouldn't see a single East Brachid amongst them.

Some people on border regions like in Sylhet or Chittagong may have some admix but I will say for Dhaka specifically the admix is very low and not detectable phenotypically.

LOL. KULIN, you think your grandfather looks Afghan Pashtun while you claim Mamata doesn't look Bengali but Assamese. You are genuinely a clown and your words mean very little.

Oh and those guys are just giga dark. They will have thr East Brachid phenotype in proper neutral images lol Many of the Bangladeshi cricketers have the East Brachid phenotype. The Burmese blood is detectable even in Dhaka , even in Shakib.

You're delusional beyond belief. Keep pretending your grandpa looks Afgan while you post your ridiculous takes.

[Jambudvīpa]

LOL. KULIN, you think your grandfather looks Afghan Pashtun while you claim Mamata doesn't look Bengali but Assamese. You are genuinely a clown and your words mean very little.

Oh and those guys are just giga dark. They will have thr East Brachid phenotype in proper neutral images lol Many of the Bangladeshi cricketers have the East Brachid phenotype. The Burmese blood is detectable even in Dhaka , even in Shakib.

You're delusional beyond belief. Keep pretending your grandpa looks Afgan while you post your ridiculous takes.

who tf is kulin

For Bengali standards, they are a little darker than average but nothing crazy.

I'm not this guy whomever you're talking about. You wanna see a picture of me and family/friends?

[renisenb]

exactly

It's hard to tell apart NorthEast Indians from Bangladeshis. It's a gradient. If you imagine India is Europe, everyone in the northEastern half of India is like the Slavs of Europe (with Mongoloid admix). And everyone on the West and extreme South has no Mongoloid.
It's very easy for me to tell apart a Bangladeshi from an Indian who is not from the NorthEast.
Also note that India surrounds Bangladesh, so parts of India are even more East of Bangladesh, and those people are even more Mongoloid than Bangladeshis.

[Jambudvīpa]

It's hard to tell apart NorthEast Indians from Bangladeshis. It's a gradient. If you imagine India is Europe, everyone in the northEastern half of India is like the Slavs of Europe (with Mongoloid admix). And everyone on the West and extreme South has no Mongoloid.
It's very easy for me to tell apart a Bangladeshi from an Indian who is not from the NorthEast.
Also note that India surrounds Bangladesh, so parts of India are even more East of Bangladesh, and those people are even more Mongoloid than Bangladeshis.

I'm gonna send you a picture of myself and my community I grew up with and I want you to be honest, you won't find a single one who is Mongoloid influenced. You live in the UK, the vast majority of the Bengalis you met are Sylhetis which is why you think that we all look Northeastern lmfao

[Madara123]

who tf is kulin

For Bengali standards, they are a little darker than average but nothing crazy.

I'm not this guy whomever you're talking about. You wanna see a picture of me and family/friends?

The lighting is trash and their faces are not in a neutral position anf they're making weird faces.

You are obviously Kulin or Son Goku from Razib's forum. You said ur grandpa looks Afghan lmao and that Mamata doesn't look Bengali but Assamese.

Also, you used to be Shah Jehan or somrthing and you used to larp as part Iranian. Please stop trying to deny this, it's obviously you, you larper.

You're utterly delusional and clueless lmao

[Jambudvīpa]

The lighting is trash and their faces are not in a neutral position anf they're making weird faces.

You are obviously Kulin or Son Goku from Razib's forum. You said ur grandpa looks Afghan lmao and that Mamata doesn't look Bengali but Assamese.

Also, you used to be Shah Jehan or somrthing and you used to larp as part Iranian. Please stop trying to deny this, it's obviously you, you larper.

You're utterly delusional and clueless lmao

I'm not them. I don't even have an account on that guys platform. stop trying to accuse me of some bs. In fact i'm a person who actively downplays our proximity to Iranic people.

[Khinerai]

It's hard to tell apart NorthEast Indians from Bangladeshis. It's a gradient. If you imagine India is Europe, everyone in the northEastern half of India is like the Slavs of Europe (with Mongoloid admix). And everyone on the West and extreme South has no Mongoloid.
It's very easy for me to tell apart a Bangladeshi from an Indian who is not from the NorthEast.
Also note that India surrounds Bangladesh, so parts of India are even more East of Bangladesh, and those people are even more Mongoloid than Bangladeshis.

I have to believe none of you have an idea what a mongoloid phenotype is. Because no bangladeshi person looks remotely mongoloid, I actually posted a half korean-half bangladeshi person, and everybody clasified him as southern indian lol

[renisenb]

Unfortunately this narrative being pushed is all too common in anthro forums. Its being presented as fact, when in reality its far from the truth.

Hey remove your signature, it's offensive

[Madara123]

I have to believe none of you have an idea what a mongoloid phenotype is. Because no bangladeshi person looks remotely mongoloid, I actually posted a half korean-half bangladeshi person, and everybody clasified him as southern indian lol

That guy was full Bangladeshi not half Korean. Korean is his citizenship no idea who told you he's half Korean when he looks the way he does lol. Bangladeshis are East Brachid which is mainly South Asian so not mainly Mongoloid but mainly South Asian with some eastern influence. We can look like other south asian groups from elsewhere too. Also, don't lie. One Latino dude said he fits in Eastern India/Bangladedh only and perhaps even SE Asia while another Euro dude said Brazil Colombia and Venezuela. Only one person said he was pan South Asian or Pan Veddoid. Not everyone and he got varying responses.. Why do you keep flipflopping and lying lmao we can read your thread why do so many ppl like you always lie on these kinda sites

Also, you're contradicting yourself again. You said that the West Bengali female politician could pass amongst Burmese, who are SE Asian. So you clearly thought she looked Mongoloid. Unless you wanna retroactively take that statement back lol

Btw ppl told me i looked nepali himalayan and mixed with se asian here when I posted and I'm Bangla af. https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367529-Classify-me-please/page3

[Khinerai]

That guy was full Bangladeshi not half Korean. Korean is his citizenship no idea who told you he's half Korean when he looks the way he does lol. Bangladeshis are East Brachid which is mainly South Asian so not mainly Mongoloid but mainly South Asian with some eastern influence. We can look like other south asian groups from elsewhere too. Also, don't lie. One Latino dude said he fits in Eastern India/Bangladedh only and perhaps even SE Asia while another Euro dude said Brazil Colombia and Venezuela. Only one person said he was pan South Asian or Pan Veddoid. Not everyone and he got varying responses.. Why do you keep flipflopping and lying lmao we can read your thread why do so many ppl like you always lie on these kinda sites

Also, you're contradicting yourself again. You said that the West Bengali female politician could pass amongst Burmese, who are SE Asian. So you clearly thought she looked Mongoloid. Unless you wanna retroactively take that statement back lol

Btw ppl told me i looked nepali himalayan and mixed with se asian here when I posted and I'm Bangla af. https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367529-Classify-me-please/page3

Which female politician???

[Khinerai]

That guy was full Bangladeshi not half Korean. Korean is his citizenship no idea who told you he's half Korean when he looks the way he does lol. Bangladeshis are East Brachid which is mainly South Asian so not mainly Mongoloid but mainly South Asian with some eastern influence. We can look like other south asian groups from elsewhere too. Also, don't lie. One Latino dude said he fits in Eastern India/Bangladedh only and perhaps even SE Asia while another Euro dude said Brazil Colombia and Venezuela. Only one person said he was pan South Asian or Pan Veddoid. Not everyone and he got varying responses.. Why do you keep flipflopping and lying lmao we can read your thread why do so many ppl like you always lie on these kinda sites

Also, you're contradicting yourself again. You said that the West Bengali female politician could pass amongst Burmese, who are SE Asian. So you clearly thought she looked Mongoloid. Unless you wanna retroactively take that statement back lol

Btw ppl told me i looked nepali himalayan and mixed with se asian here when I posted and I'm Bangla af. https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367529-Classify-me-please/page3

I mean Burma has an ethnic.minority of south asians. Its not.hard to pass for Rohingya if ur bangladeshi

[Madara123]

I mean Burma has an ethnic.minority of south asians. Its not.hard to pass for Rohingya if ur bangladeshi

You said Burmese not Rohingya. And the her name is Mamata Banerjee

[Khinerai]

You said Burmese not Rohingya. And the her name is Mamata Banerjee

Lol you mean her. Lol i clearly said atypical.
And most bengali I see.dont look like her

[Khinerai]

That guy was full Bangladeshi not half Korean. Korean is his citizenship no idea who told you he's half Korean when he looks the way he does lol. Bangladeshis are East Brachid which is mainly South Asian so not mainly Mongoloid but mainly South Asian with some eastern influence. We can look like other south asian groups from elsewhere too. Also, don't lie. One Latino dude said he fits in Eastern India/Bangladedh only and perhaps even SE Asia while another Euro dude said Brazil Colombia and Venezuela. Only one person said he was pan South Asian or Pan Veddoid. Not everyone and he got varying responses.. Why do you keep flipflopping and lying lmao we can read your thread why do so many ppl like you always lie on these kinda sites

Also, you're contradicting yourself again. You said that the West Bengali female politician could pass amongst Burmese, who are SE Asian. So you clearly thought she looked Mongoloid. Unless you wanna retroactively take that statement back lol

Btw ppl told me i looked nepali himalayan and mixed with se asian here when I posted and I'm Bangla af. https://www.theapricity.com/forum/showthread.php?367529-Classify-me-please/page3

Lol he is half korean, still looks desi as f
https://www.reddit.com/r/korea/comments/wphe12/pfc_choi_jisan_%EC%B5%9C%EC%A7%80%EC%82%B0_is_a_ha lfkorean/

[Madara123]

Lol he is half korean, still looks desi as f
https://www.reddit.com/r/korea/comments/wphe12/pfc_choi_jisan_%EC%B5%9C%EC%A7%80%EC%82%B0_is_a_ha lfkorean/

He's not half Korean though. That's just his citizenship. He's fully Bangladeshi so he looks Bangladeshi. I'm full and on the darker side for Bangla folks of my age group in Canada and he's darker so ofc he's not half Korean lol

Rola for example is half Bangladeshi and half Japanese and it shows. This guy's full. Idk if you're slow or something but this guy's full Bangladeshi. No proof he's half. Rola's brother is also half and he looks it. Search them up and post em

In your thresd, one Latin huy said he wss only typicsl in Bangladesh/Assam and that he could even pass in SE Asia(I disagree) and another Romanian said he passes in Veneuzuela Colombia etc(I disagree as well). You lied and said that all of them said he was South Indian which was not true lol one person said he was Pan Veddoid pan south asian

[Khinerai]

He's not half Korean though. That's just his citizenship. He's fully Bangladeshi so he looks Bangladeshi. I'm full and on the darker side for Bangla folks of my age group in Canada and he's darker so ofc he's not half Korean lol

Rola for example is half Bangladeshi and half Japanese and it shows. This guy's full. Idk if you're slow or something but this guy's full Bangladeshi. No proof he's half. Rola's brother is also half and he looks it. Search them up and post em

In your thresd, one Latin huy said he wss only typicsl in Bangladesh/Assam and that he could even pass in SE Asia(I disagree) and another Romanian said he passes in Veneuzuela Colombia etc(I disagree as well). You lied and said that all of them said he was South Indian which was not true lol one person said he was Pan Veddoid pan south asian

https://i.ibb.co/T1xmtdd/Screenshot-20230705-222114-Samsung-Internet.jpg (https://ibb.co/bFMzXDD)
free image upload (https://imgbb.com/)

[Madara123]

https://i.ibb.co/T1xmtdd/Screenshot-20230705-222114-Samsung-Internet.jpg (https://ibb.co/bFMzXDD)
free image upload (https://imgbb.com/)

That guy ain't half Korean lmao a random reddit post isn't changing his genetics. This girl is half Bangladeshi half Japanese and she looks it and she has a brother who looks half Japanese as well. Rola is one of the most followed females in Japan apparently. That guy ain't half

121956
121957

121955
121954

[Khinerai]

That guy ain't half Korean lmao a random reddit post isn't changing his genetics. This girl is half Bangladeshi half Japanese and she looks it and she has a brother who looks half Japanese as well. Rola is one of the most followed females in Japan apparently. That guy ain't half

121956
121957

121955
121954

Rola is half bengali, 1/4 russian and 1/4 japanese
She looks ecactly what she is, a mixtureof 3 different ethnicities

Also bi-racial people could turn out looking mono-racial, like the half bengali guy

[Madara123]

Rola is half bengali, 1/4 russian and 1/4 japanese
She looks ecactly what she is, a mixtureof 3 different ethnicities

Also bi-racial people could turn out looking mono-racial, like the half bengali guy

Rola's mom was stated to have a Russian grandparent so she would be 75% Japanese herself.

Is there any proof the guy is half Korean besides a Reddit post? Can you post a picture with his Korean mom or Korean dad? Anybody can make a reddit post. Half Asian half Bangladeshi people look clearly different as seen above

[Khinerai]

Rola's mom was stated to have a Russian grandparent so she would be 75% Japanese herself.

Is there any proof the guy is half Korean besides a Reddit post? Can you post a picture with his Korean mom or Korean dad? Anybody can make a reddit post. Half Asian half Bangladeshi people look clearly different as seen above

Who between these 2 does the half bengali girl look closest to, one is half japanese like the bengali girl, the other is Southeast Asian

Miss Japan- Half Japanese Half Bengali
https://i.ibb.co/8gkm5h9/main-qimg-02ff1a4676014308ede61483af5d91ad-lq-jpeg.jpg (https://imgbb.com/)

Miss Japan- half Japanese half african-american
https://i.ibb.co/LpkHxXZ/555196ef5afbd3956f8b4567-jpeg.jpg (https://ibb.co/f01Lkzx)

Full Filipina influencer- Marsela Guia
https://i.ibb.co/wyZKZ2b/20200822-090623.jpg (https://ibb.co/MnyRyJj)

[Jambudvīpa]

He's not half Korean though. That's just his citizenship. He's fully Bangladeshi so he looks Bangladeshi. I'm full and on the darker side for Bangla folks of my age group in Canada and he's darker so ofc he's not half Korean lol

Rola for example is half Bangladeshi and half Japanese and it shows. This guy's full. Idk if you're slow or something but this guy's full Bangladeshi. No proof he's half. Rola's brother is also half and he looks it. Search them up and post em

In your thresd, one Latin huy said he wss only typicsl in Bangladesh/Assam and that he could even pass in SE Asia(I disagree) and another Romanian said he passes in Veneuzuela Colombia etc(I disagree as well). You lied and said that all of them said he was South Indian which was not true lol one person said he was Pan Veddoid pan south asian

you are not on the darker side for Bangladeshis, I don't know if yall are skin bleaching in Canada or what but these are crowd shots of Bengalis and notice all of them are medium to dark brown.

121961121962121963

[ugochaves]

Sri Lankans are more dravidian. The Filipinos are more Mongoloid. Bangladeshis and especially Pakistanis are more Caucasian.

[Mortimer]

I can not tell them apart they all look like Gypsies

[Madara123]

you are not on the darker side for Bangladeshis, I don't know if yall are skin bleaching in Canada or what but these are crowd shots of Bengalis and notice all of them are medium to dark brown.

121961121962121963

You're actually really, reslly slow, Son Goku/Kulin/Shah-Jehan. You not only know nothing about phenotypes nd genealogy but you also can't fkn read. I specified amongst people of my age from Canada that were either born or raised here. Ofc ppl straight up from BD are pretty dark due to sun low elevation constant sun exposure humidity no mountains just crazy weather all around etc. I literally clarified about folks of my age from Canada and ur slow ass is posting stuff straight up from BD. You're seriously seriously slow in the head. Learn to read

Don't reply to me with braindead shit. Keep larping about ur grandpa looking afghan while saying typical Bengalis dont look bengali lmao

[Jambudvīpa]

You're actually really, reslly slow, Son Goku/Kulin/Shah-Jehan. You not only know nothing about phenotypes nd genealogy but you also can't fkn read. I specified amongst people of my age from Canada that were either born or raised here. Ofc ppl straight up from BD are pretty dark due to sun low elevation constant sun exposure humidity no mountains just crazy weather all around etc. I literally clarified about folks of my age from Canada and ur slow ass is posting stuff straight up from BD. You're seriously seriously slow in the head. Learn to read

Don't reply to me with braindead shit. Keep larping about ur grandpa looking afghan while saying typical Bengalis dont look bengali lmao

you dumbass for the tenth time, I don't give a fuck about your moronic forum or the idiots on there. You and them deserve each other. With that said, no living in Canada or the US is not gonna make you lighter what type of stupidity is that. I sent you a picture of me and the other bengalis I grew up with and we are all Medium to Dark brown living in the US. Your knowledge of phenotypes is absolute piss. I'm not gonna comment on genes cause its not my interest.

Again, I would never play up my proximity to Iranic people.

[Madara123]

you dumbass for the tenth time, I don't give a fuck about your moronic forum or the idiots on there. You and them deserve each other. With that said, no living in Canada or the US is not gonna make you lighter what type of stupidity is that. I sent you a picture of me and the other bengalis I grew up with and we are all Medium to Dark brown living in the US. Your knowledge of phenotypes is absolute piss. I'm not gonna comment on genes cause its not my interest.

Again, I would never play up my proximity to Iranic people.

Lmao ofc it's you ShahJehan/Kulin/SonGoku. Your writing styles are the exact same.

And yes environment and geography is a factor you braindead ape lol especially if you're born and raised in Canada or something and not humid, flat, no elevation and ultra hot BD for all your life getting extremely suntanned and sunburned etc.

Fucking clueless lmao

[Jambudvīpa]

Lmao ofc it's you ShahJehan/Kulin/SonGoku. Your writing styles are the exact same.

And yes environment and geography is a factor you braindead ape lol especially if you're born and raised in Canada or something and not humid, flat, no elevation and ultra hot BD for all your life getting extremely suntanned and sunburned etc.

Fucking clueless lmao

You're a dumbass.

Okay if that's the case explain the picture I sent you with me and all the people I grew up with IN THE UNITED STATES and we are all medium to dark brown.

[Jambudvīpa]

friend son is just half Bangladeshi and he is over 9% mongoloid on Harappa...and yeah his father looks East Brachid.

S-Indian 24.77 Pct
Baloch 15.98 Pct
Caucasian 9.81 Pct
NE-Euro 24.9 Pct
SE-Asian 3.81 Pct
Siberian 1.05 Pct
NE-Asian 2.94 Pct
Papuan 0.57 Pct
American 0.99 Pct
Beringian 0.37 Pct
Mediterranean 12.82 Pct
SW-Asian 1.62 Pct
San -
E-African 0.21 Pct
Pygmy 0.14 Pct
W-African -

Half Bangladeshi Half Croatian? that must be an interesting story

[RN97]

There are a lot of Sri Lankan tamils, pakistanis, filipinos and some (usually north) Indians here. I´d say they look usually like this:
Filipino: https://i.imgur.com/TtBKds0.jpg
Tamil: https://i.imgur.com/pLLiXQ6.jpg
Pakistani: https://i.imgur.com/7xn6iU9.jpg

Tamils are significantly darker than the other two, and Filipinos don´t have the same facial features. Some pakistanis look north Indian and some look more like Afghans, Iranians or arabs.

[Pro.crasti.nation]

I'm Bangladeshi and no we don't have "signiciant Mongoloid admixture" no one in my family or even my community growing up was ever perceived as Mongoloid.

Back in primary school, I used to take the piss out of this mongoloid Bangladeshi kid. I had my reasons for never warming to him, but he really did look "blasian"(?), very dark brown and oriental features with puffy face.


I've got distant relatives who look look very Chinese. Their kids look like Korean dolls. big heads, mops of black hair and fair complexion.
My own family are all, well, not really mongoloid/oriental looking, though.

[Jambudvīpa]

Back in primary school, I used to take the piss out of this mongoloid Bangladeshi kid. I had my reasons for never warming to him, but he really did look "blasian"(?), very dark brown and oriental features with puffy face.


I've got distant relatives who look look very Chinese. Their kids look like Korean dolls. big heads, mops of black hair and fair complexion.
My own family are all, well, not really mongoloid/oriental looking, though.

and you're what ethnicity?

[Khinerai]

Does she look dravidian?
https://i.ibb.co/8cGzVfD/Screenshot-20230707-163802-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/bJYHnCg)

[Pro.crasti.nation]

and you're what ethnicity?

South Asian, but we've been in Bangladesh since the late 1800s.

[Pro.crasti.nation]

Does she look dravidian?
https://i.ibb.co/8cGzVfD/Screenshot-20230707-163802-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/bJYHnCg)

Not even if you painted her!

[Khinerai]

Not even if you painted her!

Why not, most of TA think me and her are dravidian

[Pro.crasti.nation]

Why not, most of TA think me and her are dravidian

Face is too flat, nose is too small, even for South Indians. And of course, eyes are entirely wrong.

[Khinerai]

Face is too flat, nose is too small, even for South Indians. And of course, eyes are entirely wrong.

Those are exactly dravidian features, causcoids have been appropriating dravidian identity far too long. Us real dravidians from the Philippines are reclaiming it.

[Pro.crasti.nation]

lol.
Well, have fun!

[Khinerai]

The true inheritor of dravidian heritage wearing the traditional clothes of her ancestors
https://i.ibb.co/41JtgXP/Screenshot-20230711-175839-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/nPRm8Yz)
https://i.ibb.co/TW5BCkZ/Screenshot-20230711-175841-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/HhQDJV0)
https://i.ibb.co/LCRFTkc/Screenshot-20230711-175844-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/64wMKnT)
https://i.ibb.co/jhWnrYT/Screenshot-20230711-175846-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/5TnbR36)
https://i.ibb.co/HpCw8yF/Screenshot-20230711-175847-Tik-Tok.jpg (https://ibb.co/Cs6CGy1)