are Adnani Arabs actually European ? solve the mystery with me

[mashail]

Basically, I started searching after listening to a Saudi tiktoker that been doing researches about the Arabian DNA and the origin of Arabian tribes he basically said only half of the Arabian tribes are the real pure Arabs that descend from qahtani Bedouin tribes while the other half they either came from the caucasus or Russia or even Jewish .

Adnani Arab tribes homeland is in North Saudi Arabia and East arabia (Kuwait\Qatar\ Bahrain) exclude (west-central Saudi and south saudi\Oman\UAE\yemen).
u will notice very high caucasian\ SouthEast European \ Jewish\Levantine ancestry.
some of them scores 40-50% European or 30-50% caucasian (Georgia\ Armenia \ the caucasus ).
Adnani north Saudis:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeMtsL3EHm8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uir9wDcrRCI
Adnani Kuwaiti:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/9QA-TpOe9rU
Typical qahtani(bedouin) results:
https://youtube.com/shorts/wfOKJmNVN8U?si=A8FLz2XXoi15J66d
https://youtube.com/shorts/T43njI2Wq-Q?si=irwe881-umtoGuNm
https://youtube.com/shorts/7OOUZldaDHg?si=uC7tiv2wpb6CNr7Q
yemeni
https://youtube.com/shorts/NXPiARatXrQ?si=BaPosbiIb08_Y0Fo

Here save ur time:
https://i.imgur.com/ah8YUS3.png
https://i.imgur.com/Zm4F883.png

[chinshen]

No, I don't think so. Not even North West Asians are Europeans either which are geographically closer proximity to Europe.

[mashail]

No, I don't think so. Not even North West Asians are Europeans either which are geographically closer proximity to Europe.

How come they score almost 50% European that's really insane or even very high caucasus region or even jewish ancestry !!
look at his results
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeMtsL3EHm8

[Beowulf]

Do you have some of their samples in G25? I wonder where would they plot

[mashail]

Do you have some of their samples in G25? I wonder where would they plot

IDK u can ask them in their YouTube comments section!! Adnani Arabs can't be real Arab/southwest asian their dna revealed it those are obviously arabized Arabians.

[mashail]

Bump

[sacha]

Myheritage ethnicity estimates are a complete meme my friend, this is what they gave me:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/592888102109052931/1181320239288434819/SPOILER_Screenshot_2023-12-04_at_2.44.32_PM.png?ex=6589dbb4&is=657766b4&hm=f627fa3eedb7782805053c277f2a92c9a46037147e4058c 493eb06fe7a4f2b27&
Many Arabs do have ~2% European mixture, you can imagine how it inflated my 0% European and deflated the rest to be magnified by that. They will be telling you you’re actually Jewish no matter what lol

[sacha]

Do you have some of their samples in G25? I wonder where would they plot
Yeah this is what I would like to know too, would be really the only way to even it all out here.

[mashail]

Myheritage ethnicity estimates are a complete meme my friend, this is what they gave me:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/592888102109052931/1181320239288434819/SPOILER_Screenshot_2023-12-04_at_2.44.32_PM.png?ex=6589dbb4&is=657766b4&hm=f627fa3eedb7782805053c277f2a92c9a46037147e4058c 493eb06fe7a4f2b27&
Many Arabs do have ~2% European mixture, you can imagine how it inflated my 0% European and deflated the rest to be magnified by that. They will be telling you you’re actually Jewish no matter what lol
FR! jewish ancestry is very exaggerated in myheratge !!! that's why I only trust FTDNA their results is very accurate especially when it comes to west asians.
but it is very odd bc most of Yemeni \ Emiratis \ west and south saudis results are almost 0% European and fully Middle East\North African
and their test results was also done by myheritage:

https://youtube.com/shorts/wfOKJmNVN...FLz2XXoi15J66d
https://youtube.com/shorts/T43njI2Wq...we881-umtoGuNm
https://youtube.com/shorts/7OOUZldaD...7tiv2wpb6CNr7Q
https://youtube.com/shorts/NXPiARatX...PosbiIb08_Y0Fo

[mashail]

Bump

[chinshen]

How come they score almost 50% European that's really insane or even very high caucasus region or even jewish ancestry !!
look at his results
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeMtsL3EHm8


Well, semiconductor chips used to read human DNA are fairly accurate, but how the results are interpreted depends on the algorithms used by different DNA companies.
So raw data can be interpreted according to the algorithm used by that particular DNA company which they compare to its database that they collected from information entered by their customers.
Long story short, "Garbage In = Garbage "Out" kind of mechanism.

[Avicenna]

Myheritage ethnicity estimates are a complete meme my friend, this is what they gave me:
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/592888102109052931/1181320239288434819/SPOILER_Screenshot_2023-12-04_at_2.44.32_PM.png?ex=6589dbb4&is=657766b4&hm=f627fa3eedb7782805053c277f2a92c9a46037147e4058c 493eb06fe7a4f2b27&
Many Arabs do have ~2% European mixture, you can imagine how it inflated my 0% European and deflated the rest to be magnified by that. They will be telling you you’re actually Jewish no matter what lol

Yeah these companies are BS, I don't know how many Afghans posting their results thinking they are 25% Scandinavian lol

[chinshen]

Well, semiconductor chips used to read human DNA are fairly accurate, but how the results are interpreted depends on the algorithms used by different DNA companies.
So raw data can be interpreted according to the algorithm used by that particular DNA company which they compare it to its database that they collected from information entered by their customers.
Long story short, "Garbage In / Garbage "Out" kind of mechanism.

Here are my results:

125186

[mashail]

Here are my results:

125186
upload ur dna raw data in ftdna it's more accurate.

[chinshen]

upload ur dna raw data in ftdna it's more accurate.

Thanks for the advice, I will do it later.

[Leto]

Yeah these companies are BS, I don't know how many Afghans posting their results thinking they are 25% Scandinavian lol
Raw data is what matters. In case you haven't done a test yet, you can order a FamilyFinder for $49 only (the sale ends on January 3).

[Avicenna]

Raw data is what matters. In case you haven't done a test yet, you can order a FamilyFinder for $49 only (the sale ends on January 3).

Yes I am aware but even then autosmal admixture tools like G25 only tell a part of a wider story.