Which One defines ur real origin autosomal dna or haplogroup?

[mashail]

Someone told me that only haplogroup will define ur Real origin.
So basically, if someone is genetically 100% NA but has J1 haplogroup than it means this person is an Arab that has some ancestors that intermarried with native Berbers. Meanwhile if he has E haplogroup than he’s native Berber no matter how high ME or European he has .
Is this information true ?

[TheMaestro]

Depends on where, IRL? People don't care what ancestors you had.


If you look like German and your last 3 generations are mostly Germans they wont ever doubt your ethnicity.

[Annihilus]

Culture is passed with the male line in my case so I would say yes. I identify strongly with my Y, less with autosomal.

[celticdragongod]

Someone told me that only haplogroup will define ur Real origin.
So basically, if someone is genetically 100% NA but has J1 haplogroup than it means this person is an Arab that has some ancestors that intermarried with native Berbers. Meanwhile if he has E haplogroup than he’s native Berber no matter how high ME or European he has .
Is this information true ?

The Y-chromosome only makes up about 2% of the human genome. Autosomal DNA makes up a much greater proportion of the genome.