PDA

View Full Version : Ancient Greeks



Wildland
04-28-2012, 12:23 PM
Pelasgians (pre-Minoan Greeks, or Helladic Greeks) belonged to an admixture of I, E-V13, T and G2a. E-V13 and T probably arrived in Greece from the Levant (and ultimately from Egypt, hence the small percentage of T) in the early Neolithic, 8,500 years ago. G2a came from the Caucasus approximately 6,000 years ago as herders of sheep and goats (and early miners ?).

Minoan Greeks migrated from Mesopotamia via Anatolia. They were mostly J2 people, but probably had some E too.

Mycenaean Greeks arrived around 3,600 years ago from the Ukrainian steppes. They were an Indo-European people belonging to R1a. So were the Macedonians and the Thracians (hence the higher density of R1a in northern Greece).

Greece was invaded by the Dorians around 1200 BCE. Nobody knows who they were or where they came from, but the high percentage of R1b in the regions where they settled (Peloponese, Crete) strongly suggest that they were R1b people. The events are linked to the Sea Peoples (see below), who were probably R1b people from the north-east of the Black Sea, or early Celts from central Europe.

Greek historians sometimes mention that the Dorians were the descendants of the Trojans who came back to avenge their ancestors. The Trojans were an Indo-European people related to the R1b Hittites (see below). This would also explain why there is about the same percentage of R1b and R1a in modern Greece. Each correspond to a different wave of Indo-European invader. They only make up 12% of the population (each) because the Neolithic farmers (especially E and J2) were already well-established and numerous by that time.

Ancient Anatolians

Southern Anatolia was colonised early by Neolithic farmers from the Near East (E + J2).

The Indo-European invasions brought the Hittites (1750 BCE), the Lydians and Lycians (1450 BCE) and the Proto-Armenians (1200 BCE). All were probably R1b, considering the high percentage of R1b in the regions they settled. R1b Indo-Europeans are thought to have originated on the north-eastern shores of the Black Sea, just north of the Caucasus. They could have invaded northern Anatolia by crossing the Caucasus, sailing across the sea, or going around via the steppes through the Bosphorus.

Later R1b were possibly (part of) the Sea Peoples that ravaged the ancient Near Eastern civilizations, from Greece to Egypt. Their advance military technology and sea-based culture make of them very good candidates.

http://www.eupedia.com/forum/showthread.php?25163-Y-DNA-haplogroups-of-ancient-civilizations&p=350462&viewfull=1#post350462

brunette
04-28-2012, 09:18 PM
Agreed with above. J2a and E3b is quite frequent there.

2Cool
04-28-2012, 09:22 PM
Are modern Greeks similar genetically to the ancient Greeks?

brunette
04-28-2012, 09:25 PM
No one is the same. They can only go by genetic markers etc. Not that haplogroups mean race.

Wildland
04-28-2012, 09:32 PM
Agreed with above. J2a and E3b is quite frequent there.

E1b1b: North African, Near Eastern, Balcanic
J2: Greco-Anatolian, Mesopotamian, Caucasian

brunette
04-28-2012, 09:33 PM
E3b is Neolithic not E1bb.

Wildland
04-28-2012, 09:50 PM
E1b1b is the new name in use for E3b.

Queen B
04-28-2012, 10:10 PM
Any reason why this is not started in Greek section???

brunette
04-28-2012, 10:21 PM
E1b1b is the new name in use for E3b.

Not E1bb that's a African Arabic marker.

Kanuni
04-28-2012, 10:27 PM
That's pure speculation from Eupedia.

Arthur Scharrenhans
04-28-2012, 10:32 PM
I find the terminology confusing; I think the name 'Greeks' is best reserved for the Indo-European people(s) who actually spoke Greek. Pelasgians (whatever they were) and Minoans surely settled (parts of) Greece, and contibuted some substrate to the later Greek popolation, but I wouldn't call them 'Greeks'.

Crn Volk
04-30-2012, 01:03 AM
Any reason why this is not started in Greek section???

Agree. This should be moved to the Greek forum.

Guapo
04-30-2012, 01:19 AM
Dorians were from the Danubian basin and moved south, Pelasgians, who came from Egypt, introduced that "th" sound to the Hellenic language.

Petros Houhoulis
05-02-2012, 12:10 AM
I find the terminology confusing; I think the name 'Greeks' is best reserved for the Indo-European people(s) who actually spoke Greek. Pelasgians (whatever they were) and Minoans surely settled (parts of) Greece, and contibuted some substrate to the later Greek popolation, but I wouldn't call them 'Greeks'.

In that sense, the Greeks were the R1b because the modern Greek language is Centum IndoEuropean. R1a is Satem, others are not IndoEuropean.

Nevertheless, judging from the predominance of the Asiatic/African E1b1b and J1/J2 not just in Greece but in the entire south Balkans, your logic would turn everyone here into Semites or Arabs or whatever. Since Greece has been the origin of the Western civilization and by ruling out the possibility that the migrants from Asian/African origin actually created the Greek language and spread it to the other IndoEuropeans, the resulting concept of a non-European non-IndoEuropean people being responsible for the beginning of European culture and civilization would be absurd.

This is why genetics cannot explain everything, and were certainly not the primary element in the creation of civilizations or cultures.