PDA

View Full Version : Globalization of Your Culture



Terek
05-04-2012, 03:02 PM
In the context of European cultural preservation in a world of such globalized cultures, I want to ask you of your opinion, of what you think when you witness your own culture appear or being "used" by other nations. For example, when others take your own traditions, food, music, ideas, forms of dance and clothing style. For a specific example, a British woman performs a Turkish dance. An American plays Finnish rock music in his car. A French company designs Greek-style clothes. A Russian opens an Irish bar and restaurant.

There are of course different arguements and opinions about this.

In favor arguement says that their culture is being preserved and is thriving when others are using it. That globalization as thought of as unavoidable does not only need to be Anglo-American globalization, that it is good for people around the world to get a taste of their culture too, that they are proud to see some tradition they love to touch the hearts of others, and to become popular.

The against arguement says that, others should not make a mockery of MY (or YOUR) culture, that even if for example the custom is learned correctly, it is still somehow false when taken by someone else... that European National Preservation means that everyone shall stick to just their OWN culture that they were born with and not take anyone else's, that your culture is what makes your nation unique because it does not belong to anyone else.

And of course, there may be arguements in between or that are neither one of them.

So I want to know, what do you think? Also, notice that I mean use of your culture in a positive sence, that others honestly try to imitate and present an aspect of your culture, not to intentionally make fun of it.

Foxy
05-11-2012, 12:20 AM
The second: if they like Italy they've to come here.

Damiăo de Góis
05-11-2012, 12:26 AM
I once accidentaly found a greek singer singing a Madredeus song on youtube. I felt flattered and surprised, i don't think this is a big deal

5L8KuGdOMlA

Comte Arnau
05-11-2012, 12:29 AM
I'm more than used to paella being regarded as a Spanish dish by foreigners. But well, at least the name of it clearly reveals it is not.:coffee:

Grumpy Cat
05-11-2012, 12:33 AM
I am mixed on it. I do like it when other people enjoy my traditions: the real thing.

I do not like it when it is commercialized (ie "Cajun" burgers at fast food joints). I find that annoying.

KidMulat
05-15-2012, 12:40 AM
I am mixed on it. I do like it when other people enjoy my traditions: the real thing.

I do not like it when it is commercialized (ie "Cajun" burgers at fast food joints). I find that annoying.

You know what's even more frustrating when your culture is continually mislabelled. I can not tell you how many times this happens

Person: What are you
me: I am Creole
Person: Your Cajun!? But your not white

When will Americans learn that one it is a rural/urban divide more than anything else and not clear cut boundaries.

This is what happens when outsiders define you; they capitalize on it and the people made invisible are just at a lose.

When people call New Orleans, Gumbo, and most of French history as "Cajun" it is just so American of them to say such a thing :coffee:

But I am happy some of my Francophone kin are finally making moeny from this though :thumbs up

StonyArabia
05-15-2012, 01:03 AM
I think it's positive and unites humanity together. Rather than hate it spreads love, understanding and mutal coperation, and most often it breaks down the borders that are shaped by prejudice. When Westerners go to the Syrian Desert regions, they often are amazed at both the relatively primtive lifestyle and the hospitability they endure. Thus in a way it's legitmate and not overtly commercialized or if it's not the genuine thing that's not positive, but if it's the real thing why not? It's good to share and explore other peoples cultures and traditions. Prejuidce is just sad and because of these interactions many people break the borders and form new freindships and the like often realizing they have a lot in common than differences.

Here Western tourists in the Syrian Desert regions most often they say the most positive stuff, you know due to the media potryal of the ME they realize it's all bunch of crap :

http://s18.postimage.org/ezup6o0eh/bedouin_makeup.jpg (http://postimage.org/)
jpg upload (http://postimage.org/)

http://s8.postimage.org/8qsx4rzx1/bedouin_makeup.jpg (http://postimage.org/)
picture hosting (http://postimage.org/)

http://s15.postimage.org/qzh6nfyuj/Bed1.jpg (http://postimage.org/)
image host (http://postimage.org/)

rashka
05-15-2012, 01:10 AM
When I see people dancing or singing Serbian folklore I feel happy and flattered that so many people are knowing our beautiful culture.

For example Serbian dance is included in this Chinese dance school

FCkK1m2fHhE


Chinese kids dancing a Serbian dance

zhImShqtpTI


Americans learning to dance the kolo.

9_sMJ5L_NYg


Great Celtic singer Talitha Mackenzie singing an old Kosovo Serbian song

RrfiMtnahsY

Lahtari
05-16-2012, 05:34 AM
An American plays Finnish rock music in his car.

Oh, I'm sure the poor musician who spent hours to make that song will be royally pissed off discovering he has fans in the US... :D :D

A more relevant comparison would be if the Yank would be imitating the music... which might depent on the music style as well. There's lots of Finnish bands imitating Metallica, for example, and no-one - Finn or American - finds it as a bad thing.

Lahtari
05-16-2012, 05:38 AM
I'm more than used to paella being regarded as a Spanish dish by foreigners. But well, at least the name of it clearly reveals it is not.:coffee:

Care to enlighten us ignorant foreigners?