The Controversial Origins Of Haplogroup J and R

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PrimarisOrion

It isn't nonsense. Haplogroup J originates from the Caucuses, it is generally darker there now since many fair skinned men left long ago, in Georgia's case. Part of Iran is in the Caucuses.

It is mocking insecure cultural marxist mentally ill types who like to spread lies.

---

I doubt that the people who went to Europe from the Caucasus 30 thousand years ago were light-skinned.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PrimarisOrion

The population history of J is too complicated but R1a is a more recent phenomenon. Haplogroup J is not semitic in origin, they spoke language isolates.

---

Haplogroup J created the Semitic languages, probably J2.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Miko

Haplogroup J created the Semitic languages, probably J2.

---

No that’s E1b1b1. IJ-M429 created the Vascasian languages (Aquitania-Euskara-Iberian: I1-I2), (Hurria-Urartu-Vainakh: J1-J2).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nittionia

My dad is J2b2 and he said "nittionia, it's caucasian and western asian"

---

That is a surprise for someone who is supposedly Germanic.

A reminder that R is still from Asia.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Abti

No that’s E1b1b1. IJ-M429 created the Vascasian languages (Aquitania-Euskara-Iberian: I1-I2), (Hurria-Urartu-Vainakh: J1-J2).

---

E1b1 created the berber languages.
Even Tigrayans and Amharas speak Semitic languages.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Miko

E1b1 created the berber languages.
Even Tigrayans and Amharas speak Semitic languages.

---

E1b1: Afroasiatic exception: E1b1a1-M2 - Niger-Kongo.

But E1b1a2-M329 is Afroasiatic.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nittionia

My dad is J2b2 and he said "nittionia, it's caucasian and western asian"

---

Illyrian

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Abti

That is a surprise for someone who is supposedly Germanic.

---

Yeah it's a bit odd, but not totally unheard of

My dad's 11th chromosome may hold the secret

https://i.imgur.com/KivrPzP.png