Top 10 Countries With DNA Matches (MyHeritage)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Touijer

Commercial DNA matches include X chromosome but not Y chromosome so results are not really relevant

---

They are as they are based on autosomal dna however people need to check surnames. With my results a lot of it is diaspora Irish but Irish are close to English populations also so there is some shared ancestry. In both the USA, Ireland and Britain I have real relatives due to actual ancestry from generations ago such as a brother of my grandfathers who went to UK and ancestors that went to US and these are verified. With Scandinavia they are all Scandinavians so possibly due to shared ancestry in Northwestern Europe. With the French result there are more Isles names cropping up but also some are French so similar shared ancestry. Some of the ones down further on my list are definitely mostly due to diaspora populations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Grace O'Malley

They are as they are based on autosomal dna however people need to check surnames. With my results a lot of it is diaspora Irish but Irish are close to English populations also so there is some shared ancestry. In both the USA, Ireland and Britain I have real relatives due to actual ancestry from generations ago such as a brother of my grandfathers who went to UK and ancestors that went to US and these are verified. With Scandinavia they are all Scandinavians so possibly due to shared ancestry in Northwestern Europe. With the French result there are more Isles names cropping up but also some are French so similar shared ancestry. Some of the ones down further on my list are definitely mostly due to diaspora populations.

---

My point is they include both X chromosome and Autosomal without accounting for the Y chromosome so it doesn’t give the full picture of your relatives

1- Germany ( 119 )
2- US ( 31 )
3- France ( 27 )
4- Turkey ( 25 )
5- UK ( 22 )
6- Netherlands ( 22 )
7- Switzerland ( 19 )
8- Austria ( 16 )
9- Sweden ( 11 )
10- Australia ( 8 )

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Touijer

My point is they include both X chromosome and Autosomal without accounting for the Y chromosome so it doesn’t give the full picture of your relatives

---

In population genetics your X and Y is not a factor in your relationship to other populations. For example cousins can be a completely different ydna and not sure if by X you mean mtdna? But the same holds true. Ydna for example is good at looking at distant connections and the same with mtdna. Anyway both y and mtdna are not a factor in these lists as they are entirely based on autosomal dna and the same with plots showing which populations cluster with each other. So in the end y and mtdna are irrelevant in this.

FTDNA is the place for ydna and mtdna if you want to look into that further.

My brother's ydna uploaded to yfull. He is M222 so very Irish centric.

He's the one here marked in yellow. On FTDNA they go into a lot of detail and I know that ydna descends from the Northern Ui Neill. It is further down M222 (i.e. the so called Niall of the Nine Hostages marker).

https://i.imgur.com/DO24TS3.png

https://www.yfull.com/tree/R-S588/

I've also had the full mtdna sequencing done and that is also uploaded to yfull.

Mine is marked in yellow. Mtdna is more varied but all my full matches are Irish also.

https://i.imgur.com/avKFBTL.png

https://www.yfull.com/mtree/J1c3f/

This is from ftdna. I've got 3 exact matches in Ireland. The rest of the list is 1 step matches. As you can see mtdna is spread around more populations but relationships are more distant.

https://i.imgur.com/ZI7YxKV.png

So while all is interesting to find out your closest relationships and relatives you need to use autosomal dna.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Grace O'Malley

In population genetics your X and Y is not a factor in your relationship to other populations. For example cousins can be a completely different ydna and not sure if by X you mean mtdna? But the same holds true. Ydna for example is good at looking at distant connections and the same with mtdna. Anyway both y and mtdna are not a factor in these lists as they are entirely based on autosomal dna and the same with plots showing which populations cluster with each other. So in the end y and mtdna are irrelevant in this.]

So while all is interesting to find out your closest relationships and relatives you need to use autosomal dna.

---

False. Y chromosome is 2% of your entire genome and you share that with others under the same haplogroup. 23&me uses mtdna for dna relatives so it is used for relationship to other populations and as a factor in these lists . The only explanation as to why they don’t use Y chromosome but use the X is because everyone would get millions of matches so they don’t put it. The 2 screenshots will explain it.

Attachment 125106
Attachment 125107

https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/...-Relationships

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Grace O'Malley

In population genetics your X and Y is not a factor in your relationship to other populations. For example cousins can be a completely different ydna and not sure if by X you mean mtdna? But the same holds true. Ydna for example is good at looking at distant connections and the same with mtdna. Anyway both y and mtdna are not a factor in these lists as they are entirely based on autosomal dna and the same with plots showing which populations cluster with each other. So in the end y and mtdna are irrelevant in this.

FTDNA is the place for ydna and mtdna if you want to look into that further.

My brother's ydna uploaded to yfull. He is M222 so very Irish centric.

He's the one here marked in yellow. On FTDNA they go into a lot of detail and I know that ydna descends from the Northern Ui Neill. It is further down M222 (i.e. the so called Niall of the Nine Hostages marker).

https://i.imgur.com/DO24TS3.png

https://www.yfull.com/tree/R-S588/

I've also had the full mtdna sequencing done and that is also uploaded to yfull.

Mine is marked in yellow. Mtdna is more varied but all my full matches are Irish also.

https://i.imgur.com/avKFBTL.png

https://www.yfull.com/mtree/J1c3f/

This is from ftdna. I've got 3 exact matches in Ireland. The rest of the list is 1 step matches. As you can see mtdna is spread around more populations but relationships are more distant.

https://i.imgur.com/ZI7YxKV.png

So while all is interesting to find out your closest relationships and relatives you need to use autosomal dna.

---

X-DNA and mtDNA are different:
https://www.ancestry.com/c/dna-learning-hub/x-dna

The X-chromosome is included in autosomal DNA tests, but not all let you see matches from shared X-DNA specifically.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Touijer

False. Y chromosome is 2% of your entire genome and you share that with others under the same haplogroup. 23&me uses mtdna for dna relatives so it is used for relationship to other populations and as a factor in these lists . The only explanation as to why they don’t use Y chromosome but use the X is because everyone would get millions of matches so they don’t put it. The 2 screenshots will explain it.

Attachment 125106
Attachment 125107

https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/...-Relationships

---

I give up. If you believe that then possibly someone else can explain better than I can.

MH vs 23andme

https://i.postimg.cc/vT1JtM11/Untitled.png

https://i.postimg.cc/B6bkJsBh/2.png

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Milkaner

X-DNA and mtDNA are different:
https://www.ancestry.com/c/dna-learning-hub/x-dna

The X-chromosome is included in autosomal DNA tests, but not all let you see matches from shared X-DNA specifically.

---

I'm aware X chromosome is different than mtdna. It has more chromosomes than ydna for example but it isn't used to trace ancestry so I'm not sure what the relevance is here. Just looking at myself and my daughter she shares 49.8% dna with me and I share 50% with my mother (this is on MyHeritage), my brother shares 37.7% dna with me and a 2nd cousin shares 6.4% and a relative whose grandfather was my grandfather's brother shares 2.4% dna with myself. This is all from MyHeritage.

Number of matches
USA
4,589
United Kingdom
1,134
Finland
522
Australia
288
Germany
288
Sweden
223
Canada
206
Netherlands
183
New Zealand
154
France
128
Norway
111
Denmark
82
Hungary
81
Ireland
65
Slovakia
59
Poland
49
Switzerland
48
Czechia
39
Austria
35
Belgium
33
Spain
26
Ukraine
13
Italy
12
South Africa
9
Lithuania
8
Romania
7
Estonia
7
Greece
7
Mexico
6
Slovenia
6
Latvia
5
Singapore
4
Russia
4
Türkiye
3
Japan
3
Portugal
3
Brazil
3
Luxembourg
2
Peru
2
Bulgaria
2
Iceland
2
United Arab Emirates
2
Croatia
2
Belarus
2
Thailand
2
Chile
1
Falkland Islands
1
Bahrain
1
Colombia
1
Guadeloupe
1
Kazakhstan
1
Philippines
1
Moldova
1
Liechtenstein
1
Ethiopia
1
Ghana
1
Israel
1
Serbia
1
Uruguay
1





The man from Ethiopia is White (saw photo) with an Italian name.

The man from Ghana is White (saw photo) with a Scottish/English name.

The three from Japan have no photos but all have British names.

My Top 15 (Post Your Top 15 Countries)

1) USA 2,960 DNA Matches
2) UK 1,232 DNA Matches
3) Australia 473 DNA Matches
4) Germany 281 DNA Matches
5) Canada 237 DNA Matches
6) Finland 153 DNA Matches
7) Sweden 141 DNA Matches
8) Ireland 134 DNA Matches
9) New Zealand 134 DNA Matches
10) Netherlands 112 DNA Matches
11) Hungary 110 DNA Matches
12) France 101 DNA Matches
13) Norway 80 DNA Matches
14) Denmark 69 DNA Matches
15) Poland 57 DNA Matches

I notice a lot of Hungarian names and other central east european names in my USA and West Euro country matches.
Whats a bit odd and suprising is the 153 matches in Finland although several names among them seem central east euro
otherwise suprising see lot of Finnish matches.

MyHeritage

USA 1.144
Deutschland 451
Österreich 318
Vereinigtes Königreich 225
Schweden 130
Frankreich 113
Niederlande 102
Ungarn 90
Norwegen 89
Finnland 86
Schweiz 80

vs 23andme:

United States (488)
Austria (61)
Germany (52)
Poland (50)
United Kingdom (39)
Russia (30)
Italy (29)
Canada (27)
Slovenia (25)
Croatia (21)
Ukraine (20)
Hungary (19)
Czech Republic (15)
Belarus (12)
Slovakia (11)
Republic of Ireland (8)
Sweden (7)
Finland (7)
Bosnia and Herzegovina (6)
Greece (6)

Country Number of matches
USA
689
Germany
565
Sweden
309
France
267
Switzerland
239
United Kingdom
218
Austria
177
Norway
153
Romania
149
Hungary
121

us
239
greece
98
germany
72
sweden
43
australia
42
uk
33
france
25

the rest are very low number, insignificant.

Updated Top 15
USA 517
Germany 200
United Kingdom 113
Greece 81
Sweden 70
France 68
Australia 58
Canada 51
Hungary 43
Netherlands 39
Austria 37
Poland 35
Switzerland 34
Norway 34
Denmark 32

Father
USA 329
Germany 198
United Kingdom 87
Switzerland 52
France 48
Greece 40
Netherlands 34
Romania 34
Sweden 33
Hungary 30
Austria 29
Bulgaria 27
Norway 25
Canada 21
Australia 20

https://i.imgur.com/2Jbaiyo.png

My23andMe


United States (527)

United Kingdom (125)

Canada (67)

Republic of Ireland (39)

Poland (33)

Hungary (21)

Germany (21)

Slovakia (16)

Australia (14)

Italy (14)

Czech Republic (12)

Austria (7)

Sweden (6)

Norway (5)

Netherlands (5)

Ukraine (5)

France (5)

Lithuania (4)

Denmark (4)

Spain (4)

I have several Hungarian matches in USA and UK.