Dodecad k12b West, Central & South Asian results Vol. 3

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

Why so? Then you may as well just leave and stop commenting here so actively.

---

People who are interested could see that, but not for all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bender1999

People who are interested could see that, but not for all.

---

Gedmatch results are hardly something private, in the end they are just numbers

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bender1999

People who are interested could see that, but not for all.

---

Dude, you won't be a diamond in the sand, there are hundreds of Turks on Gedmatch if not thousands. Whether it's 10% East Eurasian or 15% doesn't matter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Halgurd

According to Bender this is the splendid and academic work of a Turk historian 'Əli Rza Özdəmir'. According to this i'm a Yoruk.

https://axar.az/news/toplum/95261.html

Əşirət (Tayfa) Adı: Balik, Balikan

Yaşadığı Yerlər: Ərbil, Revanduz, Tunceli (Mazgirt)

Boyu: Yörük

I must applaud their research though. Honestly, they've literally listed every Kurdish tribe and assigned a Turkic subgroup origin to them.

I really wish it is a parody, but it is not.

---

That’s pretty wild. The title to his page “ Türk kökənli kürd tayfaları – Araşdırma” translates “Kurdish tribes of Turkish origin - Research”. So according to him every kurd is a turk, Even
Kurmanji kurds “ Gürmanç / Kurmanç” are Afshars . There’s even some Kurd tribes i’ve never heard of such as “ Tatar tayfası”. Would have been nice for him to post some references.
I wonder how he would explain the big diversity of kurdish dialects or kurdish being closer to Parthian than farsi to parthian lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zoro

That’s pretty wild. The title to his page “ Türk kökənli kürd tayfaları – Araşdırma” translates “Kurdish tribes of Turkish origin - Research”. So according to him every kurd is a turk, Even
Kurmanji kurds “ Gürmanç / Kurmanç” are Afshars . There’s even some Kurd tribes i’ve never heard of such as “ Tatar tayfası”. Would have been nice for him to post some references.
I wonder how he would explain the big diversity of kurdish dialects or kurdish being closer to Parthian than farsi to parthian lol

---

Didn't you know? Parthians were Turks. Medes were Turks too. Original Mesopotamians were Turks. Muhammad SAW was a Turk. God speaks Turkish.

Also Sumerians are Turks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zoro

That’s pretty wild. The title to his page “ Türk kökənli kürd tayfaları – Araşdırma” translates “Kurdish tribes of Turkish origin - Research”. So according to him every kurd is a turk, Even
Kurmanji kurds “ Gürmanç / Kurmanç” are Afshars . There’s even some Kurd tribes i’ve never heard of such as “ Tatar tayfası”. Would have been nice for him to post some references.
I wonder how he would explain the big diversity of kurdish dialects or kurdish being closer to Parthian than farsi to parthian lol

---

Well, the map is in your signature is made in 1998 by someone who obviously never visited those regions. They always show Adana/Osmaniye as "Lak Kurds" even though the only local tribes there are Varsak and Afshars, because a British report in the 19th century claimed that there were "Laks", where are those Laks now? The map is bullshit. Osmaniye is full of nationalist Turks, where MHP wins.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Halgurd

Also Sumerians are Turks

---

You fight those people from every ethnicity - meanwhile Kurdish history pages claim Ancient Greeks
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EdzLUmmW...jpg&name=small

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fedora

Well, the map is in your signature is made in 1998 by someone who obviously never visited those regions. They always show Adana/Osmaniye as "Lak Kurds" even though the only local tribes there are Varsak and Afshars, because a British report in the 19th century claimed that there were "Laks", where are those Laks now? The map is bullshit. Osmaniye is full of nationalist Turks, where MHP wins.

---

Adana has some Lak Kurds. Turkish user Ashina from anthroscape claimed partly Adanali Lak ancestry.

Look both Kurds and Turks have no shame, they claim everything. Now move on and keep posting Gedmatch results.