Ukrainian academic regional k13 results - more than 100

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

Dodecad works fine for a lot of Eurasians. I dislike the G25 bullshit that is being spammed by gixajo and some other users. He is a fucking nobody scientifically and creates bullshit models every single day.

---

There is an inflation of Global25 models with idiotic sources from different periods and no relevance for sure but i am annoyed by people using Gedmatch calcs to claim PIEs had Gedrosian/came from Iran, Sintastha were North Atlanic-like with zero affinity to East Europeans and use the components based on modern pops to model ancient people who are their ancestors (like making a calc based on the sons of a person to model the father). For the Asians i am interested it is not working always because it lumps different kind of East Asian (WSHG, Mongol_N, Han/Mongol/Proto-like) and Middle Eastern (CHG, Iran_N, Iran_Chalc, Natufian) together. Harappa is here still the most accuate but even it fails to differentiate these kind of ancestries accurately (Global25 is also not perfect here but the best so far for non-Europeans)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ion Basescul

G25 will never catch up, as long as it 1) is not free and 2) available for people to get it straight from a website like on GEDmatch. Otherwise, it is extremely hard if not impossible to build proper references. Relying only on academic samples is not enough to get a comprehensive picture.

---

Exactly. There will be nothing like the massive Gedmatch database for G25 anytime soon. It's too complicated for most "normies". In fact many people even find Gedmatch complicated. I once talked to a Russian-Ukrainian woman, a match of my brother-in-law's and she was like "I went to Gedmatch and understood nothing". To this day she is not there :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arhat

There is an inflation of Global25 models with idiotic sources from different periods and no relevance for sure but i am annoyed by people using Gedmatch calcs to claim PIEs had Gedrosian/came from Iran, Sintastha were North Atlanic-like with zero affinity to East Europeans and use the components based on modern pops to model ancient people who are their ancestors (like making a calc based on the sons of a person to model the father). For the Asians i am interested it is not working always because it lumps different kind of East Asian (WSHG, Mongol_N, Han/Mongol/Proto-like) and Middle Eastern (CHG, Iran_N, Iran_Chalc, Natufian) together. Harappa is here still the most accuate but even it fails to differentiate these kind of ancestries accurately (Global25 is also not perfect here but the best so far for non-Europeans)

---

Much of that is too high-brow and too involved. Here we can just say "Mongoloid" for East Eurasian. Everyone knows what it is :)

Minsk K13:

Code:

---

Minsk1,28.20,50.20,9.76,1.71,4.24,0.85,1.48,1.54,0.79,0,0.19,1.04,0
Minsk2,32.58,49.11,6.34,4.42,2.96,0.21,1.53,0,0.73,1.14,0.59,0,0.38
Minsk3,27.31,49.18,7.09,2.72,8.96,1.24,0.87,0,2.24,0.20,0.13,0,0.06
Minsk4,25.74,50.33,7.73,4.80,6.55,1.43,0,0.95,1.55,0,0.85,0.07,0
Minsk5,24.68,52.00,9.76,4.38,2.43,1.33,1.48,0,1.65,0.92,0.36,0.98,0
Minsk6,26.82,52.27,7.98,2.69,5.23,0.52,3.62,0,0.15,0,0,0.48,0.24
Minsk7,26.76,50.66,8.27,1.73,7.91,0.47,1.11,0,1.06,1.53,0.48,0,0
Minsk8,28.60,48.75,6.61,5.18,3.51,2.29,2.95,0,0.53,0.71,0.72,0,0.14
Minsk9,27.19,47.57,9.51,5.63,5.10,0,1.32,0,3.27,0,0,0,0.41
Minsk10,22.46,39.39,12.87,6.44,14.31,0.44,0.94,1.23,1.15,0.32,0,0,0.45
Minsk11,27.63,47.74,8.72,6.31,4.17,0.83,2.59,0.01,0,1.99,0,0.02,0
Minsk12,28.80,51.64,7.14,6.17,3.35,0,0.38,1.35,0,0,0.52,0.65,0
Minsk13,28.88,46.86,9.88,4.24,6.49,0,0.61,0.47,0.87,0.64,0,0.68,0.39
Minsk14,27.45,48.00,11.43,5.28,5.00,0.22,1.07,0,1.29,0.26,0,0,0
Minsk15,25.26,53.34,10.79,2.79,2.38,0.38,3.29,0,1.11,0.55,0,0,0.11
Minsk16,29.16,46.31,8.25,8.20,4.35,0,0,0,1.48,0.89,0.89,0,0.45
Minsk17,26.78,51.98,8.91,5.85,2.01,0,1.13,0.22,0.37,0.83,1.80,0,0.13
Minsk18,26.38,52.87,8.11,3.55,4.22,0,2.72,0,0.60,1.00,0,0.54,0
Minsk19,21.86,51.08,10.92,5.66,6.73,0,0.06,0,1.27,0.64,0.73,1.06,0
Minsk20,26.85,49.41,7.95,7.80,3.72,0.51,1.77,0.54,0.69,0.77,0,0,0
Minsk21,26.69,49.09,11.99,5.73,2.00,0.23,0.43,0,0.91,1.43,1.50,0,0
Minsk22,26.99,51.75,9.46,2.62,2.98,0.42,1.59,0.59,0.99,2.08,0,0,0.53
Minsk23,27.76,47.96,7.07,5.25,6.78,0.14,0.12,0,3.01,0,0.91,0,1.00
Minsk24,23.34,33.80,12.58,10.28,12.39,1.14,2.35,0.43,2.46,0.68,0,0.55,0
Minsk25,31.26,48.40,7.80,6.40,2.05,0.42,1.02,0,0,1.74,0.86,0,0.04
Minsk26,26.20,48.44,12.22,2.35,6.97,0.16,0.13,0.46,1.21,0.79,0.10,0,0.95
Minsk27,24.60,48.12,12.59,3.69,4.36,1.94,1.44,0.09,2.42,0.73,0,0,0
Minsk28,26.56,45.91,12.30,5.28,4.75,0.29,0.12,0,3.35,0,0.49,0,0.95

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ion Basescul

G25 will never catch up, as long as it 1) is not free and 2) available for people to get it straight from a website like on GEDmatch. Otherwise, it is extremely hard if not impossible to build proper references. Relying only on academic samples is not enough to get a comprehensive picture.

---

Maybe we can start on TA free database of G25 coords? At least 100 or 200 users here had g25.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Peterski

Minsk K13:

---

Thanks!
Removed two samples marked by you previously as outliers

Code:

---

Belarusian_Minsk,27.19,49.58,9.18,4.63,4.58,0.53,1.26,0.24,1.21,0.72,0.43,0.21,0.22

---

Distance to: Belarusian_Minsk
1.47851277 Estonian_Polish
2.44804003 Russian_Smolensk
3.04642413 Belorussian
4.07349972 Russian_Southwest
4.70054252 Russian_average
5.24371052 Ukrainian_Belgorod
5.63055947 Polish
5.99219492 Lithuanian
6.36007075 Russian_Kostroma
6.98833313 Ukrainian

It's fairly similar to the old average and also not far away from my father's results.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

Removed two samples marked by you previously as outliers

---

They might not be numbered in exactly the same order as in K15 thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Peterski

They might not be numbered in exactly the same order as in K15 thread.

---

They looked like outliers too.
Now K12b is next.

Minsk in K12b:

Code:

---

Minsk1,3.93,0,0,1.38,23.61,60.45,1.29,0.50,1.17,0,7.67,0
Minsk2,3.27,1.17,0,0.02,21.29,62.70,1.73,0,1.31,0,8.50,0
Minsk3,4.50,1.97,0.27,0,20.95,59.69,0,0,1.97,0,10.57,0.09
Minsk4,3.74,2.09,0,0.55,20.61,59.74,0,0,1.49,0.26,11.52,0
Minsk5,4.73,0.83,0,0,21.78,58.14,1.24,0.06,2.99,0.10,10.13,0
Minsk6,2.87,0,0,0,20.68,61.37,2.69,0.02,2.51,0,9.87,0
Minsk7,1.58,2.27,0,0,19.96,61.64,1.57,0,1.27,0,11.71,0
Minsk8,3.56,0.36,0,1.01,19.56,59.35,2.32,0,1.43,0,12.43,0
Minsk9,3.85,2.66,0.33,0,22.45,58.39,1.00,0,0,0,11.33,0
Minsk10,1.82,0,1.13,1.53,23.03,48.22,1.80,0,4.34,0.25,17.89,0
Minsk11,2.44,0.03,0,0,22.87,59.50,2.70,0,1.96,0.26,10.25,0
Minsk12,3.40,1.09,0.88,0.15,20.43,63.61,0,0,0,0,10.43,0
Minsk13,3.89,0,1.66,0,23.99,58.70,0,0,1.56,1.21,8.99,0.01
Minsk14,6.71,0.96,0,0,24.07,59.03,0,0,0.40,0,8.83,0
Minsk15,2.97,0.99,0.25,0,25.34,61.07,2.08,0,1.22,0,6.10,0
Minsk16,5.20,1.80,0.38,0,21.78,60.12,0,0,0,0,10.72,0
Minsk17,1.45,0,0.92,0.25,20.40,61.25,2.94,0.05,0,0,12.73,0
Minsk18,4.63,0.44,0.57,0,21.94,61.58,2.07,0,0.45,0,8.33,0
Minsk19,2.39,1.51,0.28,0,22.92,56.02,0.83,0.15,1.15,0,14.64,0.12
Minsk20,5.22,0.82,0,0,21.35,59.66,1.67,0,0,0.42,10.86,0
Minsk21,5.12,0.93,0,0,24.12,58.05,0,0,0,0.58,11.19,0
Minsk22,4.08,2.01,0,0.45,19.41,62.58,1.17,0,0.28,0,10.02,0
Minsk23,3.92,2.41,0.47,0,21.30,56.51,0.92,0,0.75,0,13.28,0.44
Minsk24,2.76,2.56,0,0,21.05,44.97,2.37,0.27,4.63,1.52,19.87,0
Minsk25,5.05,1.35,0,0,22.73,61.11,0.03,0,0,0.11,9.63,0
Minsk26,1.92,1.43,1.65,0,22.67,58.62,0,0,0.53,0,13.17,0
Minsk27,0.75,2.08,0.87,0.73,23.32,56.85,1.34,0,1.67,0,12.39,0
Minsk28,3.97,2.72,0,0,21.27,56.12,0.14,0,2.29,0,12.91,0.58

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucas

Maybe we can start on TA free database of G25 coords? At least 100 or 200 users here had g25.

---

If I remember correctly someone already started that project some months ago.