South Slavic & neighbours gedmatch results - vol.2

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

How would those mixed Bosnians identify? Would they typically identify with a religious community? After all, it's all just a bunch of "religious tribes" (Bosniensis).

---

As Yugoslavs or Bosnians. Only Bosniaks are a religious tribe. Croat and Serb identity preceeds Christianity even if it was formed along religious lines in 19th century.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varda

It will be known these days.

Person is South Slav for sure, and this is thread about S. Slavic genetic.

---

Yes, you're right. But we should know to include them in statistics.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stearsolina

As Yugoslavs or Bosnians. Only Bosniaks are a religious tribe. Croat and Serb identity preceeds Christianity even if it was formed along religious lines in 19th century.

---

No,I mean does de-Islamization of Bosniaks happen in such cases?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

No,I mean does de-Islamization of Bosniaks happen in such cases?

---

I think those mixes are mostly agnostic/atheist. Because such mixing was common only during communist Yugoslavia, not before or after it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stearsolina

I think those mixes are mostly agnostic/atheist. Because such mixing was common only during communist Yugoslavia, not before or after it.

---

Okay. I was hoping there is at least some number of Bosniaks leaving Islam for Christianity (joining the Serbian or Croatian communities). But it'd be extremely difficult - their entire ethnic identity would become meaningless once Islam is removed from the equation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

How would those mixed Bosnians identify? Would they typically identify with a religious community? After all, it's all just a bunch of "religious tribes" (Bosniensis).

---

Some Muslims (mostly intelectuals) in the past had Serbian identity as Muslims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serb_Muslims

^^
Look on notable people on the link.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leto

Okay. I was hoping there is at least some number of Bosniaks leaving Islam for Christianity (joining the Serbian or Croatian communities). But it'd be extremely difficult - their entire ethnic identity would become meaningless once Islam is removed from the equation.

---

Some did, like Emir Kusturica who converted to Orthodoxy. Because he is of Serb origin.

User Max Luburić who was Bosniak of Croatian origin converted to Catholicism. Now he's a Croat.
Hrvoje had his results, but can't send them to me because he's banned and they are in his inbox.

But I know what they are like.

BTW, we have muslim Croats (but much less than before Yugoslavia) today like politican Zlako Hasanbegović who is a Croat but never converted.
One guy who studied with me was the same story.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stearsolina

Some did, like Emir Kusturica who converted to Orthodoxy. Because he is of Serb origin.

User Max Luburić who is Bosniak of Croatian origin converted to Catholicism.
Hrvoje had his results, but can't send them to me because he's banned and they are in his inbox.

But I know what they are like.

BTW, we have muslim Croats (but much less than before Yugoslavia) today like politican Zlako Hasanbegović who is a Croat but never converted.
One guy who studied with me was the same story.

---

Neither of them is Croat. There are no Bosniaks today who are purely either of Serbian or Croatian origin.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Insuperable

Neither of them is Croat. There are no Bosniaks today who are purely either of Serbian or Croatian origin.

---

Ofcourse there are. And they are genetically significantly more Croat than you are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stearsolina

Ofcourse there are. And they are genetically significantly more Croat than you are.

---

There isn't. Hasanbegovic is Bosniak and not Croat. Deal with it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Insuperable

There isn't. Hasanbegovic is Bosniak and not Croat. Deal with it.

---

No, he's a Croat and you are a Vlach. I value blood above religion and so do many modern right wingers.