Your results are in range but on high end of Slavic input for Serbs. Just like Croats with 35% Baltic are on high end of Slavic and certanly not average.
Printable View
Your results are in range but on high end of Slavic input for Serbs. Just like Croats with 35% Baltic are on high end of Slavic and certanly not average.
27 is absolutely not Montenegrin level as I have fairly many verified southern Croats with that amount of Baltic.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pribislav
Average Montenegrins are 24-25
Lets delete all regional averages and to stay this
Croat,28.17,33.10,14.63,7.80,11.67,1.42,0.60,0.20, 0.48,0.59,0.45,0.09,0.12
Serb,25.07,29.92,17.03,8.75,15.35,1.59,0.48,0.29,0 .67,0.43,0.30,0.08,0.04
I am ok with that.
But to add Herzegovina or Tropolje Croat average, and not to add Krajina Serb average is ridiculous!
Btw Istrian average of Baltic is 30 based on what I have so far.
I include all Serb regions in my runs made by VbenthkioQuote:
Originally Posted by Dušan
Yes they should be added, but obviously his which has much larger sample size of confirmed samples. Or you send him those he lack so he can add them if they are verified.
Montenegrins are more like 26 on average.Quote:
Originally Posted by Est.1992
Again I say, it's imposible to average Baltic is only 27 for Krajina Serbs on 25 samples between Dušan's 28 and vbnetkhio's 53 to fell for 2.1%. I made little mistake Dušan's sample was 28 and vbnetkhio claim 53.
27 Baltic is average for Shopluk Serbs.
Just stop, nordicist who add people with completely unchecked background and almost never posted south shifted Serb. You don't know what is average for Shopluk based on 1 or 2 samples. Lot of western Serbs have 27% Baltic, a lot, especially since many Croats do to and we are more northern shifted overall.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pribislav
You have no arguments, you just don't like his average.
Wrong, Lika Serbs have high Baltic. According to vbnetkhio 31.45. Acoording to him Kordun/Banija Serbs are 30.92, and Dalmatian Serbs 29.53. Tell me how is possible that 31.45+30.92+29.53 / 3 = 29.66!? Lika+Kordun/Banija are 2/3 and Dalmatian ones are 1/3 or less in total sample.Quote:
Originally Posted by Est.1992
They have lot of variations and many certanly have low while others have high, unless you think Serbs are more northern than people here.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pribislav
I don't count made up kits from HungryLion.
so it isn't representative for what we are researching here.Quote:
Originally Posted by Est.1992
we are aiming for pre ww2 (mostly) rural populations here, right?
those academic averages should be included in the sheet just for fun, or to fill gaps where we don't have enough samples yet.
yes. there's probably some Macedonian and Vlach (Timok Romanian) admixture too. i have real gedmatch results of people like that, but i didn't include them in any average.Quote:
Originally Posted by Est.1992
also there's one Austrian like sample, it could be a Danube Swabian or Hungarian.