https://youtu.be/BZd_sAVKqPw
Printable View
Throat singing is distributed mainly just in Siberia, Mogolia and Tibet.
Possibly the Siberian Turks borrowed it from the Mongols.
And the Mongols borrowed it from the Tibetans.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overtone_singing
At one time, I became interested in where the custom of making skull cups came from among the Scythians and Turks.
This was clearly not a local tradition.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skull_cup
The closest analogue of this tradition was found in Tibet and in India. It was an early Buddhist/Induist tradition.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kapala
Possibly the Mongols became Buddhists a long time ago.
A medieval vocabulary of Central Asian Turks is filled with words of Buddhist-Sanskrit origin.
As the Tibetans, Turks and Scythians decorated the skull cup with gold and precious stones.
Throat singing was a kind of Tibetan Buddhist meditation technique. The Mongols later turned this into a national musical tradition.
I think this is the most interesting version of the origin of throat singing and the tradition of making skull cups among mongols and turks.
Tibetan throat singing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIYkgJ183ek
What makes you believe it was all borrowed from Tibet and not other way around?Quote:
Originally Posted by Chelubey
I think this is the most likely version.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarmatian
These 2 traditions are somehow related to Buddhism and Induism, whose roots are in the east .Sakas, Mongols, Huns were influenced by Buddhism.
Buddhism is simplified Hinduism. Hinduism was brought in by Aryans. So the roots are not in the East but in the North.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chelubey
In Europe, this tradition is recorded only in the first millennium BC. This is not a Bronze Age traditionQuote:
Originally Posted by Sarmatian
https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%98...B8%D0%B7%D0%BCQuote:
Hinduism is one of the Indian religions, which is often described as a combination of religious traditions and philosophical schools that arose on the Indian subcontinent and have common features.
Since when is Europe north of India?Quote:
Originally Posted by Chelubey
Wikipedia? Seriously???Quote:
Originally Posted by Chelubey
Most Z93 is today found in India, Pakistan and Afghanistan so this music does not really fits Z93 which is ultimately anyways from East EuropeQuote:
Originally Posted by Illyrius
He's a troll. Don't pay him any mind.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arhat