Search:

Type: Posts; User: Dr_Maul; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 127 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.38 seconds.

  1. Replies
    20
    Views
    1,826

    There are a handful of Sassanid abna left in...

    There are a handful of Sassanid abna left in yemen, actually yemen's ambassador to tehran Ibrahim Al-Daylami belongs to this tribe, I do not believe that they have affected the country in any...
  2. Replies
    1,423
    Views
    182,012

    haha yeah I felt that

    haha yeah I felt that
  3. Replies
    1,423
    Views
    182,012

    Probably not, although im fairly certain all...

    Probably not, although im fairly certain all Bandaris can speak farsi, they do speak Balochi and Arabic as well which are the 2 sources of their mixed origins for the most part
  4. Replies
    1,423
    Views
    182,012

    Probably not, although im fairly certain all...

    Probably not, although im fairly certain all Bandaris can speak farsi, they do speak Balochi and Arabic as well which are the 2 sources of their mixed origins for the most part
  5. No but currently when it comes to these groups...

    No but currently when it comes to these groups there is 30% Iranian and 70% unknown for the most part, or at most 5% non-Iranian others... that is why it is academic consensus. And I am not here to...
  6. No but currently when it comes to these groups...

    No but currently when it comes to these groups there is 30% Iranian and 70% unknown for the most part, or at most 5% non-Iranian others... that is why it is academic consensus. And I am not here to...
  7. I have no idea about any ethnonyms in Kazakhstan,...

    I have no idea about any ethnonyms in Kazakhstan, but you can read whatever sources they have brought forth here
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saka_language
    Majority rule here is mostly just based...
  8. It is for linguistic, 1 Turkic etymology...

    It is for linguistic, 1 Turkic etymology (probably Proto Turkic or as it says non-Turkic) is nothing compared to entire dictionaries of Scythian derived/related languages aka Saka, Parthian, Alanic,...
  9. Yes, languages can be fluid, especially in the...

    Yes, languages can be fluid, especially in the bronze or iron age and in the steppe as well. Even in the modern day, many Tajiks are just persianize Uzbeks/Turks of some kind and ofc Mongolic Kazakhs...
  10. yes they are generally far. But my point was that...

    yes they are generally far. But my point was that the medieval Turkics samples belonged to those clades, at least some of them.



    Well obviously Andronovo-Sintashta wouldn't be Proto Turkic...
  11. I agree but some parts aren't adding up I think.....

    I agree but some parts aren't adding up I think.. So your theory is
    40-50 Asian 40-50 Steppe and trace amount BMAC (Eastern Scythian profile) = proto Turkic, correct?
    haplos reflecting that,...
  12. Man, this is literally my point. You have pointed...

    Man, this is literally my point. You have pointed out R1a Z2124 as if it is some specific branch, but it is really not that different from just saying "R1a Z93" or just R1a at this point. Z2124 is...
  13. No, I mean that the specific y DNA is found in...

    No, I mean that the specific y DNA is found in those 2 ancient samples. My point is that nowadays subclade is in fact important, because "R1a Z93" means nothing, really. No difference between that...
  14. Well, thats why I am asking what clades you mean...

    Well, thats why I am asking what clades you mean in the first place.. but sure I will go ahead. How about DA89, which is R1a-Y40. He matches with Western Scythians and Ancient India. Lets take a look...
  15. No, not that much. But some clades are less...

    No, not that much. But some clades are less complicated than you might think. Its foolish to think that simply being Z93 can mean anything, considering it is a haplogroup which is widespread and has...
  16. But which clades are you talking about...

    But which clades are you talking about specifically? As I said before most of the Turkic sample R1a belong to unrelated branches, unlike Q or J2a.
  17. Well both of these have their own problems so I...

    Well both of these have their own problems so I don't think either makes sense
    I obviously don't believe in Asian origin for the reasons I have said in past few messages.
    Scytho-Siberians to Turks...
  18. Only Turkics who have C belong to genuine Mongol...

    Only Turkics who have C belong to genuine Mongol tribes for the most part, so no surprises there
    But you again missed my point, that the Slab grave only fits GENETICALLY (you say it fits in...
  19. Slab Grave doesn't make sense because it would...

    Slab Grave doesn't make sense because it would mean nearly 0% continuity. Partial discontinuity is obviously expected of a group as widespread as Turkics, but in the case of Slab grave it would mean...
  20. It doesn't make sense for the J to be assimilated...

    It doesn't make sense for the J to be assimilated Iranics. If anything, the R1 in Medieval Turkics are assimilated Iranics because 1/3 of them are under 30% Mongoloid (some basically 0%) whereas all...
  21. Can't comment on linguistics but it would have...

    Can't comment on linguistics but it would have odd implications on Turkic assimilation if proven, making the vast majority of Medieval and modern Turkics not descended paternally by Proto-Turkics
  22. Replies
    3,682
    Views
    337,330

    Almost but there are some things ;) Please...

    Almost but there are some things ;)

    Please also delete Iranian_Persian_Shiraz and Iranian_Fars (Not Iranian_Persian_Fars which I posted) As well as their Individuals and please post the...
  23. Thread: Jews 31% R1b??

    by Dr_Maul
    Replies
    96
    Views
    11,047

    Yes most likely they seem correlating with...

    Yes most likely they seem correlating with Mitanni, Hittites, possibly Kassites/Gutians (if they were IE or not, not confirmed) but I think most of Levant R1 (R1a definitely) is more Iron age. But...
  24. Thread: Jews 31% R1b??

    by Dr_Maul
    Replies
    96
    Views
    11,047

    I would find it extremely unlikely to think that...

    I would find it extremely unlikely to think that lineage being under Germanic U106 was anywhere in the Middle East prior to the middle ages
  25. Thread: Jews 31% R1b??

    by Dr_Maul
    Replies
    96
    Views
    11,047

    Well these 2 branches of Z2103 seem Jewish and...

    Well these 2 branches of Z2103 seem Jewish and the upstream is more or less NW Asian (NW Asian lineages being fairly typical in the Levant since Iron age)
    https://www.yfull.com/tree/R-BY13830/...
Results 1 to 25 of 3158
Page 1 of 127 1 2 3 4