Search:

Type: Posts; User: Fantomas; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 36 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.34 seconds.

  1. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    I don't think so. However, Halstatt noble centers...

    I don't think so. However, Halstatt noble centers system was short-lived experience and were wiped out by new waves of invasions from west. Nothing is known about their poltical power, except it was...
  2. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    We are talking here about pre-historic period of...

    We are talking here about pre-historic period of late Bronze Age. The earliest textual information about Celts is the 6 century BC And we don't know anything about their political unity for the...
  3. Not exactly. Taking extreme examples is not...

    Not exactly. Taking extreme examples is not representative enough. But if you take cumulative C.I. from that work, for example of Cordeds it'd be 72.4 and for Meds it is 76.7. And more to the point,...
  4. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Yes, CONTINUED spread, not began, with the Late...

    Yes, CONTINUED spread, not began, with the Late BA, and where exactly there's previous unity we don't know, there can be just suggested scenarios


    Once again, because there's no Halstatt culture...
  5. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    You have not read that book. just like anything...

    You have not read that book. just like anything about Atlantic core zone. There're constant contacts for thousands of years. since late Neolithic up to Late Bronze Age forming actually one contact...
  6. Replies
    419
    Views
    20,798

    Despite that it was one of the first democratic...

    Despite that it was one of the first democratic experiences in history, you can't argue that these 'sacred texts' do work not so bad even today, especially. Current not the best place in...
  7. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Allright, i've seen your arguments....

    Allright, i've seen your arguments. Proto-Germanic language that developed for 1000 years, covered whole northern Europe (Nordic Bronze Age) and divided by sea is absolutely par for the course for...
  8. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Then, how proto-Germanic before splitting around...

    Then, how proto-Germanic before splitting around 500 BC was managed to develope in Northern Europe all that time? If only you have got alternative theory of speedy occupations of all Northern Europe...
  9. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Proto-Germanic language originated for just one...

    Proto-Germanic language originated for just one century?!:confused: I think you get process formation of languages incorrectly. Language doesn't just happen from nothing, it evolves long time, many...
  10. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Proto-Germanic, possibly, broke away from...

    Proto-Germanic, possibly, broke away from Italo-Celtic, but very early and had been in close contacts with Baltic for a very long time.
  11. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Yeah, Halstatt looke like multicultural...

    Yeah, Halstatt looke like multicultural supranational culture based on trading river system, mineral extraction and prestigious goods. They willingly took new foreign ideas, prestige metal works...
  12. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    1. Correct me if i wrong, evolution of Germanic...

    1. Correct me if i wrong, evolution of Germanic languages has very similar history with Proto-Celtic, if Jastorf and Nordic Bronze Age cultures are associated with it. From Corded ware culture to...
  13. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    This trend documents gene flow into Iberia...

    This trend documents
    gene flow into Iberia during the Late Bronze
    Age or Early Iron Age, possibly associated with
    the introduction of the Urnfield tradition (18).
    Unlike in Central or Northern...
  14. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    https://i.imgur.com/eI7AWzo.png...

    https://i.imgur.com/eI7AWzo.png
    https://i.imgur.com/53gnOh3.png

    Celtic language (Gaulish) had first contact wirh proto-Germanic at very late time, already in Iron Age
  15. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Very interesting, i am at full attention. How...

    Very interesting, i am at full attention. How Gaulish, Iberian, British and easpecially Irish were impacted in Iron Age by Central European. Are you going by genetics here, or maybe archaeological,...
  16. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    :eek: You'll might be very surprised, but it's...

    :eek: You'll might be very surprised, but it's not contradict to the west-east Celtic expansion as well. Rather argues in favour of it because of distribution of patrilineal DNA in Europe
  17. Replies
    419
    Views
    20,798

    Wars is valid excuse and possibly the main reason...

    Wars is valid excuse and possibly the main reason to explain why some Europeans hate Americans so much
  18. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    It's not known what pigmentation has this type,...

    It's not known what pigmentation has this type, but very similar to highly reduced Borreby, western European type
  19. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Everything that you've said does not contradict...

    Everything that you've said does not contradict west-east expansion


    :eek: No, Romans and Greeks gave very clear explanations who were the Celts
  20. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    What exact ancient DNA dismantled it? So...

    What exact ancient DNA dismantled it?

    So standing as opposition 'Central European theory' made more sense?
  21. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    That's right, ancient chroniclers described Celts...

    That's right, ancient chroniclers described Celts as different in terms of appearance, some of them as clearly Mediterranids another as Nordoid, but mostly as somwhere in between, lighter than...
  22. Replies
    345
    Views
    37,736

    Hypothesis of Central European Celtic homeland is...

    Hypothesis of Central European Celtic homeland is outdated completely

    https://i.imgur.com/ozUhAAn.png
    The Ancient Celts 2nd Edition.2018. Barry Cunliffe


    This seems fairly reasonable, all of...
  23. Replies
    419
    Views
    20,798

    It's absolutely normal inherent dialectic and...

    It's absolutely normal inherent dialectic and contradiction, declare the war is a too serious decision for people to categorically say yes, especially when it's not concerns their country directly, ...
  24. Replies
    419
    Views
    20,798

    Being practically a home front for Allies means...

    Being practically a home front for Allies means to participate in war, people cannot fail to understand it, declaration of war become just a formality in this case. Sending troops to war is a last...
  25. Replies
    419
    Views
    20,798

    He called himself so. And he's supporting...

    He called himself so. And he's supporting isolationism. Isn't it traditional conservative characteristic? Neocons for active foreign policy
Results 1 to 25 of 898
Page 1 of 36 1 2 3 4