Independent federal Transilvania?

[Antimage]

Is there a difference between Hungarian from Hungry and the ones from Transylvania or Between Romanians from the other parts of Romania and the ones from Transylvania?

Hungarians in transylvania speak the a same dialect as the ones in hungary, they use some words that we don't but that's about it. Phenotypically they are similar too. Romanians in transylvania are lighter than the ones in south romania who are quite mediterranean looking

Romanians from transylvania don't want independent state.

[Jehan]

So there aren't any reason to see an independant transylvania. Except if the hungarian minority want to not be a part of romania.

[Antimage]

So there aren't any reason to see an independant transylvania. Except if the hungarian minority want to not be a part of romania.

yes.

[blogen]

Hungarians in transylvania speak the a same dialect as the ones in hungary

The Hungarian dialects:

[Zmey Gorynych]

Won't happen. Hungarians can dream but that's what it will always be - a dream. My feeling is that hungarians wont get even autonomy.

The Hungarian dialects:

Still mutualy understandable though or not?

[Antimage]

The Hungarian dialects:

the differences between these "dialects" are very small, almost non existent. I understand everything hungarians from romania say without any effort. I don't consider them to have a different dialect.

[blogen]

Still mutualy understandable though or not?

The dialects in the Hungarian language is only a scientific cathegory, since these are very small differencies (99% similar vocalbulary, sounds, etc.). Every Hungarian clearly understand an other Hungarian.

[Antimage]

Still mutualy understandable though or not?

yes.

[blogen]

the differences between these "dialects" are very small, almost non existent. I understand everything hungarians from romania say without any effort. I don't consider them to have a different dialect.

The dialects is a scientific category, where the subjectivity is not a factor. There is lot of differencies between these dialects, but these differencies are not basic differencies in the language. For example the word onto a thing. There is lot of words in a language onto a thing and some dialect used one from them and an another is an another, but all of the speakers know all of the words, so this is not problem for the understanding.

This is why you do not see the punctual size of these differencies.

[alfieb]

No. Transylvania is Romania.