Independent federal Transilvania?

**~~Antimage~~** · 12-23-2014, 11:15 AM

Originally Posted by blogen

The dialects is a scientific category, where the subjectivity is not a factor. There is lot of differencies between these dialects, but these differencies are not basic differencies in the language. For example the word onto a thing. There is lot of words in a language onto a thing and some dialect used one from them and an another is an another, but all of the speakers know all of the words, so this is not problem for the understanding.

This is why you do not see the punctual size of these differencies.

all i am saying is that the differences between dialects are small compared to other languages. South germans have troubles understanding north germans. Western slovakians have troubles understanding eastern slovaks etc. such things don't exist in hungary(and the hungarian populations that live in surrounding countries). As you said, every hungarian speak understand every other hungarian speaker easily, no matter where they come from

**blogen** · 12-23-2014, 11:20 AM

Originally Posted by alfieb

No. Transylvania is Romania.

You Africans do not understand the Eurasian things.

**blogen** · 12-23-2014, 11:43 AM

Originally Posted by illes93

all i am saying is that the differences between dialects are small compared to other languages.

This is not true. Only the vocabulary of the common Hungarian language as bridge of the understandig is the differency, because of the small geographical area where the Hungarian speakers live. The acoustic differencies are similar huge for example.

**fenix978** · 12-23-2014, 08:40 PM

Originally Posted by alfieb

No. Transylvania is Romania.

Transylvania is historically Hungarian land. Before Turkish conquest the Romanian population in Transylvania was negligible in comparison to Hungarians and Germans.