1
Some of my qualms might seem a bit specific and strange, but they derive from an experience I had that put me on the spiritual path and which I cannot disbelieve in. Some problems I have are the idea that the spirit of man is entirely created and time-bound, that animal souls dissolve at death, that there are only two possible postmortem paths, i.e. eternal heaven or eternal hell, that God is separate from his creation (I'm a monist/Neoplatonist, etc.), that man cannot be saved through his own efforts (the need for priestly intervention), that liberation is entirely postmortem (the judgement of God at the end of time rather than the ability to obtain liberation in this life), the idea of divine linear time, i.e. one single creation and one final destruction (I believe in cyclical time), and so on. As you can see, philosophically it's impossible for me to be a Christian despite my love of old Western Christian culture (medieval culture primarily.)
Those are the big issues. I also cannot accept the God of the Old Testament, the idea of the Hebrews being God's specially chosen people, or the idea that all non-Christians must be converted and that the religion of my pre-Christian ancestors was evil, demonic, etc. On a social/ethnic/political plane, I also cannot accept what I previously mentioned, namely the universalism which would prefer an ethnic replacement of non-Christian Europeans by non-European Christians.
So I certainly am sympathetic to neo-pagans. Unfortunately I think 99% of it is LARPing that won't lead anywhere, but again it needn't be that way.
Bookmarks