Is France a LATIN or truly a strong GERMANO-CELTIC-ROMANCE country?

[Robocop]

I think this is much more accurate question of thread/poll for country such as France.

Because France have really strong Nordish element in Northern-Eastern part of France and Eastern in general, and Celto-Romance/Latin element in rest of the country.

Sure, France is Romance speaking country, but even in French language there is much influence of Gaul (Celtic) element, as well as some Germanic words, but overall it is Romance language.

There is no doubt that France is by linguistc Romance language, but Celto-Germanic component of France is so strong that it cannot be just overlooked.

Sure, Spain also have Iberian, Celto-Iberian, Romance and VisiGothic element.

Italy have more than strong Langobard (Germanic) element in Northern Italy and they are still present there (Romanized) as Italians ofcourse.

But France is truly a 100% HYBRID of Germanic-Celtic-Romance combination IMO, and this is coming from me who loves everything Romance/Latin, so I have no reason what so ever to "invent stuff" for France. What do you think?

And also vote.

[Robocop]

I decided to place here various genetical maps so that we can see French genetical structure as well.

GERMANIC Y-DNA (I2-M223, R1a-Z284, R1b-U106, and R1b-L238) MAP:




The Northwest European Autosomal DNA MAP, representing essentially the Italic, Celtic and Germanic branches:

[Styrian Mujo]

Well France is large and unique enough to form it's own seperate identity from both the Celto-Germanic and the Roman-Mediterranean world..well the coast is def. part of the later though.

[AphroditeWorshiper]

France is a beautiful CELTIC country

with Germanic and Latin influences

Vercingetorix is a true hero of French people!

[Lightshade25]

God, this again?

[Robocop]

God, this again?

Yeah, but with better and more transparent & realistic choices for voting

[Bezprym]

Yes.

[MellowD]

Yes.

I second this.

[Rethel]

Robocop,
you gave a wonderfull example, that putting some group of people into one
category is sensless, becasue they are from different categories, and this is
the thing which should be differentiated....

There are Celts, Germans, Romans, Slavs, even OE and newcommers.

But per definition it is a Roman country with celtic population created by Germans.

[Cristiano viejo]

France is Africa, let be realistic.