Haplogroup E1b, Nigger or West Eurasian?

[Kazbolat]

Do you think haplgogroup E is West Eurasian originally? It peaks in Northeast Africa and Greece and North Africa.

Were E carriers originally West Eurasian or Subsaharan?

[Rethel]

Both and neither.

E is, the same as all hg from Iraq, and as
descendats of Ham settled in the Levant
and North Africa. Does Bantu E1b was at
the beginning swarthy or black maybe can
be a matter of debate, but, probably don't
and today is almost exclusively black, so it
doesn;t matter anyway.

[Sacrificed Ram]

DE (YAP+) is syrian in origin.

[Kazbolat]

Both and neither.

E is, the same as all hg from Iraq, and as
descendats of Ham settled in the Levant
and North Africa. Does Bantu E1b was at
the beginning swarthy or black maybe can
be a matter of debate, but, probably don't
and today is almost exclusively black, so it
doesn;t matter anyway.

Well Natufians were E1b carriers and they were closer to Basal Eurasians. Haplogroup E was dominant in SW Asia before CHG related Haplogroup J fucked them all in Bronze Age

[babuk]

Basal Eurasian

[Kazbolat]

Basal Eurasian

and were basal eurasians closer to africans or modern west eurasians?

[Sacrificed Ram]

E1b (E-P2) has origin in Ethiopia or Somalia.

[Lek]

E1b is Negroid as much as R1a is Indian

[Sacrificed Ram]

We cannot flee from Africa, is no sense preocupation about E1b, but none preocupation about A1b.

[Kazbolat]

E1b is Negroid as much as R1a is Indian

well not a fair comparison. we know that haplogroup E is Basal Eurasian and Basal Eurasians were not really "West Eurasian", they just played a role in formation of West Eurasians. The same goes for haplogroup R, they were North Eurasians and contributed to West Eurasian gene pool